FAVORITE AND LEAST FAVORITE COMIC BOOK TURNED INTO A MOVIE

[Prairiedogking]

We all know that most comic books that get turned into movies suck, although there are a few that somehow end up being an awesome flick. My question to you is what is your favorite and least favorite movie based off a comic book.

[A.J. Hakari]

Best: "X-Men"

Worst: "Judge Dredd" (ugh..."ADRIAAAN! I AM THE LAW!!!")

[the night watchman]

Best: "X-Men" followed closely by "The Crow" and "Superman (I & II)"

Worst: "Captain America"

[Caleb]

Best is Batman Returns for me.
Worst is Batman and Robin.
The new best will soon be Ghostworld when it comes out.

[fllatt]

what's Ghostworld? is that a sequel to the Westworld and Futureworld?

Anyway, best of my picks...

X-men, of course
Batman
Blade
Superman 1&2
I hope Spider-man kicks ass!

worst...

The Punisher, why did they make that movie with Dolph and no freakin way was that movie like the comic.

Captain America..ditto for above

other news..i hear they are making a fantastic four and hulk movie.. does anyone know anything else about this..project statis in limbo?

[Prairiedogking]

Here are, in my opinion, the goodies

BATMAN (1989)
BATMAN: MASK OF THE PHANTASM
BATMAN RETURNS
BATMAN: RETURN OF THE JOKER
BLADE
X-MEN
SUPERMAN
SUPERMAN 2
TEENAGE MUTANT NINJA TURTLES (What?)

The sucky are....
TEENAGE MUTANT NINJA TURTLES 3
BATMAN AND ROBIN
PUNISHER
JUDGE DREDD
And that's just a few for the moment

[the night watchman]

Hey, Prairiedogking, I'm there with you on "TMNT." I just wish they hadn't kidified it, and had left it the violent and funny satire the series was meant to be.

[This message has been edited by the night watchman (edited 12-21-2000).]

[Snert]

Best: X-men

Worst: Batman Returns

[Prairiedogking]

Oh come on Snert. BATMAN RETURNS wasn't all that bad. It's better than BATMAN FOREVER and a hell of a lot better than the horror that is BATMAN AND ROBIN.

[Candyman]

Best: Blade + The Crow
worst: Batman & Robin (both the 1990's version and the 1960's)

[Kal]

Worst most definitely Captain America, especially as i was eating something that looked far too much like Red when he came on........UGGGGGHHHHHHHHH!

[This message has been edited by Kal (edited 01-01-2001).]

[Venom127]

The best comic book movie of all time (not counting the upcoming Spider-Man film) has to be X-Men. Besides the amazing special effects, it had an actual story, whereas most comic movies are just non-stop fighting.

And the award for all-time worst comic book movie goes to...it's a tie between The Punisher and Batman And Robin! What were they thinking when they made those pieces of crap?!

[raphroehler]

Best: TMNT 1&2, Superman, Blade, (I'm sure Spiderman will join this list)

Worst: Batman and Robin, Captain America, Superman IV

[Corpse Candle]

Here we go:

Best:
Crow

Worst:
Dr strange

Also look out for the new HULK film (my favourite comic character) it is directed by ANG LEE.