Fight Club Vs Memento

[heretic]

Me and a fellow friend are having a debate about which is the better film can you please give us an answear before I beat his face with my fist!

[VicVega]

Memento (9/10)
Fight Club (8.5/10)

[charliebobo]

Fight Club 7/10 slightly better
Memento 7/10

[Cosimo]

I really couldnt prioritise one over the other.Two of the greatest movies of all time though.

Fight Club-9/10
Memento-9/10

[Puck Bond]

Fight Club(1999)-10/10...a modern masterpiece!
Memento(2001)-9/10...great but flawed and overrated.

[Nate6]

Originally posted by Puck Bond
Fight Club(1999)-10/10...a modern masterpiece!
Memento(2001)-9/10...great but flawed and overrated.

I agree with every word of that.

[POLYDISTORTION]

Tough question damn! ,since i love both the same, i wont vote.

Fight Club (10/10)

Memento (10/10)

[Moviefan1234]

"Fight Club"

[Black Mage]

Well, I loved Fight Club (9.5/10), but Memento (10/10) is hands down the best movie I've ever seen, so I've got to go with Memento over Fight Club.

[LAW]

You need not look further than over to the left <<<<<<.

[Cyclonus]

I'd have to go with Fight Club (9/10). Memento was good, but after only watching it once, I really don't want to give it a proper rating just yet, probably 7/10.

[mrdeeds]

Memento hands down. I think the story and directing was absolutely brilliant. Even the movie's concept beats the pants off of Fight Club.

[idealdiscountdude]

Definetly Fight Club (A-)

I find Memento to be good, but way overrated. (B)

[screamer581]

Fight Club 10/10
Memento 9/10

Both great films, but Fight Club is the better film.

[The Delfonics]

Memento has its moments, but its allll Fight Club in this one

[Moviebuff]

Memento is the better film. It has brilliant directing and great performances!

[Scarface98.9]

I'd say Memento. Even though FC was good, I think it's somewhat overrated, while I absolutely love Memento

[MikeyB]

Fight Club 8.5/10
Memento 8/10

[Razorblade Smile]

I usually rank films based upon their re-watchability. In this case, it comes down to the replay value of two modern marvels. Ultimately there's really only one choice.

I can't tell you what that is though, because the first rule is that no one is supposed to talk about it.
;)

[Dude]

Fight Club