Signs Vs Frailty

[saintofscars]

I think Signs and Frailty are similar in some ways. They both came out the same year. They've both got a wrinkly dad with a couple of kids, a rural setting, spooky direction and great stories. They also have no gore and no sexy ladies (bah!)....

I want to know which one people think is best.

[my_name_is_neo]

Signs (8/10) by far.

Frailty (5/10) was, IMO, overrated.

[countchocula]

S I G N S

[Jason Voorhees]

Frailty.

[martyds761]

Frailty by far............

[Antonio]

A tie from me: equally magnificent. Glad that was a choice!

[syxxpac]

Frailty

[dr_nocturna]

Signs by a close margin.

Pleasant Screams-Doc Noc

[Jess]

Frailty. I love you Bill Paxton!

[IamNoOne666]

it was close but I had to go with Signs.

[EVILxxx]

It was close, Signs was better in the tension' department but Frailty was better overall IMO

[Ripper1888]

Frailty by far Signs like M.Night's other two flicks sucked ass.

[Cronos]

Frailty by a very looooooooooooooooong shot,

Signs was a pile of shit, very very disappointing throughout, especially the ending whereas Frailty is a marvelous film that gripped me from the beginning

[Carrie White]

My vote is for Frailty but Signs was also very good.

[KillerKlown]

Signs

[Draven2277]

i think these two movies are totally different movies, and i love them both tremendously in their own right. so i am giving this vote a tie score.

[Shockwave]

Signs, but only by a hair.

[SenorSpielbergo]

Frailty

[Jack_Cheze]

I like them both

[XpatrickX]

easily frailty for me

[Haddonfield]

Both are very good movies in different ways.

[Raw Chili]

Frailty

[Moviefan1234]

Signs

[TheDeadWalk]

Frailty didn't have the bullshit plot holes like Signs did with the aliens.

[noseboy]

Signs is more entertaining, but Frailty is more shocking and enthralling... it's a tie for me.

[Boba Joe]

Signs

[mshulman5]

Both very good but if I was forced to pick it would have to be Signs. I have a 56 inch TV with Boston Acoustic Dolby Surround in a room with windows all around. When I put that movie in at night it still manages to give me the chills, and every now and then look out the windows to make sure nothing is out there.

[LedFloyd]

I went with Signs. It's funny, spooky, entertaining, gripping, and more rewatchable than Frailty. Both however are high 8/10's and lay on the outskirts of my top 100.

[John Galt]

SIGNS

Both very interesting though definitely. Having just come back out of the south after 7+ years; both films affected me differently.

Signs was way more effective. The only part in Frailty that kind of got me *SPOILER*

was when the other, younger kid picks up the axe and starts killing that guy.

Whereas Signs had me keeping my stereo on at night for weeks.

Sidenote: What's interesting about Signs(and before I post this I should note that I am not religious in any manner whatsoever) is that whereas most films about aliens argue against the existence of god, M Night's film uses aliens as an argument for religion.
I think that's pretty crafty.

Frailty uses religious fanatacism as a template for the proof of real evil. It succeeds. But I've heard certain reactions like it says "it's okay to kill in the name of religion", which, while I can see how they can come up with that; I find it pretty ridiculous.

[Tagia_Romero]

Frailty. The story was truly original and there was no need for any aliens or any *interesting* plot fillers. It was a character based piece and a wonderful one at that.

[Frank the Tank]

Frailty - 8.5/10
Signs - 7/10

[drdash]

frailty was a much more kickass movie, that ending was awesome! signs just paled in comparison, especially in light of how awesome unbreakable was.

ciao
drdash

[aenima]

Frailty.
for some reason i didn't noticed any shitty computerised aliens in this film unlike some.. other movies but damn am i pleased not too!

[MickeyKnox]

Frailty

[screamer581]

Frailty-8/10
Signs-7.5/10

Both very good flicks, but I have to give the edge to the underrated Frailty.

[TheDeadWalk]

Signs was a trip to illogical hell for me.

And that has nothing to do with actual Aliens, just his thought process with them.

[girl6]

Fraility..By Far!

[neilg78]

Frailty god damn it!!!

[normanbatesjr]

Equal.

Signs is one of the most misunderstood movies I've ever seen. You have to understand the concept of "Faith" to understand this movie.

[GoldenGhost]

Signs.

Frailty didn't tickle my fancy.

[optimusprime]

Signs is a joke, Frailty owns