Best of filmmaker KEVIN SMITH?

[dh1989]

http://us.ent4.yimg.com/movies.yahoo.com/images/hv/photo/movie_pix/dimension_films/jay_and_silent_bob_strike_back/_group_photos/jason_mewes1.jpg

Kevin Smith seems to be one of the most cherished directors on this message board, but which of his classic films is your personal favorite? Here is my ranking for them....

1.) CHASING AMY (10/10)
2.) DOGMA (10/10)
3.) JAY & SILENT BOB STRIKE BACK (8/10)
4.) CLERKS (8/10)
5.) MALLRATS (6/10)

Average Rating: 8/10

So I am quite a big fan of him, and I cannot wait until JERSEY GIRL comes out! Please vote.

[The Claw]

Clerks was the best, but I thought all of his films were good.

[boo]

definatly Chasing Amy

Chasing Amy 10/10
Dogma 8/10
JASBSB 8/10
Clerks 7/10
Mallrats 6/10

[Puck Bond]

Clerks-9/10
Dogma-8/10
Mallrats-8/10
Chasing Amy-7/10
Jay and Silent Bob Strike Back-7/10

[blankpage]

It may sound like I don't have any taste but I think Jay and Silent Bob Strike Back is my favourite. Probably tied with JASBSB is Clerks.

But, he is one of my favourite writer/director's.

[bob]

I think Mallrats is the one I watch the most, but Dogma is his most complete film.

[Hucksta G]

Jay and Silent Bob Strike Back is my favourite.

Jay and Silent Bob Strike Back (9/10)
Dogma (8/10)
Clerks (8/10)

Mallrats and Chasing Amy I both have to see again.

[Scarface98.9]

Clerks. I'm one of the few one the board who thinks Chasing Amy was his worst, and Clerks was his best

[bankholdup]

Chasing Amy - 10/10
Clerks - 9/10
Mallrats - 8/10
Jay and Silent Bob Strike Back - 7/10
Dogma - 5/10 at best

[Ren Hoek]

Wow, a lot of 10/10s around here :eek: I like most of his films but I'm not such a huge fan:

1.) CHASING AMY (8/10)
2.) CLERKS (7/10)
3.) DOGMA (6/10)
4.) JAY & SILENT BOB STRIKE BACK (6/10)
5.) MALLRATS (5/10)

[VicVega]

Clerks takes the cake.

[JCLC11]

Mallrats - 8/10

Non-stop laughter!!!

[Jasonite]

I still think Clerks is his best, but Chasing Amy is a pretty close second.

J

[Fisting Ackbar]

CLERKS 9/10
MALLRATS 6/10
CHASING AMY 8/10
DOGMA 7/10
JAY & SILENT BOB STRIKE BACK 7/10

[arto_j]

Chasing Amy (10/10) is still his best work.

[idealdiscountdude]

Easily Chasing Amy!

[blankpage]

My Ratings for his film's....

1) Jay and Silent Bob Strike Back- 9/10
2) Clerks- 9/10
3) Mallrats- 8/10
4) Chasing Amy- 8/10
5) Dogma- 8/10

[MikeyB]

Clerks- 10/10
Dogma- 8/10
Jay and Silent Bob Strike Back- 8/10
Mallrats- 7/10
Chasing Amy- 5/10

[Rob Gordon]

Chasing Amy
Clerks
Dogma
Jay and Silent Bob Strike Back
Mallrats

[Bullet Tooth Tony]

I really like Jay & Silent Bob Strike Back...bout time they had their own movie.

[Mr. Orange]

I love Chasing Amy.

It's his smartest movie. Not his funniest but the dialouge it amazing and the love story is one of the best in recent years.

[eraserhead_99]

1.Mallrats 8.5/10
2.Clerks 8.5/10
3.Chasing Amy 8/10
4.Dogma 7/10
5.J & SB Stike Back! 6.5/10

[SAI]

Amy. By a mile. On my all time top 10.

