BLU-RAY/DVD REVIEWS

003581Reviews & Counting
SEARCH BY TITLE # A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z
Bobby
DVD disk
Apr 19, 2007 By: Jason Adams
Bobby order
Director:
Emilio Estevez

Actors:
Everyone

Rating:
Movie:
Extras:
Overall:

star Printer-Friendly version
comment
WHAT'S IT ABOUT?
June 4, 1968. The Ambassador Hotel in Los Angeles is the bustling campaign headquarters for Presidential Primary candidate Robert F. Kennedy. As hotel staff and political supporters prepare for his arrival, the lives of a select few cross paths, ultimately culminating in a tragic assassination.

Then, almost 40 years later, Emilio Estevez will spend two hours of your time kissing RFKs ass.
IS IT A GOOD MOVIE?
Anthony Hopkins, William H. Macy, Sharon Stone, Lindsay Lohan, Elijah Wood, Harry Belafonte, Laurence Fishburne, Demi Moore, Heather Graham, Helen Hunt, Martin Sheen, Joshua Jackson, Ashton Kutcher, Shia LeBeouf, Nick Canon, Emilio Estevez, Freddy Rodriguez and Christian Slater.

If theres a reason youre curious about watching BOBBY, its probably the fact that the above people all star in it. The cast assembled is indeed legendary but the way in which theyre used ultimately renders them, and the film, pointless.

You can feel Emilio Estevez reaching for an Oscar in every frame of BOBBY. All the ingredients are there: intersecting stories rooted in a historical tragedy involving race relations, politics and people overcoming obstacles. (Haha, CRASH, you only had racism!) To Estevezs credit, it sounds good in theory (or when previously done in Robert Altmans NASHVILLE) and he does a great job recreating the look and feel of the 1960s, but unfortunately the story comes together as a jumbled mess.

Right from the get go were presented with footage of Kennedy speaking, the Vietnam War, Martin Luther Kings assassinationEstevez obviously wants to make some sort of grand statement. But is the movie a love letter to the life and ideals of the fallen senator? A blatant parallel to our current state of war and politics? A commentary on the historical progress of civil rights? I couldnt tell you because Estevez never tells us. For all its high-minded lecturing, BOBBY suffers from the same problem I had with the similarly constructed CRASHit points out all these obvious (however unfortunate) truths about people and pretends like its discovered something revolutionary. For example, theres a character whose sole purpose is to every 30 seconds yell Im discriminated against because Im Mexican! Well, youre right! There was racism in the 1960s. Annnnnd

I attribute BOBBYs problems to the fact that theres just way too much going on. With over ten different storylines at play and with so many people involved, every character is reduced to minutes of screentime. Theres the hotel workers, the kitchen staff, the reporters, the political pundits, hippies, students, celebritiesall of whom need to have their individual stories set up and resolved in two hours. So when Helen Hunt and Martin Sheen have an extended conversation about shoes or Demi Moore gets drunk and starts comparing the feminine mystique to a Twinkie, it feels like were just wasting precious time waiting until the assassination. When the film finally reaches its climax, the aftermath has a few powerful moments, but it lingers too longmostly because it has to show how each of the 20+ characters is affected. And the only person I really cared about was Freddy Rodriguezs kitchen worker, and thats only because we spend the most time with his character.

I dont feel like I got much out of BOBBY; no better understanding of Kennedy or what he stood for, no background on his assassination, no new lessons about the politically charged era, and no great insight in to these characters. It also doesnt help that each of the films subplots has been done to death (extramarital affairs, racism, alcoholism, coming of age). As Estevez presents it, the only way BOBBY could work would be as a four hour movie, and I dont think Id particularly want to watch that either.
THE EXTRAS
Only two extras, but both are quality.

BOBBY: The Making of an American Epic (28:15): Estevez talks about how this is a personal, long gestating project for him and most of the cast also gets time in front of the camera to discuss their connection to the film. Theres some additional segments from various crew and more interestingly, historians on Bobby Kennedy himself. All in all, a thorough extra.

Eyewitness Accounts from the Ambassador Hotel (29:13): A panel of witnesses to RFKs assassination each discuss what they remember about that night. Its a nice complement to the film, which gives some insight in to the titular man (something the movie itself is strangely lacking).

Theatrical Trailer, too.
FINAL DIAGNOSIS
If somebody had sat Emilio Estevez down and told him, Dude, you dont need to have all these characters just because your friends agreed to be in the movie, BOBBY wouldve been a much better experience. Its a well-meaning film, but a little too self-serving and directionless for my tastes, not to mention a prime example of why having the best cast in the world cant make up for a lackluster script.

Extra Tidbit: Bryan Adams, Mary J. Blige and Aretha Franklin all contributed to the soundtrack.
Strikeback
Not registered? Sign-up!
Or

JoBlo's T-Shirt Shoppe | support our site... Wear Our Gear!