Jason/Michael
06-09-2008, 09:06 PM
Ok I'm sure there have been dozens of posts about the ending to this movie, but I searched and I did not see any recent ones. When I first saw it, I figured the whole movie, except for the 1st and last scenes, were Marie's alibi (hence her sitting in a room with a camera and asking "are they recording?" in the very beginning). I then realized that this is not plausible because why would she reveal the truth of the story at the end of her alibi?
I then realized that the story had to do with split-personality disorder. I think the biggest clue leading to this conclusion is when Marie is in her room and after she realized that jack behind the dresser is a TV outlet, she leans back in disappointment and looks at doll with crack down the middle of its face. That cracked doll is a symbol of Marie having a split personality.
So now the motives. Maire kills Alex's family so that "nothing can come between them anymore" out of either love or an extremely unhealthy friendship. Maybe Marie's killing spree is catalyzed by Alex's prank of leaving her in the cornfields towards the beginning of the movie. I don't think that's likely but it's just a thought.
Just to mention 1 scene in its "reality" context, Marie kills the mother and while she's lying on the ground, Marie's personality switches so she runs into the closet in fear. She then walks out in disbelief (you can see a trail of blood from the body to the closet doors, which is a clue) and the movie goes on.
Can anybody tell me if I'm on the right track here, or maybe you would like to give me your explanation. I would just like to add that the scene where the "man" is sexually abusing the decapitated head does not make sense at all because that cannot be Marie since she is still in the car with Alex. Maybe that was put in to throw the audience off, or to set the tone, or to give the audience a preview of how sick this "guy" really is. All thoughts are appreciated!
I then realized that the story had to do with split-personality disorder. I think the biggest clue leading to this conclusion is when Marie is in her room and after she realized that jack behind the dresser is a TV outlet, she leans back in disappointment and looks at doll with crack down the middle of its face. That cracked doll is a symbol of Marie having a split personality.
So now the motives. Maire kills Alex's family so that "nothing can come between them anymore" out of either love or an extremely unhealthy friendship. Maybe Marie's killing spree is catalyzed by Alex's prank of leaving her in the cornfields towards the beginning of the movie. I don't think that's likely but it's just a thought.
Just to mention 1 scene in its "reality" context, Marie kills the mother and while she's lying on the ground, Marie's personality switches so she runs into the closet in fear. She then walks out in disbelief (you can see a trail of blood from the body to the closet doors, which is a clue) and the movie goes on.
Can anybody tell me if I'm on the right track here, or maybe you would like to give me your explanation. I would just like to add that the scene where the "man" is sexually abusing the decapitated head does not make sense at all because that cannot be Marie since she is still in the car with Alex. Maybe that was put in to throw the audience off, or to set the tone, or to give the audience a preview of how sick this "guy" really is. All thoughts are appreciated!