PDA

View Full Version : (VIDEO) "Carlito's Way" (10/10)


Brock Landers
12-15-2000, 03:46 PM
"Carlito's Way" A Brock Landers Overview of Brock Landers' Favorite Film from Director Brian De Palma (10/10)

"Carlito's Way" is the story of Carlito Brigante (Al Pacino), a former drug kingpin out of Spanish Harlem, New York City. Carlito is sprung from a long prison term by his cokehead attorney, played with wild spontaneity and brilliant energy by Sean Penn (great, great, great performance…there, I've said it three times, Tyler Durden-style). Carlito swears to himself…and everybody else, that he is finally going straight, heading to the islands and starting up a car rental agency. Most everyone who knows Carlito, knows that he won't follow through on this plan. But Carlito is convinced he can follow through and he's quite dedicated to his dream. Of course, it's sort of hard for Carlito, when these friends of his keep introducing elements that he really doesn't need in his life. Besides the ill-advised association with Sean Penn's character, Carlito has Luis Guzman (Maurice T. Rodriguez in "Boogie Nights") playing his right hand man who's only in it for the cash…and loyalty is secondary to the green stuff. There's also the over-the-top "Benny Blanco from the Bronx" (John Leguizamo…another good performance from the "Summer Of Sam" veteran) who represents the old Carlito, an analogy Carlito himself doesn't seem to recognize…or at least refuses to. Carlito would sooner smack Benny in the face and send him head long down a flight of stairs, than sit with him and share a glass of champagne. The one redeeming thing in Carlito's life is his ex-girlfriend (Penelope Ann Miller…she was great in 'The Freshman")…an aspiring dancer currently working in strip clubs…and hey bras, that's dancin' in my book…the best kind…dig? Carlito puts his sunglasses on and keeps moving forward, never minding the bloody family reunion (great scene by the way…"You think you're big time? You gonna' die big time!") he has with his young cousin, doublecrossing business associates, or the apocalyptic mob hit operated by his attorney. He heads towards his goal of making a legit seventy-five grand by operating a Latin disco (hence Luis Guzman runs a disco in 'Boogie Nights")…and he almost makes it too. But no, there can't be a happy ending for Carlito…there never is, for his type. The film opens with his assassination, and the following movie is just the random thoughts of a dying man, so it's not giving anything away to say Carlito is a dead man walking thoughout the film. I still like to think that the doctors do find "all the stitches in the world" and sew him back together again. It's just that I really dig Carlito…I mean, it's like I feel that I know him and what he is trying to accomplish…what his struggle is all about, and I feel compassion towards him at the end. Sometimes I think about Carlito walking on the beaches of his tropical island in an unseen epilogue…

Brian De Palma turns the camera into another player in his personal worlds. You can never simply watch a De Palma film…you live it…even if just for a few hours. I am writing this as someone who isn't a giant fan of a lot of De Palma's films. I find some of his films to be mediocre and derivative…but "Carlito's Way" is something else entirely…because one of the true talents De Palma has as an artist, is his appreciation of characters…it also helps that he gets really great writers to create some of his characters…and that he get's the world's greatest character actors to bring them to life (once again, Penn and Pacino are out-fuckin'-standing). "Carlito's Way" is De Palma's greatest film…combining a wonderful script, great camera work and one of the finest casts he's ever assembled (the exception being "The Untouchables"). If you are a collector of great films like I am, than this film is a must have. It is a true masterpiece…

(Note: Viggo Mortenson appears in a small wheelchaired role…Sean Penn brought him to the attention of Brian De Palma since they have known each other for a long time and were good friends…Viggo Mortenson also appeared in Sean Penn's directorial debut "The Indian Runner" with David Morse, Charles Bronson and a great cast of many…One of my favorite films about brothers…one is a cop, one is an outlaw…based on the Steve Earle song "The Highway Patrolman"…Steve Earle also wrote and performed the song "Ellis Unit One" in "Dead Man Walking"…and is about as close to a true rebel you will ever meet…)

(DVD Note: the film transfer is flawless…the colors are vivid and pure…the neon and rain shots are the best…the sound is bad-ass, just listen to the gunshots echo and ring and the scenes in the disco with the swirling beats…great shite…P.S. not really any extras…I don't think De Palma does commentaries…ever…still a kick-ass flick…)


[This message has been edited by Brock Landers (edited 12-15-2000).]

Jon Lap
12-15-2000, 05:40 PM
Youuu. You got a gift my friend.

Where the fuck were you when I was in NYU fighting with pretentious little cock-sucks who tried to convince me that this film was majorly flawed, and get this... was run amok, or gone awry with "contrived shot choices." -- of all the fucking things!

It took me too long to wipe the bubblegum-stickiness of "guilt" off my shoe, after I named "Carlito's Way" 9th on my "Top 10 of the 90s List" because of these jerk-off's.

In any case, the viewing experience of this film is like watching a bullet-proof window catch a fired-hollowpoint, as you stand behind the glass, facing the shooter.

Aside from the exhilirating introspective-action-ride this film provides, the gritty realism of "soldier-work" [in Mob-related cartels] is wonderfully breath taking to watch. So many times you get the most local kid from Brooklyn attempting to make his semi-autobiographical "crime" drama (i.e. "One Deadly Road"), and they fail miserably. "Carlito's Way" is based on the true story of a spanish gangster, "Spanish Ray." It's not really public knowledge... I've never read it anywhere, and never heard De Palma mention any such fact... but I've heard from reliable "family" sources (if you get my drift). De Palma does everything with this film in terms of finding the perfect balance between resonance, evocation, and making a smart film. Like you said with "Scarface" (it's second act is severely flawed), and like many of his other ventures, they too are schoolyard pebbles, trying to be sold as jewels. (You mentioned "Untouchables"... and I have serious problems with this film that I won't get into now. I take it that you like the film).

