PDA

View Full Version : D'Onofrio sues Madonna and Guy Ritchie


JoBlo
10-08-2002, 11:19 PM
Poor Madonnass...it's bad enough that she just tainted her husband's spotless filmography thus far (I saw SWEPT AWAY last night and it was one of the worst experiences that I've had all year), but now actor Vincent D'Onofrio is suing her ass for apparently stealing his idea for the film's remake. Fun times! (got story from Yahoo! Movies (http://movies.yahoo.com/news/va/20021008/103413830600.html))

Judge won't halt Madonna film for actor's lawsuit

"A Los Angeles judge refused Tuesday to halt release this week of the film "Swept Away," starring Madonna ( news - web sites) and directed by her husband, Guy Ritchie ( news), despite last-minute claims by another actor that the project was his idea.

But an attorney for Vincent D'Onofrio, who starred opposite Jennifer Lopez ( news) in "The Cell" said the actor would press forward with his lawsuit against Madonna, Ritchie and Sony Pictures Entertainment over the film.

Though "Swept Away" is a remake of a 1974 Italian movie of the same name, D'Onofrio claims in his Los Angeles Superior Court lawsuit that it was his idea to produce it again with Madonna in the leading role.

Representatives for Sony Pictures and Madonna could not be reached for comment.

"They used his idea and they didn't want to compensate him," D'Onofrio's lawyer, Morris Getzels, said after a hearing in Los Angeles Superior Court.

Getzels said D'Onofrio asked Judge David Yaffe to issue a preliminary injunction stopping the Friday release of "Swept Away" unless Madonna, Ritchie and Sony gave him a producer credit. But Yaffe refused.

Getzels said that D'Onofrio was not the first person to sue seeking credit for a remake, citing what he said was a similar case brought against the actors Elizabeth Taylor ( news) and Richard Burton over a film version of "The Taming of the Shrew"

"Almost every newspaper article about 'Swept Away' starts with the question of where did the idea come from to remake this film," Getzels said. "And the idea came from my client."

Getzels said D'Onofrio first approached Lina Wertmuller -- who wrote and directed the original -- about making the romantic comedy again with Madonna as the star, and Wertmuller "got all excited about it."

Madonna, through her representatives, also was "very enthusiastic" about the film, the attorney said. But in the spring of 2001, Getzels said, D'Onofrio learned that Madonna was making the movie without him.

"He hired lawyers and has been trying to persuade Madonna to settle, but they won't do anything for him," he said.

Madonna stars in "Swept Away" as a wealthy U.S. woman who becomes stranded on a Greek island with an Italian fisherman, played by Adriano Giannini, and falls in love. Ritchie is credited as the film's screenwriter and director. Reuters/Variety"

Buck Turgidson
10-09-2002, 01:44 AM
Y'know...I really adore Vince. I've made the case over the last few years, here and elsewhere, that he's one of the very best American actors in his age group.

I know he stands to make a lot of scratch off of this, but why in God's name would anyone, especially a guy a self-evidently smart as he is, want to claim credit for this...idea.

If Guy's smart, they'll settle and then try to blame the gathering debacle all on Vince :D

A.J. Hakari
10-09-2002, 03:59 PM
Originally posted by Buck Turgidson

If Guy's smart, they'll settle and then try to blame the gathering debacle all on Vince :D

My thoughts exactly. If all the crap I'm hearing about the film is true, Guy should be glad Vincent wants his idea back. He can have it. :)

darkface
10-09-2002, 05:27 PM
They should come to a settlement, and if Guy is smart enough he'll tell Vince that he gets all of the profit from the movie :D
-which will end up like a total $2 bucks

The Postmaster General
10-09-2002, 06:40 PM
sounds to me like Vince doesn't have much ground to walk on.

unless he has some hard evidence like a contract, or something more legal binding than, "I talked about that same idea" no court of law is going to back him up (see the Harry Potter debacle)


more free legal advice from BubbaStrangelove - law school dropout since 1994

FeydRautha
10-09-2002, 07:16 PM
I really feel for poor Vince, but I don't think he has a legal leg to stand on. The real tragedy is, he has more artistic talent in his little finger than Madonna has in her whole body.

If memory serves, however, this wouldn't be the first time Madonna's nicked someone else's idea for her own benefit.

Tom Samborski
10-09-2002, 08:36 PM
Go Vince! He CAN act, and NOT get Razzies unlike Madonna.

Jason Voorhees
10-10-2002, 03:39 AM
I hear that the Vincent D'onofrio in question is not the actor: but rather someone else entirely...

JoBlo
10-10-2002, 04:01 AM
Yup, apparently the YAHOO article is wrong. It's not ACTOR Vincent D'Onofrio...it's PRODUCER Vincent D'Onofrio.

Don't ask.

Here's what the IMDB reported:

Producer Sues Madonna, Says He Felt 'Swept Away'

Producer Vincent D'Onofrio has filed suit against Madonna and her husband, Guy Ritchie, claiming that he brought the idea for a remake of Lina Wertmüller's Swept Away to her in April 1997 and had several meetings about it with her CAA agents before she and Ritchie went on to make the movie on their own. On Tuesday, a Los Angeles judge blocked D'Onofrio's attempt to have the release of Swept Away held up until after the case comes to trial. Nevertheless, the producer's lawyer told today's (Wednesday) New York Post, "We're still going to seek a credit and seek damages." D'Onofrio described himself as "a singer, songwriter, actor, director, writer and producer" and has worked in the entertainment industry since 1965. Various news outlets had erroneously reported that the suit was brought by actor Vincent D'Onofrio (Full Metal Jacket, Steal This Movie, The Dangerous Life of Altar Boys); the actor's publicist quickly issued a statement Wednesday that he had no relation to the lawsuit.

Scarface98.9
10-10-2002, 05:11 PM
Full Metal Jacket D'Onofrio or not, I don't see what he can gain from this since it'll bomb critically and financially

FeydRautha
10-10-2002, 11:56 PM
Originally posted by Scarface98.9
Full Metal Jacket D'Onofrio or not, I don't see what he can gain from this since it'll bomb critically and financially

I agree, but I think what he's going for is recognition for coming up with the idea. Last I heard, he's suing for a producer's credit as well as financial restitution.

I don't see him having any luck, as oral or "handshake" agreements don't carry much weight in Hollywood. Anyone remember Jennifer Lynch's "Boxing Helena"? Kim Basinger was slated to play Helena, but backed out at the last minute and cost the production valuable $$$. Lynch's production company sued her successfully, but the decision was later turned over on appeal and the amount Basinger had to pay greatly reduced.

I think Mr. D'Onofrio should count himself lucky his name wasn't attached to this bomb in the first place...