Comic Book Movies

[KRGR1428]

Name comic book movies Best (from the top) to worst (the bottom).

DAREDEVIL (10/10)

FROM HELL (9.5/10)

BATMAN RETURNS (9/10)

BATMAN (8/10)

LEAGUE OF EXTRAORDINARY GENTLEMEN (8/10)

BATMAN FOREVER (8/10)

SPIDER-MAN (6/10)

BATMAN RETURNS (2/10)

[Mikey2Dope]

The Crow (9/10)
X2 (9/10)
Batman (8/10)
Batman Returns (8/10)
X-Men (8/10)
Blade (8/10)
From Hell (8/10)
Spider-Man (8/10)
Batman Forever (5/10)
Blade 2 (4/10)
The Punisher (3/10)
Daredevil (3/10)
The Hulk (3/10)
The Avengers (2/10)
Batman and Robin (2/10)

[Scarface98.9]

X2 (9/10)

Ghost World (9/10)

Blade 2 (8.5/10)

From Hell (7.5/10)

Blade (7/10)

LXG (7/10)

Batman Forever (7/10)

The Hulk (6.5/10)

Spider Man (6.5/10)

Batman 1 & 2 (6/10)

[Tom Samborski]

Batman (9/10)
X2: X-Men United (9/10)
Batman Returns (8.5/10)
DareDevil (8.5/10)
X-Men (8/10)
Batman Forever (7/10)
Batman & Robin (4.5/10)

[Cosimo]

Road To Perdition (8/10)
Batman (8/10)
Ghost World (8/10)
Blade (7/10)
The Crow (7/10)
The Hulk (7/10)
X-Men (7/10)

[Clarkey07]

The Hulk - 9/10
Daredevil - 8.5/10
Batman - 8/10
Spider-Man - 8/10
X-Men - 8/10
X2 - 8/10
Batman Returns - 8/10
LXG - 4/10
Batman Forever - 7/10
Batman and Robin - 7/10

[Ripper1888]

Batman 9/10
Batman Returns 9/10
Batman Forever 6/10
Batman and Robin 0/10
Blade 8/10
Blade II 9/10
The Crow 10/10
DareDevil 8/10
From Hell 10/10
Ghost World 8.5/10
The Hulk 2/10
League of Extraordinary Gentleman 5/10
Men in Black 5/10
Men in Black II 3/10
Road to Perdition 10/10
Spawn 7/10
Spiderman 6/10
Superman 4/10
Superman II 3/10
Superman III 3/10
Superman IV 2/10
X-Men 6/10
X2 5/10

[Hucksta G]

Road to Perdition (10/10)
Unbreakable (10/10) *kind of a comic book movie*
The Crow (9/10)
Daredevil (8/10)
Spider-man (8/10)
The Hulk (8/10)
Blade (8/10)
Blade 2 (8/10)
X-Men 2 (8/10)
Batman Returns (7/10)
X-Men (7/10)
Batman & Robin (3/10)

[Strider]

"Batman" (10/10)
"Batman Returns" (9/10)
"Batman Forever" (7/10)
"Batman & Robin" (3/10)
"Superman" (7/10)
"Superman II" (7/10)
"Superman III" (5/10)
"Superman IV: The Quest for Peace" (3/10)
"Blade" (8/10)
"Blade II" (9/10)
"Men In Black" (8/10)
"Men In Black II" (5/10)
"The Fantastic Four" (3/10)
"Captain America" (2/10)
"The Punisher" (4/10)
"Spider-Man" (10/10)
"X-Men" (8/10)
"X2" (8/10)
"Spawn" (5/10)
"Road to Perdition" (10/10)
"Ghost World" (10/10)
"Akira" (8/10)
"The Crow" (6/10)
"The Avengers" (4/10)
"Daredevil" (8/10)
"The Hulk" (5/10)
"The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen" (4/10)

[Hannibal21]

1. Batman Returns - 9/10
2. Batman - 9/10
3. Superman - 9/10
4. Ghost World - 8.5/10
5. Superman II - 8.5/10
6. From Hell - 8.5/10
7. X-Men - 8/10
8. X2 - 8/10
9. Blade - 8/10
10. Daredevil - 8/10

[Frank the Tank]

The Crow 10/10
Blade 2 9.5/10
Blade 9/10
Spider Man 8/10
Men In Black 8/10
Xmen 7.5/10
Batman 7.5/10
Spawn 7/10
Batman Forever 6.5/10
Batman Returns 6/10
Daredevil 5.5/10
Batman And Robin 5/10
LXG 4/10

[boo]

Superman (10/10)
Spider-Man (9/10)
Superman 2 (9/10)
X-Men (9/10)
X2 (9/10)
Batman Returns (8/10)
The Hulk (7/10)
Batman (7/10)
Blade (5/10)
Blade 2 (3/10)
Daredevil (2/10)

[Jon Lyrik]

Batman (10.5/10)
Batman Returns (7/10)
Hulk (6.5/10)
Blade (8/10)
Superman (10.5/10)
Superman II (6.5/10)
The Crow (9/10)
X-Men (5/10)
X2 (8/10)
Batman Forever (0/10)
Batman & Robin (0/10)
Akira (10/10)
Road to Perdition (10/10)
Ghost World (9.5/10)
Spider-Man (9/10)

[Brock-Landers]

