Fight Club vs. Pulp Fiction.

[The Delfonics]

Ok ive seen the Memento pole but this one is between two heavyweights. I pick Fight Club (10/10) and Pulp Fiction which is still an awesome movie at (8.5/10)

[BakeTheMooCow]

Man, that's like making someone choose between his sons. Both are 10/10s for me, both in my top 10.

But Pulp Fiction is better overall.

[Grebdron]

Pulp Fiction (10/10) is far better, IMO. Fight Club (8/10) was good, but I can't buy into the greatness everybody seems to see.

[ec_winton]

Its no contest--Pulp Fiction. Fight Club is in my top ten list of the most highly overrated movies....

[Gregorious8]

I liked Pulp Fiction a little more

[Black Mage]

See, now I never really got into Pulp Fiction. I mean, sure, it was a cool movie and all, and fun to watch, but I thought Reservoir Dogs was so much better, and, I dunno, Pulp Fiction just didn't seem to click for me like it seemed to for many, many others. So, yeah, Fight Club wins.

[VicVega]

Please tell me you are joking with this poll. We both know which is the bettter movie.

Pulp Fiction all the way. :D

[El Bracamonti]

they're both incredible films, but my vote goes to pulp fiction.

[The Delfonics]

Originally posted by VicVega
Please tell me you are joking with this poll. We both know which is the bettter movie.

ya Fight Club :)

[VicVega]

Shouldn't you be in school right now, Mr. Delfonics??

[Sugar_Kane]

I love them both but I prefer Pulp Fiction.

[ColinM]

Both are great, but Pulp Fiction is far better.

[The Delfonics]

Originally posted by VicVega
Shouldn't you be in school right now, Mr. Delfonics??

Was about to come in but i fell asleep to long!

[Puck Bond]

Pulp Fiction-10/10
Fight Club-10/10

Both are great, but Pulp Fiction is a landmark film that had more of an impact on film.

[Moviefan1234]

"Fight Club"

[MikeyB]

Fight Club is great but I think Pulp Fiction is a better overall movie.

[Dude]

Fight Club is good... but Pulp Fiction is Freekin Cool... as if this needed to be asked. :p

[Nate6]

If matched up against almost any other movie, Fight Club would win. But against Pulp Fiction, it doesn't even come close.

[MickeyKnox]

Fight Club and Pulp Fiction for me no competition they are both on the same level!

[darkface]

Both great movies. But i love Tyler Durden's character the best... and more one liners.

[Shockwave]

Fight Club for pretty much the same reasons. Pulp is still pretty high up there for me but Fight Club just had more meaning i thought.

pulp fiction 10/10
fight club 10/10

[Hucksta G]

Fight Club (10/10)
Pulp Fiction (8/10)

[KornKidJedi]

Pulp Fiction will always be My favorite film of all time. but PF is better than Fight Club. Fight Club will always be an awesome flick.

[SubMethod]

Pulp Fiction(8/10) even though it has its flaws is so much better than the mediocre Fight Club(5/10), which I think to be the most overrated film of all time.

[the ooze]

fight club fight club fight club....honestly, who picks a pulp fiction?

yeah pulp is high up there but its not jacks awesome movie!
word.

[bowieee]

Fight club

but it was a really tough call

[Clarkey07]

Fight Club got my vote.

[RickySlade]

Pulp Fiction 10/10
Fight Club 7/10

[Cyclonus]

Both are great (9/10) but my vote goes to Fight Club.

[Raoul Duke]

Fight Club was awesome.

But Pulp Fiction was just better for me, more fun.

[zeppelin]

I love Fight Club, but Pulp Fiction is far superior.

[DaMovieMan]

PULP FICTION (10/10) of course cannot touch FIGHT CLUB (9/10).

DMM

[Hannibal21]

PULP FICTION. Amazing direction, hip dialogue, great editing, memorable sequences and excellent performances makes this a 10/10 in my book.

[ohsocrazy]

Fight Club 9/10
Pulp Fiction 7/10

P.S... i dont think i "understood" Pulp Fiction. i just thought it was a comedy with lots of violence and drugs. can someone please explain the movie to me.

[edgeofhell]

Originally posted by Grebdron
Pulp Fiction (10/10) is far better, IMO. Fight Club (8/10) was good, but I can't buy into the greatness everybody seems to see.

I agree with you 100%.. took the words right outa my mouth

[jenna25]

I voted for Fight Club(favorite movie of all time... so far), but I do love them both. Samuel L. Jackson was brilliant in Pulp Fiction. But really out of Tarantino's work, I prefer Reservoir Dogs over Pulp Fiction( though I will grudgingly admit that the latter is the better movie overall). So it wasn't really a hard choice, if it was between Fight Club and Reservoir Dogs, that would have thrown me a bit...

:D :rolleyes:

[Sad man]

PULP FICTION and FIGHT CLUB are both 8/10.But I enjoyed PULP a bit more.

[QUENTIN]

Fight Club is a great movie, no doubt, but c'mon now, Pulp Fiction is like THE movie, it's ahead by miles, my all-time favorite.

[sharkstank]

pulp fiction---10/10
fight club---9/10

both are amazing,but pulp fiction is a masterpiece to me.better overall movie

[therealjohng]

This is not even a contest. Fight Club is no where near the realm that is PULP FICTION.

PF: 10/10
FC:7/10

[therealjohng]

Originally posted by darkface
Both great movies. But i love Tyler Durden's character the best... and more one liners.

There are ten times more 1 liners in PF than in FC.

[KillerKlown]

Pulp Fiction, as it brought 'The Gimp' to the world! ;)

[The Delfonics]

Originally posted by therealjohng
There are ten times more 1 liners in PF than in FC.

Ya but they are no where near as good as Fight Clubs

[Brock-Landers]

PULP FICTION!!!!!

[Neesh]

Originally posted by therealjohng
There are ten times more 1 liners in PF than in FC.

Thats a bold statement.

[bob]

I like Fight Club a lot more. I find it more intelligent, funnier, and a lot less tedious to watch.