BLU-RAY/DVD REVIEWS

003566Reviews & Counting
SEARCH BY TITLE # A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z
Valkyrie (2-Disc)
BLU-RAY disk
Jun 19, 2009 By: Mathew Plale
Valkyrie (2-Disc) order download
Director:
Bryan Singer

Actors:
Tom Cruise
Bill Nighy
Tom Wilkinson

Rating:
Movie:
Extras:
Overall:

star Printer-Friendly version
comment
WHAT'S IT ABOUT?
A dramatization of the July 20th, 1944 plot to assassinate Adolf Hitler and take Berlin.
IS IT A GOOD MOVIE?
Operation Valkyrie, the codas text tells us, was the last of 15 known plots to assassinate Hitler. But movies for the other 14 may never be made, if not just for the fact that none of their key conspirators resembled a movie star. But because Tom Cruise, that ravishing old thespian, is a ringer for Colonel Claus von Stauffenberg, here is Valkyrie.

And how brave of Cruise to portray a disfigured Nazi hunter who, after his mission fails, dies like a martyr at the bullet of former associates. And how brave of Bryan Singer to tackle a WWII-set thriller-epic (about the attempt on the life of one of historys most evil men, no less) to prove his worth to critics after spending the last decade solely on superhero movies. If the cast and crew make it easy on themselves here (and they do), at least their historic/big screen counterparts put on a show.

The plot, which remained widely unknown until United Artists backed the production, was to be carried out on July 20th, 1944. The goals: take Berlin, assassinate the Fhrer, and negotiate a truce with the Allies.

Valkyrie, despite what I may have suggested in the earlier paragraphs, offers many thrills and is, after its two hours exhaust themselves, a fine attempt at bringing an important event in history to audiences attention. Its not intended to shed any new light on Hitler (portrayed with a stony presence--because how else do you do it?--by David Bamber)--he will always be a monster--but to put a light on forgotten heroes.

Quotes seem--if not necessary--suitable. Thats how the conspirators of the coup are portrayed here: not as treasonous rats, but as determined patriots, tired of Hitler putting a bad face on their sacred Germany. Yes, Hitler Bad, Resistance Good, but cant we make up our own minds on what makes a hero?

Among the plotters are: Major General Henning von Tresckow (Kenneth Branagh), whose attempt to explode the Fhrers plane are thwarted due to a faulty detonator; General Friedrich Ulbricht (Bill Nighy), who brings Stauffenberg onboard; General Friedrich Fromm (Tom Wilkinson), the only conflicted of the bunch; and General Erich Fallible (Eddie Izzard, not terribly funny here), brought in to sever communication lines at the Wolfs Lair.

All of the men give strong, sympathetic (almost to a fault--see above) performances, donning the Nazi garb less as costumes than as uniforms. And its because of them (and not as much Bryan Singer or writers Christopher McQuarrie and Nathan Alexander) that the film, despite our knowing the outcome of Operation Valkyrie, is often tight and tense.
THE EXTRAS
Disc One:

Commentaries: The first with Tom Cruise, Director/Producer Bryan Singer, and Co-Writer/Producer Christopher McQuarrie, and the second with McQuarrie and Co-Writer Nathan Alexander both rely on chemistry throughout their runtimes and are merely adequate. Youll get more from the following features:

The Journey to Valkyrie (HD; 15:56) gathers various cast and crew members to discuss how they came onboard the project and to give an overview of Valkyrie from script to screen. On-set footage is included.

The Road to Resistance (HD; 9:08): Colonel Claus von Stauffenbergs grandson, Philipp von Schulthess (who was seen in the previous featurette), serves up a biography while taking viewers on a personal tour of numerous locations important to his grandfathers life.

The African Front Sequence (HD; 7:01) takes a look at the filming of the opening sequence, where von Stauffenberg is wounded after an air attack.

Taking to the Air (HD; 7:32) is a neat addition that look at the various airplanes used throughout the film, made all the better by comments from coordinators and on-set footage of the cast/crews excitement during test runs.

Recreating Berlin (HD; 6:51) offers a brief look at the production design of Berlin.

Reel Pieces with Tom Cruise and Bryan Singer (SD; 38:56): This episode, filmed at New York Citys 92nd Street Y center, sits the star down with his director to discuss Valkyrie and the history behind it. It runs a bit long, but there is a lot of great information thrown about.

The Valkyrie Legacy (HD; 1:54:15): This Kevin Burns-directed (Star Wars: The Legacy Revealed) documentary is as comprehensive as history buffs would want it and is unquestionably the best addition to the disc. Interviewees include experts, July 20th 1944 plot conspirators, and more. A terrific companion piece that outshines the film.

Disc Two:

The sole extra here is the Digital Copy.
FINAL DIAGNOSIS
Valkyrie is an awfully safe picture for Bryan Singer and Tom Cruise to take on, considering what their careers need. There are many suspenseful moments throughout, but not nearly enough to put audiences where they should be: on the edge of their seats.

The bonus material (sans the commentaries) are all worthwhile for fans, who should have no reason to skip this Blu-ray, which also boasts very good transfers.
Strikeback
Not registered? Sign-up!
Or

JoBlo's T-Shirt Shoppe | support our site... Wear Our Gear!