Ratings:
Clerks 4/5
Mallrats 4/5
Chasing Amy 5/5
Dogma 2/5
Jay And Silent Bob Strike Back 3/5

[BadCoverVersion]

Chasing Amy 9/10
J&SBSB 7.5/10
Dogma 7/10
Clerks 7/10
Mallrats 5.5/10

His films are ALWAYS enjoyable, and J&SBSB is a pure guilty pleasure!!!

[theJeeper]

JASBSB 10/10

MALLRATS 10/10

CLERKS 10/10

CHASING AMY 10/10

HALLOWEEN 4 10/10

[rushmore beauty]

I think Jay and Silent Bob Strike Back (8/10) is his funniest, but Chasing Amy (8/10) is his most mature film.

[MickeyKnox]

Clerks(10/10) ands Dogma(10/10) are his most original movies and they are both excellent!

[neilg78]

1. Clerks
2. Jay & Silent Bob Strikes Back
3. Chasing Amy
4. Mallrats
5. Dogma

[James Logan]

DOGMA's my personal favorite, but they're all great flicks -- there's no denying it.

[Trinity]

1. Chasing Amy 10/10
2. Clerks 9/10
3. Dogma 9/10
4. Jay & Silent Bob 8/10
5. Mallrats 7/10

[ColinM]

1) Clerks (8/10)
2) Dogma (8/10)
3) Jay and Silent Bob Strike Back (8/10)
4) Chasing Amy (7/10) - probably 8, pending a rewatch
5) Mallrats (6/10)

[screamer581]

1.Chasing Amy 10/10
2.Clerks 9/10
3.Dogma 8.5/10
4.Jay And Silent Bob Strike Back 7.5/10
5.Mallrats 5.5/10

[QUENTIN]

1.) Chasing Amy -10/10
2.) Clerks -10/10
3.) Dogma -8.5/10
4.) Jay & Silent Bob Strike Back -8/10
5.) Mallrats -6/10

[Benny]

Clerks is my favorite, with Dogma coming in a close second.

I never loved Chasing Amy as much as others do on these boards.

[The Delfonics]

Clerks - 8.5/10
Mallrats - 8/10
Dogma - 7.5/10
JSBSB - 8/10

[Reagan]

Chasing Amy was the best overall. It was definitely the most emotionally true of his movies. and jason Lee was so damn funny.

[POLYDISTORTION]

1) - Dogma - 9/10
2) - Jay & Silent Bob Strike Back - 8/10
3) - Clerks - 8/10
4) - Chasing Amy - 8/10
5) - Mallrats - 7/10

[Squid Vicious]

I always have a tough time choosing between Dogma and Chasing Amy. I'll go with Dogma for now....

1) Dogma - 9/10
2) Chasing Amy - 9/10
3) Clerks - 9/10
4) Jay and Silent Bob Strike Back - 8/10
5) Mallrats - 6/10

[EBastard]

Me being Christian...Dogma (1999, 10/10) gets my vote.

2. Jay & Silent Bob Strike Back (2001, 8/10)
3.Chasing Amy (1997, 8/10)
4.Mallrats (1995, 7/10)
5.Clerks...haven't seen it yet!

[APzombie]

Being Christian as well, Dogma 10/10. It is also his bravest and most thought-out film to date.

[Grebdron]

Originally posted by Trinity
1. Chasing Amy 10/10
2. Clerks 9/10
3. Dogma 9/10
4. Jay & Silent Bob 8/10
5. Mallrats 7/10

That's pretty much my order, with one exception. The failure that was Mallrats. 5/10

[marz]

Dogma - 10/10
Chasing Amy - 9/10
Clerks - 9/10
Jay &Silent Bob - 8/10
Mallrats - 6/10


For Kevin Smith fans, I highly recommend you see his "An Evening with Kevin Smith" DVD.