Best Comic Book Movie

[Ripper1888]

Whats the best comic book movie adaptation so far.

my top five
1.The Crow
2.Blade II
3.Blade
4.From Hell
5.Ghost World

my bottom five
1.Batman and Robin
2.X2
3.Superman IV
4.DareDevil
5.The Hulk

the League of Extrodinary Gentleman looks pretty good and from what I have read and seen Hellboy seems like it is going to kickass the fact that Guillermo del Toro is at the helm is a major plus.

[rushmore beauty]

I voted for The Crow because I love dark and gothic films and this is my favorite superhero film, but I actually like Ghost World more.

[Hannibal21]

The Crow 8/10
Spawn 7/10
Ghost World 9/10
Spider-Man 7/10
Daredevil 8/10
X-Men 8/10
X2 8/10
The Hulk 6/10
Batman 9/10
Superman 9/10
Blade 8/10

'Batman' gets my vote.

[Scarface98.9]

Ghost World, although X2 is a close contender. And am I the only one who noticed it's simply titled X2 and not with the stupid subtitle "X-Men United"?

[Mikey2Dope]

I gave both The Crow and X2 9/10's but in the end my vote goes to The Crow.

[stevereno]

GHOST WORLD Enid Coleslaw is my hero

SHIVER ME TIMBERS

[Moviefan1234]

"Spider-Man," but "Daredevil" is a close second.

[Clarkey07]

I love them all, but gotta go with my fav......


THE HULK

[Brock-Landers]

1. X2 - (10/10)
2. Road to Perdition - (10/10)
3. Superman - (10/10)
4. Batman - (9/10)
5. Spider-Man - (8/10)
6. Blade II - (8/10)
7. X-Men - (8/10)
8. Blade - (7/10)
9. The Crow - (7/10)
10. Ghost World - (7/10)

I can't wait for Spider-Man 2, The Punisher and my fav comic Hellboy they all look amazing!!

[ilovemovies]

1. Daredevil * * * 1/2
2. Batman * * * 1/2
3. Superman * * * 1/2
4. Spider-Man * * * 1/2
5. Superman II * * * 1/2
6. The Rocketeer * * *
7. Batman Forever * * *
8. Blade II * * *
9. X2: Men United * * *
10. Spawn * * *
11. Batman Returns * * *
12. X-Men * * *
13. Blade * * *
14. Hulk * * *
15. The Crow * * *
16. Captain America * * *
17. The Phantom * * *


Special mention to Unbreakable * * * 1/2 out of * * * * which isn't based on a comic book but is a comic book movie. If it was included on the list then it would be #2.

Worst comic book adaptation : Batman & Robin * *

[ilovemovies]

If Road to Perdition counts then it would be #1.

[boo]

Spider-man

Although the first two Superman movies come very close

[bob]

I voted for X2, the only film on that list worth owning.

[syxxpac]

Spider-man

[mrdeeds]

Superman is the best, while my fave is Superman II, as if you dont know !;)

[jmcpher_007]

Spider-man all the way. I don't think any other comic to movie adaptation has been able to completely capture the essence of the main characters as Spider-man did. A lot of people knock it for being corny, but I felt it was perfect.

[Andrew Tom]

Voted for other. Punisher. Why? Because it most definately kicks ass. Now if I just could find an uncut DVD of it...

Well, I do enjoy The Crow more than Punisher, but I just wanted to bring it to the light of day...

[Jasonite]

I'd say Superman over Batman, but only by a hair. *sigh* I wish they'd come out with a decent Batman DVD.....


J

[Living_Dead_Dude]

Being a Burton fan I gotta vote Batman!!

[Masterbrain]

Iam a big fan of Tim Burton, so I voted for BATMAN...

[dh1989]

Daredevil

[Jerk Shapiro]

There are some good movies on that list, but in the end my vote goes to The Crow.

[blankpage]

Ghost World.

A dark and beautiful film.

X2 and X-Men come close....

[eraserhead_99]

The Crow 10/10
Spawn 7/10
Ghost World 10/10 *I voted ghost world
Spiderman 7/10
Daredevil n/a
X-Men 9/10
X-2:X-Men United 9.5/10
Hulk n/a
Batman 8/10
Batman Returns 10/10 much better
Superman 8/10
Blade 8/10

[The Other]

Ghost World overall.

One of the X-Men flicks in terms of "super-hero" comics.

Road to Perdition was a comic book as well (that's not on the list). I thought it was merely okay, but there are others who loved it.

[MickeyKnox]

The Crow-(9.5/10)
Spawn-(5/10)
Ghost World-(9/10)
Spiderman-(7.5/10)
Daredevil-(6/10)
X-Men-(6/10)
X-2:X-Men United-(7.5/10)
Hulk-(8/10)
Batman[Tim Burton]-(8.5/10)
Superman-(9/10)
Blade-(8/10)
Batman Returns-(9/10)
Blade II-(8/10)

[Michael_myers]

You guys are breaking my heart. I voted other because Dick Tracy fucking kicks ass!

[Annie Hall]

Ghost World.

Closely followed by both X-men.

The rest don't even come close.

[El Bracamonti]

other-batman returns, then the hulk

[Tagia_Romero]

The Crow 8/10
Spawn 4/10 *Spawn's cape was kewl though*
Ghost World *not yet seen*
Spiderman 8/10
Daredevil *not yet seen*
X-Men 8.5/10
X-2:X-Men United 9/10
Hulk *not yet seen*
Batman [Tim Burton] 8/10
Batman Returns 8/10
Batman Forever 8.5/10
Batman And Robin 4/10 *if it weren't for the charismatic leads, it would have been TOTAL shite*
Superman 7.5/10
Blade 8/10
Blade II 8.5/10
The Rocketeer 8/10
From Hell 7/10

[bskutle]

"The Crow" is the only one to make my 100 Best Films list.

[therealjohng]

The Crow hands down. The best comic book movie ever made. It has everything that is a comic book. The characters, the atmosphere, the colors. Everything.