American History X VS. Fight Club

[PorcheRacer]

Can you decide? I can't at the moment but I'm leaning towards AHX. Both (10/10)s from me, though.

[Mad Maggot]

Yes, I can - Fight Club. American History X is a brilliant, but not as much as Fight Club.

[VicVega]

American History X

Edward Norton gave steller performances in both, but in the end, AHX had a more powerful message than Fight Club.

[Reigh Kaufman]

I hate to say this, but I am calling it a draw. Wait, shit, no - I disliked one aspect of AHX so the vote goes to...shit, goddamit, I can't do this. It's a draw. I've decided.

[ze424]

American History X 10/10

Fight Club 8/10

[therealjohng]

American History X is a better movie. (8/10)

Fight Club, while good, not as great as everyone makes it out to be. Overrated. (7/10)

[Addi88]

Fight Club

Amerrican History X was great but it's just too depressing to watch over again.

[movies35]

Fight Club 10/10

American History X- NEVER SAW IT!

[idealdiscountdude]

Both are really good films, but American History X is the only one of the two that still lingers in my mind some 5+ years later, so it gets my vote.

[Clarkey07]

American History X - 10/10 - In my top 10 of all time.

Fight Club - 9/10 - Awesome movie, but not as good as AHX

[MickeyKnox]

American History X-(10/10)
Fight Club-9.9/10

[Cole666]

Fight Club - ****/*****
American History X - ***/*****

[QUENTIN]

Both are 9/10's, I think Fight Club is the better movie but AHX features the better Norton performance.

[Scarface98.9]

Fight Club, though I do think the board overrates both movies

[ColinM]

Ditto with Quentin, only I gave American History X and 8/10. Fight Club is better, but Norton is better in AHX.

[The Delfonics]

No contest. Fight Club is easier the better movie. However both movies are stellar.

[rupert pupkin]

tough one...they are both visceral highly enterataining movies

but both are extremely pretentious and have silly endings

hmm i go for fight club

[Hucksta G]

Both 10/10's for me but Fight Clubs my favourite movie so I'm going for Fight Club.

[Squid Vicious]

Originally posted by QUENTIN
I think Fight Club is the better movie but AHX features the better Norton performance.

My thoughts exactly.

[JasonLeeFan]

I thought both were probably some of the best movies I've ever seen, but Fight Club is more of a thrill ride and I like that.

[Hannibal21]

American History X (8/10) - Brilliant, Ed Norton's best performance.

Fight Club (0/10) - I HATE DAVID FINCHER!!!! THE BASTARD. I GIVE EVERY FILM OF HIS A 0/10 EVEN IF THEY ARE GOOD!!!! I WANT TO BLOW FINCHER AWAY WITH A MACHINE GUN!!!!!! I HATE HIM! FIGHT CLUB WAS A GOOD MOVIE, BUT I GIVE IT A 0/10 BECAUSE HE DIRECTED IT. DIE FINCHER DIE!!!!!!!!!! :mad: :mad: ;)

[Lindsey]

Both good film, but American History X is by far one of the best films ever made.

[jenna25]

Fight Club is in my top ten...so I go with it. But Norton's performance in American History X is one of the most powerful I have ever seen.:)

[eraserhead_99]

Thats hard.

Fight Club-10
AHX-10

Ill go with Reigh and say its a draw.

[Brock-Landers]

Fight Club ...but American History X is a great picture.

[Grebdron]

Not even close. Fight Club wasn't bad, but gets far too much praise here.

American History X was simply brilliant.