For starters this is the most repetitive movie I’ve ever seen. Every moment, every line, every supposed “joke” in PHAT GIRLZ is about the main character being overweight. Mo’Nique is not skinny…we get it. It’s been an hour and a half; would you like to talk about something else—preferably something entertaining? As expected, the filmmakers still try to pack in an obvious moral lesson with one of the most unbelievable love stories since Michael Jackson and Lisa Marie Presley frenched on live TV. Mo’Nique finds a rich, muscular doctor who falls in love with her because he’s from Nigeria and apparently over there they too have the stereotype that black men like “thick” women. And through his selfless love, Mo’Nique literally changes the world for all plus-sized women. I have an idea…if you want to be accepted for who you are, the best way is to not go around yelling at everybody about your weight.
More importantly though, for a comedy PHAT GIRLZ is devoid of any laughs. (There’s a restaurant called Fatassburger! OMG ROTFL!!1! ) I think the majority of the humor was supposed to be derived from Ms. Nique being loud and assertive to her enemies (i.e. everyone), but I found it more terrifying than funny.
There’s a reason this is #7 on the IMDB Bottom 100. And that reason is intense sucking.
Commentary by director Nnegest Likké: If there was a film that didn’t need a commentary, it was PHAT GIRLZ. Example comment: “When you love yourself, nothing can stop you. Here, Dick tries to hate on her and stop her and she’s all like…’No, not this time!’” It’s obvious Likké is ecstatic just to get the chance to make a movie, and I hate to tear apart a first time filmmaker’s debut, but I have to call it like I see it.
Deleted Scenes: This extra should be about two hours long and comprise the entire movie. What it actually is is ten scenes, most featuring Mo’Nique “riffing.”
The Phattest Guy: A Tribute To Producer Bobby Newmeyer: A nice homage to a man who obviously felt passion for his projects. (Newmeyer mortgaged his house to make PHAT GIRLZ.)
Bloopers: Nothing worthwhile here, unless you want to catch a glimpse of Mo’Nique’s panties. (Sadly, I bet this just convinced some people to watch PHAT GIRLZ.)
Super Size Dreams: Likké’s Video Diaries: From her personal footage, you can tell Likké tries hard and means well with her first feature film; it just didn’t turn out that way.
The Reel Deal: The Making of PHAT GIRLS: Some interviews to reinforce the film’s message, in case you couldn’t guess it from the cover.
Also, a Theatrical Trailer.