PDA

View Full Version : Who Is Harry Kellerman and Why Is He Saying Those Terrible Things About Me? (8/10)


Irene Manor
02-26-2002, 10:46 AM
Predating the recent slew of movies containing twist endings, changing perspectives, and twisted narration by 30 years, Who Is Harry Kellerman and Why Is He Saying Those Terrible Things About Me? was very much ahead of its time. It is the story of Geroge, a famous rock musician, played by Dustin Hoffman, who is living in NYC and has the world in the palm of his hands. This is until a character named Harry Kellerman shows up into his life and starts to change that. Kellerman has been calling women that George is sleeping with, and telling them that their boyfriend is a scoundrel. A completely evil person who has no friends, and violent tendancies. George is going nuts over this.

George spends much time speaking with his psychiatrist, played by Jack Ward doing a very exagerrated Freud. As Geroge starts to deteriorate through out the movie, he begins seeing the psychatrist appear in other forms and as different characters: Santa Claus, A cab driver, a street vendor, and so forth. Of course this all may or may not be a figment of George's derranged mind. His shrink has no qualms about telling him, "You must accept the fact that you are a bird. A complete and utter looney bird."

One thing a particularly liked about this flick was the surrealism of it all. This was made in 1971, and even atop of the normal psychedelia of the era, the film went a step further and disjoined the scenes, shifted from 1st to 3rd person POV, constantly altered the settings/time, and constantly makes the viewer question how much is real. I got a kick out all this because, like I mentioned earlier, this sort of stuff seems so standard nowadays.

The acting all around was magnificent. I never showed any interest in Jack Warden before, but here he raised my brow. This film also features a young, slimmed-down Dom Deluise, with out his usual chubby guy silliness, as Geroge's friend/accountant. A great scene in the movie comes while Geroge, who has been awake for 4 days (You listening Fight Club fans?), calls the accountant to talk to him at 3 in the morning. Geroge visits with him and insists, as the accountants highest paid client, that he be read the entire yearly budget in bedtime story form. Weird, but worth it.

This movie may seemed dated for some viewers, but it is a strong film. The psychedelia fits the story perfectly, and never seems out of place in George's dream-like life. There are multiple near-suicide scenes that have enough manic energy to light the countries state mental wards.

As the movie progressed, I became more and more part of the story, almost feeling George's insanity being passed on to me. This movie holds some traces of Vonnegut abound, but holds the energy of a rock and roll movie. It is very funny in most parts, but the real treat is the, well, I guess I use the word trippiness of the whole thing.

I recommend this movie to anyone who gets a kick out of Monty Python, Yellow Submarine, The Trip, or any of those other, well I'll say it again, trippy movies. If it isn't you scene, this movie may not do it for you, but then again, everyone turns on somewhere.

Fergus
03-17-2002, 01:24 AM
I took your recommendation Irene, and stuck it in the back of my mind when you first posted this review. I got my hands on the movie and watched it 3 days ago. The case to the movie said it was a comedy, but it wasn't really, I don't think I laughed once, except at Jack Warden's hilarious accent, and the different characters he becomes while George is "somewhere else." About a half of an hour into it, I had already guessed who Harry Kellerman was, and I was right, no surprise there, but this movie was just a series of recollections, and kept me wondering what would happen next. One of the quickest two hours I've ever had with an old movie. At times it did make sense, at times I was a little confused. For example, the skiing at the end, I didn't get it, and when I saw the credits I was a little dumbfounded.

Compared to today's mind trips, this one is pretty tame, and I did feel a little used to the technique. But it entertained me, even when not much was happening. There are a few scenes. Like when he is recalling that memory about the "girl with red hair", his first love or something like that. That first scene where we meet her is a tad slow, but I was so into the movie that I didn't realize it till later. Also, the scene where George is watching the audition, and the girl gets stuck on stage and doesn't want to move, that was slow, but I didn't mind. Nothing in it bored me at all, it is like watching a dream where you never know what will happen next. Something pops up here, a recollection here and there. Stuff like that. I almost gave it a lower rating after it finished, and was going to say the movie was a "muddled mess", but I changed my mind. I'd rate it the same as you. **** stars or 8/10. I do remember one part, the very opening scene where Hoffman is deciding whether to jump or not, then sits on the ledge and changes his note. The note blows away and his impulse is to movie after it, and he ends up falling. I laughed my butt off, but that was one of the few parts. I also wanted to compliment you on your review, well done. [applause]

Irene Manor
03-19-2002, 07:44 AM
I'm glad you liked it. I think it's a cool movie.

You are right about that openning scene. In fact, if this was something I had started watching after that scene, I may not have been that into it. That clip set the mood perfectly, and it also reminded me alot of The Big Lebowski, because of the way he was falling vs. the way Lebowski flew.

I also agree about this being tamer than recent movies of a simiar nature. It definiately takes on a lighter tone, mostly due to the intended comedy.

All-in-all, I'm glad you dug it too, Fergus.

Now, I'm off to go spread some rumours about your violent tendancies. http://www.joblo.com/ubb/smile.gif