Recent Horror film that deserves "Classic" status most

[dannywalker17]

I stole this poll from imdb. I was just curious what the schmoes thought. Which of these recent horror flicks most deserves to be a classic? My pick is The Others, but The Ring and Frailty are not far behind. Somehow I accidentally voted for 28 Days Later.

[Scarface98.9]

Out of the list, I'd say Frailty (8.5/10)

[Lynn Minmei]

Signs (6/10).

[dannywalker17]

Originally posted by Lynn Minmei
Signs (6/10).

Nothing on that list gets more than 6/10 from you? Not a horror fan?

[Lynn Minmei]

Originally posted by dannywalker17
Nothing on that list gets more than 6/10 from you? Not a horror fan?

Nah, because Signs is the most likely to be a classic in my mind. It was a huge success and has all the elements of a director who may be the next Spielburg.

[dannywalker17]

Originally posted by Lynn Minmei
Nah, because Signs is the most likely to be a classic in my mind. It was a huge success and has all the elements of a director who may be the next Spielburg.

Oh. Well I was going more for what you think most deserves it, but I see what you are saying.

[Lynn Minmei]

Originally posted by dannywalker17
Oh. Well I was going more for what you think most deserves it, but I see what you are saying.

Yeah, that is kinda what I think deserves it, because I do like the director, but not the film. Aren't I great?

[Moviefan1234]

The brillant, Signs.

[Lindsey]

The Ring...9/10

[screamer581]

28 Days Later-8/10.

[Hannibal21]

Frailty

Second place: It's not on the poll but I think Willard deserves mentioning, it will become a great cult classic some day. :)

[Lynn Minmei]

Originally posted by Hannibal21


Second place: It's not on the poll but I think Willard deserves mentioning, it will become a great cult classic some day. :)

The more AJ Hakari pimps it, the more people will know about it.

[night prowler]

28 DAYS LATER: I loved this movie. Now I know why this film got so many good reviews.

[Frank the Tank]

The Ring

[Golden Ghost]

None of them deserve the 'Classic' status. If anything though, Signs would get it.

[A.J. Hakari]

SIGNS. I think in a few years, maybe 10 years or so, people will realize what a true genre classic it is.

[syxxpac]

Frailty

[edonline]

Voted for The Ring althought I really wanted to vote for the original version Ringu

[therealjohng]

28 Days Later... A horror masterpiece.

[A.J. Hakari]

Originally posted by Lynn Minmei
The more AJ Hakari pimps it, the more people will know about it.

And pimp it I shall. Hey, Horror whore finally watched it, so I know I'm doing something right. :D

[Sculder]

I picked Final Destination but would also go for Signs,Frailty,The Others and The Ring.

[VicVega]

Frailty or Final Destination...since those are the 2 most original films on there.

[SuperSoulMan]

It was a tie between signs and fraility but i had to go with Signs

[markuskorpela]

Signs. What a brilliant movie. Much better than Shyamalan's first hit, The Sixth Sense.

[bowieee]

28 days later.

[BadCoverVersion]

On the list, definitely 28 Days Later.

Off the list, Ginger Snaps.

[Sad man]

28 Days Later - 8/10 (B+)
The Ring - 7/10 (B)
The Texas Chainsaw Massacre - N/A
Frailty - 6/10 (C+)
Final Destination - 8/10 (B+)
Cabin Fever - N/A
Signs - 6/10 (B-)
Wrong Turn - 7/10 (B)
Resident Evil - 6/10 (B-)
The Others - 8/10 (B+)
Pitch Black - 5/10 (C)
Jeepers Creepers - 6/10 (C+)

[Jerk Shapiro]

Signs, man! Awesome shit! Already a classic in my mind...

[The Delfonics]

Cabin Fever - 9/10
Just amazing.

[blankpage]

Signs, Cabin Fever, and 28 Days Later are all classics in my eyes, but my vote will go to Signs (9/10).

[screamer581]

Oh, though I wouldn't exactly call it a "Horror Masterpiece", I think Dog Soldiers should be on this list, kick ass film.

[blurofserenity]

Not on the list....but May. That movie, is balls out horror my friends.

[The TZA]

Frailty's the best film there, but I think Signs and Final Destination will become classics in their own right, just for being a little different and more memorable. I would say Ringu, but I think that's already a classic.

[Tagia_Romero]

"Frailty", "The Others" and "28 Days Later..." spark me as future classics for generations to come.

[Guy Strong]

Cabin Fever - 7/10

[ANavissi500]

Its definitely The Ring

I dont consider Frailty and Signs (while better movies) to be horror.

I also think 28 Days Later wasnt all that horror-ey, more of a thriller w/a lot of thought-provoking fun.

But The Ring was pure horror.

[Bullet Tooth Tony]

I voted for 28 Days Later but I also think Signs should be up there in years to come.

[Briare Rabbit]

Originally posted by ANavissi500

But The Ring was pure horror.

It's also pure crap. I voted for Signs.

[mreeez]

Close call but I said Frailty. Great job by Bill Paxton in front of and behind the camera.

[dh1989]

Classic Spookfest -- Cabin Fever (Which I Voted For)

Classic Shitfest Trying, And Failing, To Pass Itself Off As Horror -- Wrong Turn

[thompsoncory]

It's a tie between THE RING and THE TEXAS CHAINSAW MASSACRE.

[Black Christmas]

either texas or ring but off the list May. That was so AWSOME !

[Lazy Boy]

On the list: The Ring. Still a creepy little gem, methinks.

Not on the list: May. It should be a classic right now.

[Mikey2Dope]

The Ring (9/10)

[Directly2Deep]

I voted for Cabin Fever but I also think Frailty and 28 Days Later should become classics

[dannywalker17]

Wow it's really close.

[Folco]

Their all crap except for Signs, Frailty and The Others.

The best horror movies in the last 10 years, though, are Ringu and Dark Water, both from Hideo Nakata.

[movieguy1021]

Originally posted by Hannibal21
Frailty

Second place: It's not on the poll but I think Willard deserves mentioning, it will become a great cult classic some day. :)

I agree. Willard is a classic, but since it isn't on there, I vote for The Others, one of the only original ones on there that are scary.