In any case, just like Dorothy "knew she wasn't in Kansas anymore", now I know I'm rambling. A few more comments though:

Penn helps cinch his place on the top of my Actors Under 40 List with this performance (and obviously others that followed, like "Dead Man Walking" and "Sweet And LowDown" and actually thought he was brilliant in "Hugo Pool"). Pacino is incredible to, with as many one-liners and quotable phrases as "Goodfellas"...

CARLITO:
(TO BENNY BLANCO)
"what, you think you like me? You aint like me motherfucker. You a punk. I been wit made people. Connected people. Who you been with? Chain-snatching, jive-ass, mardicone motherfuckers. (snickers) Go on. Get outta hea. Go snatch a purse."

BENNY:
"There's no problem, no problem. I'll just take Stephie, and we go."

CARLITO:
(with defiance) - "Stephie belongs to the club."

BENNY:
"I think Stephie's making a big fucking mistake..." (he goes to grab Stephie). (Kleinfeld pulls his gun on Benny's face).

DAVE KLEINFELD:
(devilish and credulous grin) "Huh?! How does it feel... how does it feel."

MOMENTS LATER IN CARLITO'S OFFICE...

DAVE KLEINFELD:
(TO CARLITO)
(coked up enough to try and hide his anxious-fear) "Tell me he's in a coffin... tell me he's in a fucking coffin."

These lines and many more not only bring the ulimate in social mimesis... but also provide 2 hours of solid entertainment, and one of the best films of the 90s. And a great soundtrack, and side performances (as you mentioned).

Sorry for writing so much, but if you had any idea how much more I could have written... you'd thank me.

Jon


[This message has been edited by Jon Lap (edited 12-15-2000).]

Brock Landers
12-15-2000, 05:59 PM
It's nice to see I'm not the only schmoe to like this flick...I have not made a top 10 list of the 90's, but if I did make a top 10 list of the 90's, this would be near the top of my top 10 list of the 90's...

by the way, I can't stand watching "The Untouchables"...it's garbage, I was just remarking on the great cast of actors...not the quality of the film...

Jon Lap
12-15-2000, 06:22 PM
Phewww! Glad you don't like "The Untouchables" because I respect your opinion's, and finding out such a fact would have digressed me to the days of such innocence-losing moments as finding out there's no Santa Claus... or even worse, realizing who your parents really are (heh).

lata

Brock Landers
12-17-2000, 10:05 PM
I watched "Carlito's Way" AGAIN this weekend and was once again stunned by the great performances and De Palma's camera work...the more I see Penelope Ann Miller, the more I dig her. Penn was phenomenal as always and I really dig Pacino with a beard...Guzman is one of the most steadfast character actors around and John Leguizamo is always full of energy and enthusiastic performances...I just love this film and the people in it...damn, I'm becoming a fanboy...what is the world coming to?

JoBlo
02-08-2001, 04:24 AM
<moderator bump>

Schilachi
02-08-2001, 03:26 PM
YES! some positive recogintion for Carlito's Way.
In my opinion, this is very under-rated movie. Apart from my own mouth and on this message board, the film never seems to get much said about it. Just glad im not alone in thinking this movie is class.

Brock Landers
02-08-2001, 03:36 PM
"Carlito's Way" is another reminder of how much it will suck if Sean Penn gives up acting to become a full-time director...which he has been discussing recently...

Tuukka
02-10-2001, 01:19 PM
Hey, Untouchables is a great film! One of the best films of it's genre. Sure, it's extremely cliched and lacks a deeper meaning, but it still works wonderfully on all levels. Superb acting, stunning visuals, fine music, great direction and a very well written script.

The script is cliched, but it also has very good dialogue, good characters and great structure. I love what Mamet did with the script, he took all the traditional cliches and archetype characters and managed to make them better than ever before... In my eyes Untouchables is a perfect popcorn film. It succeeds brilliantly in everyhing it tries to achieve.

8/10.

SAI
02-15-2002, 08:13 AM
Carlito's Way is the best. The absolute best film I have ever seen.

The first time I saw it I only caught the last 15 minutes on TV, so impressed was I that I found out the title of the film and spent the next six months tracking it down on video.

Thank God I did. From first frame to last Carlito's Way holds your attention. I love everything about it. The plot structure is ingenious, showing Carlito getting shot in the opening introduces a tension into the film as to when this occurs, as the film progresses you come to like Carlito and root for him and this tension grows.

The last twenty minutes of this film are the very best Brian De Palma has shot. As we follow Carlito's attempt to escape the camera and editing are fluid, providing constant motion in the visuals as well as the story, every time I see it I still want him to get on that train and am still choked up when he doesn't.

This is down to the performances of Al Pacino and Penelope Ann Miller, we all know that Pacino is one of the greatest living actors and so his superlative performance as Carlito was to be expected, it is Miller who is the surprise. To go from the role of token female in Kindergarten Cop to this was a huge challenge and is one she pulls off. She makes Gail a very sympathetic character, which gives us a reason not just to root for Carlito but for THEM. This is why the ending remains so affecting.

The whole cast is fine but you have to single out Sean Penn, he is almost unrecognisable as Klienfeld and I could not imagine anyone else in the role.

Since I first saw the whole film five years ago Carlito's Way has been my favourite film, to anyone who has not seen it, I urge you stop reading this rambling nonsense and go rent it.

Carlito's Way 10/10
I wish I could give a higher score