I think the biggest mistake with the film is with the basic philosophy on the film. Chris Carter wanted to go backwards and make a standalone film that told a story. He abandoned the running drama and conspiracy storyline that had made the series so popular. If he had focused on the conspiracy stories and fixed some of the wrongs the last two seasons committed, I think they would have had an easier time getting fans back in the theaters. Instead, we didnít have a reason to catch up with Scully and Mulder because theyíve basically been living a normal life since the series finale. If we had picked up the end-of-the-world scenario and alien conspiracies, I think fans would have been more excited about seeing their favorite FBI agents.
As it was, the movie was very reminiscent of the first couple of seasons of the show with a horror-esque storyline that starts and stops with the movie. This was great when the show started, but as the show evolved, the stories got more complex and intricate, each time peeling back a layer from our heroes. This film did not do that. So in essence, the film took a major leap backward and the progression that the series made was lost in hopes of telling a scary story. Unfortunately, the story itself is average at best and wasnít enough to carry the film.
But itís not all completely disappointing. X-Files fans get a glimpse into the personal lives of Scully and Mulder, which is a welcomed treat for those of us that have been with them since the beginning. Their witty dialogue shines through at times and makes for some nice, nostalgic moments that hark back to the showís heyday. Even though the film didnít wow me, I enjoyed watching Scully and Mulder together again. Theyíre two of my favorite TV characters of all time and it was nice to give them a better ending than what they got during the series finale.
Deleted Scenes (5:53): For a split second, I thought they were going to mention Scullyís baby and I got super excited, then they didnít and I got dissappointed again. There are three scenes, all of which further (slightly) the story. Theyír okay, but nothing special.
Trust No One: Can the X-Files Remain a Secret? (86:01): Everything you wanted to know about this film, and more. This is good if you donít know all the drama that went on with Fox and the X-Files. Basically, they wanted to make the movie around season 9, but contract hiccups and other problems made it impossible. They touch a lot on the security around the set, but they couldíve used some more publicity and this made me think that their efforts to be secret hindered their word of mouth publicity. But this long featurette is pretty good and a must see for fans of the series.
Chris Carter: Statement on Green Production (6:16): Chris talks about the lengths he and Fox went to in order to make the production environmentally friendly. Iím big on recycling, so I appreciate their efforts. Iím not sure we needed a separate featurette talking about it, but we got one.
Body Parts: Special Makeup Effects (8:12): The effects guys stand by a pile of fake, dead bodies and talk about what they did to make them and when they were used. Itís pretty interesting for effects people, but Iím not sure it was environmentally friendlyÖ
Gag Reel (9:49): Most gag reels are pretty typical, but every now and again, you get some cool actors who are just fun to watch, no matter what theyíre doing. Duchovny and Anderson are two of those actors. Theyíre great together and it was nice anytime they were onscreen. Good times.
Agent Dakota Whitneyís Files (BD-Live) (31:28): These are readable ďfilesĒ that mainly contain brief bios on characters in the film. It allows you to post messages that others can read and things like that. Meh, itís okay, but I wanted more behind-the-scenes type stuff and wasnít really in the mood to type my thoughts about specific characters from the movie.
In-Movie Features: If you select this, you have the option of pressing certain buttons on your remote that will take you to various features. I watched it for a little while, but Iím not a huge fan of this feature. Iíd rather have them come up effortlessly while the movie plays.
Complete X-Files History: This is probably the best feature on the disc. It goes through every single episode and shows a clip from each one along with a detailed, written description. You can go through the entire series one episode at a time without changing discs. Very, very, very cool.
There are some Previews and a Music Video set to images