I had read that the first film was originally planned on being a comedy. I think the second tried to capture that original sentiment because they seemed to have thrown in more jokes and more lighthearted themes this time around. Iím actually ok with that, but the comedic feel to the film didnít work well with the over-serious feel the Silver Surfer brought to the franchise. One minute weíre supposed to be laughing at the Thing getting hit by a big rock and the next weíre supposed to cry at the Silver Surfer accepting heíll never see the woman he loves again. It didnít work and the result was a movie that didnít know what it wanted to be.
Iím torn on my feelings about the actors. I think they did a great job casting actors that look like the comic book characters, but for some reason, none of the actors do even a halfway decent job. I realize Jessica Alba is the near perfect woman, physically, but she canít act. Lucky for her, she fits right in with the rest of the cast. On the other hand, the Silver Surfer was pretty cool. The Surfer isnít the most interesting character in Marvel history, but he is one of the coolest looking. Iím pleased to say that they did a great job making the Surfer look life-like and slick.
Superhero films will get sequels as long as they make a slight profit, but Iím surprised FANTASTIC FOUR got one so fast. The first film wasnít very good and the second didnít change anything and therefore failed on the same levels the first one failed. The FANTASTIC FOUR just donít have any chemistry and their stories boring compared to other superheroes.
Commentary with Avi Arad, Don Payne, Peter S. Elliot and William Hoy: The first commentary didnít have enough participants and this one has too many. Iím not a fan of commentaries that are done separately and then spliced together. I like it when everyone is in the same room. Otherwise, you get a dry, sometimes mundane commentary track, such as this one.
There are also some Previews