PDA

View Full Version : Please review this... especially the guys that know their stuff well.


Kastman
01-25-2004, 11:09 AM
OK I'm not 100% sure I am allowed to post this here but I think it should be allowed.

My friend is writing a book, and I thought it would be good if I posted a short start of it here, to see what you people think, because in general, you know a shit load of stuff about writing.

It's not very long, so could you please review this for me :)

________________________________________________

“Just shut the fuck up! Ill be out soon” Typical angry….typical. As usual Ellie , with a little less than 5 minutes to the movie starts, is still not ready. Her flowing black dress is looking more detestably tacky every moment , not surprising though really, I presume nearly all garments tend to look a bit worn after 60 minutes of stumbling around a room smaller than an adequately sized breadbin. Girls take such a long time to get ready don’t they. Worth it though, in the end, because they, like she, look very beautiful, stunning even. Elle’s tiny face resembled that of a porcelain doll, a smooth and pale mixture of confusion and torment riddled every dimple and tiny blemish. Beautiful though, none the less.But on the other hand I mention with great haste the beauty flows only “outside” rather than in. Inside there wasn’t room for beauty. Not even the tiniest crevice could house a glisten of beauty or alternativly a sprinkle of promise or hope. Secrets. Secrets consumed all that was inside.

A final glance in the mirror and a hand ran through her messy black hair signified to the others she was ready, so, one by one, they turned to face the door, and Elle, flicked off the light. There is something terribly consuming about darkness and even stranger is the matter in which it multiples when you are alone. Laying wide eyed at night Elle feels the blackness is doing nothing more than suffocating her. Watching to, the blackness always watches, but she was always deadly positive that it wasn’t to concerned about watching, more on tightening its grip. With company darkness’ arms divide and the suffocating coincidently becomes less evident. Surrounded by friendly company, thankfully, no arms reached her. She could breathe tonight.

Elle seems recognisably more comfortable outside of her apartment.

“Your not hiding something are you Elle?” I ask myself silently.

No no,beautiful girl,nothing sinister. A constant natter from a girl whom i think is named Corey drowns out any hints of destination and so they head off,me none the wiser.The destination (my guess) , a choice of one of four clubs, occasionally venturing into two if they have the time. Warp, Jumping Jax, Shadow Zone or the often talked about, deadly secluded, “I come here because everywhere else people spit at me” nightclub “The Vault” are the names of the four, out of town,hideous, goth clubs that they so frequently attend. I think I have an attraction. No,more of a,how can I put this, sexual frenzy towards gothic people and there is not one girl in that group that I wouldn’t like to fuck. All dressed in black they are always very hard to spot out around town and usually I end up spotting them by the harsh sound of Eliza’s stupid laugh.They laugh a lot and I think it would be safe to say that their appreance deceives people into thinking they have a bleak opinion on live. They could not be more mistaken , the girls have a beautiful , positive outlook on the world. They smile a smile so bright that I feel like im staring directly into the sun. Their happiness blisters me. I don’t know why I keep doing this to myself , I don’t want to turn the monitor back on but I have became so dependant that I barely get a winks sleep because I have to feel near them.Their happiness..blisters me.

Morning comes and the sun shines deeply into my eyes, bursting them open like peapods to once again witness the brutal turns and twists of todays modern world. As I step into the hallway I have a brief flash back to the back of the coffee house last weekend, trying desperately to recall what thread I opted for that particular evening. I do not remember.

________________________________________________


Opinions? Reviews? Criticisms?

Thanks in advance, Kastman

C-Desecration-
01-25-2004, 12:07 PM
This is messy.

First off . . .
"Her flowing black dress is looking more detestably tacky every moment, not surprising though really, I presume nearly-"
I've already lost interest.

Make is easier to follow:
" That black waterfall of a dress is looking more detestably tacky every moment."
Leave out the rest. It makes no sense. Why would clothes get worn out by . . . by stumbling around a room? Huh?

In general, what you have isn't too hot. How the sentences are put together leads me to wonder if English is the author's fist language. Things like
" Elle seems recognisably more comfortable outside of her apartment."
come out of left field and pretty much KO any interest the reader might have.

“Your not hiding something are you Elle?” I ask myself silently.
Again. "I asked myself silently?" You mean I thought? I said under my breath? I muttered?
People don't "ask themselves silently".

I honestly didn't read everything. It's just not written in a coherant manner.
But, to be a little positive, there are some nice pros . . .
. . . yet again the author doesn't know how to use them.
" Elle’s tiny face resembled that of a porcelain doll, a smooth and pale mixture of confusion and torment riddled every dimple and tiny blemish."
Problem. " . . . riddled every dimple and tiny blemish-"
Boom. Your tense is wrong.
" . . . procelain doll, a smooth and pale mixture of confusion and torment riddling every dimple and tiny blemish."
Further more, 'tiny blemish' is a little wordy. Just say 'pores'.

" Inside there wasn’t room for beauty. Not even the tiniest crevice could house a glisten of beauty or alternativly a sprinkle of promise or hope."
Not good. The word 'beauty' is overused, and everything else . . . well, simplify it:
" Inside there wasn't room for beauty. Inside we were all barren rooms with padded walls and straight jackets in the corners."
Doesn't that flow better?

I'm sorry about the sporadic review/criticism, but what you have above just has too many problems to address individually. In general, he needs to check his spelling and grammer, clean up his sentences, know when to start a new paragraph, get a better voice for the narrator (give him a unique voice, most importantly) . . . just make the whole thing easier to follow.
Oh, and I don't think your friend should tackle a novel at the moment . . .

Cyd V
01-25-2004, 01:15 PM
He's right it's messy, doesn't flow well. If you want to help your friend, tell him to rent the jackie brown dvd. On it is 10 tips from author Elmore Lenard. The most important tip is, if it looks like writing, rewrite it...

Ares2907
01-25-2004, 05:31 PM
More or less what they said :cool:
It sounds like your 'friend' :rolleyes: is trying to write poetry in prose whilst barely having a grip on the English language. It lost me after sentence two. It screams 'I've just read a book that I want to imitate, but don't know how'.
Beyond the massacred language, there's not really anything gripping, is there? Nothing that makes one want to keep reading. If he had better English skills, it might be prettier, but it would still be boring.