X2 - 10/10

Batman - 10/10

Superman II - 9.5/10

Superman - 9/10

Road to Perdition - 9/10

X-Men - 8/10

Blade II - 8/10

Ghost World - 8/10

Spider-Man - 8/10

Batman Returns - 8/10

Blade - 8/10

The Crow - 8/10

The Hulk - 6/10

Superman III - 6/10

From Hell - 6/10

The Mask - 6/10

Batman Forever - 6/10

Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles - 5/10

Men in Black - 5/10

Spawn - 5/10

Men in Black II - 4/10

Superman IV: The Quest for Peace - 4/10

Steel - 3/10

Dick Tracy - 3/10

Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles II - 3/10

LXG - 3/10

Daredevil - 3/10

Judge Dreed - 2/10

Barb Wire - 2/10

The Phantom - 1/10

Batman & Robin - 0/10

[QUENTIN]

1.) Superman -10/10
2.) The Crow -9/10
3.) Ghost World -9/10
4.) Superman II -9/10
5.) Spider-Man -9/10
6.) Dick Tracy -8/10
7.) Batman Returns -7.5/10
8.) The Road To Perdition -7/10
9.) The Rocketeer -7/10
10.) Blade II -7/10

That's my top 10 comic book movies, some others I've seen off the top of my head:

Batman -5/10
Batman Forever -7/10
Batman & Robin -2/10
X-Men -5/10
X2: X-Men United -7/10
Blade -7/10
Fritz The Cat -7/10
Heavy Metal -6/10
Hulk -7/10
Men in Black -4/10
Men in Black 2 -4/10
The Shadow -6/10
Howard The Duck -7/10 (ya heard me...I like this movie, it's wonderful camp...c'mon Caroline in the City sleeping with a duck alien who fights Ferris Bueller's principal)
Judge Dredd -3/10
Steel -2/10
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles 2: The Secret of The Ooze
Superman III
Superman IV: The Quest for Peace (both TMNT and latter Superman films are unratable for me, I haven't seen any of them in a good 8-10 years, but loved them as a kid)
Spawn -4/10
The Mask -5/10
Barb Wire -2/10
The Avengers -3/10

The worst would have to be Batman & Robin, Steel, Barb Wire, and Judge Dredd.

[mrdeeds]

These two:

Superman II (10/10)
Superman (10/10)

Will never be surpassed in my mind



Others not mentioned already are:

Conan the Barbarian (8.5/10)
Conan the Destroyer (7/10)
Darkman (8.5/10)
The Phantom (6.5/10)

[bankholdup]

My favorite comic book movie, and it's in my top 20 of all-time:

http://images.amazon.com/images/P/B00005T7I1.01.LZZZZZZZ.jpg

Can't beat this classic.

[ilovemovies]

1. Road to Perdition * * * * (if it counts)
2. Daredevil * * * 1/2
3. Batman * * * 1/2
4. The Rocketeer * * * 1/2
5. The Shadow * * * 1/2
6. Superman * * * 1/2
7. Spider-Man * * * 1/2
8. Superman II * * * 1/2
9. The Mask * * *
10. Judge Dredd * * *

Special mention goes to Unbreakable (* * * * ) which isn't based on a comic book but is a comic book movie.

The Worst:

Barb Wire *

What a turkey that movie was!


Some of these I didn't even know were from comic books such as the Ninja Turtles movies or the Men in Black movies. Or the Avengers, which was also pretty bad but I gave it credit because atleast that movie looked great (and so does Uma Thurman ;) )

[rushmore beauty]

The Crow (9/10).
Road to Perdition (9/10).
Ghost World (9/10).
From Hell (9/10).
Batman (9/10).
Batman Returns (9/10).
Blade (7/10).
Blade II (8/10).
Superman (8/10).
Daredevil (8/10).
Spider-Man (7/10).
X-Men (7/10).
X2 (7/10).

[KornKidJedi]

1.Ghost World
2.The Crow
3.Blade II
4.Creepshow
5.Batman Returns

[ColinM]

http://i.imdb.com/Photos/Ss/0162346/GW_94.jpg

Top Ten Comic Book Movies
1) Ghost World (8.5/10)
2) Road to Perdition (8.5/10)
3) X2 (8/10)
4) Spider-Man (8/10)
5) X-Men (8/10)
6) Batman (8/10)
7) Dick Tracy (8/10)
8) Annie (7.5/10)
9) Batman Returns (7.5/10)
10T) Daredevil (7.5/10)
10T) The Rocketeer (7.5/10)

Honorable Mentions:
A Charlie Brown Christmas (8.5/10) and Ziggy's Gift (7.5/10)

If I counted Unbreakable (9/10), it would be #1.

All the ones in my Top Ten have been mentioned with the exception of Annie, but here are some that haven't been yet...

Mars Attacks! (7/10) - does this count?
Metropolis (7/10) - the anime film
Mystery Men (6/10)
Josie and the Pussycats (5.5/10)
Casper (5/10)
Annie (tv ver.) (5/10)
Diabolik (3/10)

[ColinM]

I just got The Crow today from Netflix, so I should be seeing that soon. I'm really looking forward to it, especially after how great Dark City was.

[randythetool]

If UNBREAKABLE counts, then I can come up with a fairly decent list.

UNBREAKABLE, ****
DICK TRACY, ****
HULK, ****
BATMAN (1966), ****
BATMAN RETURNS, ***1/2
X-MEN, ***
BATMAN, ***
SUPERMAN, ***
MEN IN BLACK, ***
ROAD TO PERDITION, **1/2
BATMAN FOREVER, **1/2
X2: X-MEN UNITED, **1/2
SPIDER-MAN, **
THE CROW, *1/2
DAREDEVIL, *1/2
SPAWN, *1/2
THE SHADOW, *
THE PHANTOM, *
JUDGE DREDD, 1/2*
BATMAN AND ROBIN, 1/2*

Honestly, can't remember any others. I suppose that means the rest blew enough for me to forget :p

[BostonPublicFan]

Come on, Batman and Robin was not that bad!
It was a cool, entertaining movie! It's nowhere near one of the worst movies of all time!