Pulp Fiction vs. The Shawshank Redemption

[SpacePuppet]

I know I made this thread once before, but I can't find it, & I can't remember which film won the vote. So vote away!

Pulp Fiction: (10/10)
The Shawshank Redemption: (7/10)

[jaymckee74]

Shawshank all the way

[Cronos]

Shawshank

[Gordon]

That's like comparing a jucy steak and a 7 layer cake cripping in chocolate.

Pulp Fiction, both are in my top ten though.

[Mr-Blonde]

Comparing two disparate films such as this really doesn't accomplish much but Pulp Fiction was more enjoyable in my book.

[screamer581]

Originally posted by Gordon

Pulp Fiction, both are in my top ten though.

What this man said.

[Shockwave]

Both are 10/10 movies.

Pulp is more entertaining, and Shawshank is more inspiring.

I feel like going with Shawshank today. TODAY.

[poopontheshoes7]

Shawshank is an amazing movie. And you guys are right. Apples and Oranges. But as far as my favorite just look to the left.

Pulp 10/10
Shawshank 10/10

[MickeyKnox]

Pulp Fiction by far even though Shawshank is good Pulp is much more fun to watch.

[Lazy Boy]

Pulp Fiction

[Lord Nikon]

Well these 2 movies are both in my top 3. Not really sure how to put the order. I'm not voting, cuz I am giving them both 10/10 and there is really no way I can decide which is better.

[Terror Australis]

Hard to say, I mean I love both these movies. But if I had to choose it would be Pulp Fiction.

[ChemicalRomance]

PULP FICTION-->10/10 (4th Favorite of All Time)
THE SHAWSHANK REDEMPTION-->10/10 (1st Favorite of All Time)

So, Shawshank.

[Hannibal21]

Love both, but Pulp Fiction takes the cake.

[Backstabba]

...I HAVE to choose Pulp Fiction...
.....but, a very hard decision.

[GoldenGhost]

S'all about the Pulp.

[chasingbanky]

Pulp fiction....... Not very similar movies, so I don't understand the comparison, but I do enjoy both a lot.

[bluesbrother965]

Pulp Fiction is in my top 10, Shawshank is in my top 15.

[SpacePuppet]

Originally posted by chasingbanky
Pulp fiction....... Not very similar movies, so I don't understand the comparison, but I do enjoy both a lot.

I just compared them becuase people are always saying these movies deserved 'best picture', not Forrest Gump. So I just wanted to see what is liked more.

[ilovemovies]

Top 3 movies of 1994:

1. Forrest Gump 10/10
2. Shawshank Redemption 10/10
3. Pulp Fiction 10/10

[Shockwave]

Gump robbed both Pulp and Shawshank of deserved rewards.:)

That being said, i still loved the Gump. 9/10.

[blankpage]

I love both, but I'm gonna have to give the slight edge to Pulp Fiction.

[Grebdron]

Shawshank was more intelligent and nuanced.

Pulp was great, but Shawshank is top 5 material.

[morricone]

Both are tens in my book. I like both movies, but The Shawshank Redemption reigns supreme over, and I voted for The Shawshank Redemption. But of course, people are gonna vote for the cool movie.

[drago25]

Pulp Fiction - 10/10
Shawshank Redemption - 9/10

Both fantastic flicks and personal favourites, but 'Fiction has a slight edge in my books.

[Allie]

This is a crazy poll. Crazy , I say.

Talk about apples and oranges, sheesh.

Both 10/10 IMO but I guess Shawshank. Ask me tomorrow, it'll be Pulp probably. :rolleyes:

[Mikey2Dope]

Both 10/10 and two amazing movies, but I vote for Pulp Fiction.

[bechols]

Man this is a though choice because I really do love both movies. Humm I guess for me it would come down to if both movies were on at the same time which would I watch. I would have to say......Pulp fiction. Watching Jules and Vincents little intellectual talks just crack me up.

[redcunningham]

Pulp Fiction.

[creekin111]

Wow, I'm actually shocked at the results here. Both are my favorite films of the 90's and if I had to choose I'd go with Shawshank.

[Hucksta G]

Shawshank (10/10)
Pulp (8/10)

[urbanlegend23]

Shawshank was more intelligent and nuanced.

Pulp was great, but Shawshank is top 5 material.

Well said. My thoughts exactly. As great a film as Pulp is, it can't quite compare to Shawshank for me.

[darknite125]

Shawshank

[DarkKnight81]

Both are amazing, but Pulp Fiction is in my top 10 and I once considered it my favorite movie of all time.

[athf1980]

i did the whole flip the quarter and shawshank won

[Matchbox225]

Pulp Fiction easily and I'm not even in love with the movie like so many are, as good as it is.

[yyuusr]

Shawshank by miles. Pulp Fiction is decent but its quite overrated. It doesn't deserve to be in the IMDb top 250.

[Jig Saw 123]

Pulp Fiction I can watch again again. Shawshank, not so much.

[Le_Big_Mac]

Pulp Fiction- 10/10
The Shawshank Redemption- 7/10

[Frosty_86]

Both fantastic films and both deserved to win Best Picture in 94 over Forrest Gump but I've give it to Pulp Fiction, it's my favorite movie.

[The Postmaster General]

I'd have to go with Pulp Fiction because, all respect to Shawshank, it had the more unique and clever twist on anal rape.

[Matchbox225]

I'd have to go with Pulp Fiction because, all respect to Shawshank, it had the more unique and clever twist on anal rape.

So true. Pulp Fiction really set the bar high for anal rape scenes.

[SS-Block]

The Shawshank Redemption

[jeo4]

The Shawshank Redemption - 9/10

Pulp Fiction - 8/10

[bigred760]

Pulp Fiction

[magjournal]

Pulp Fiction

But The Shawshank Redemption is a fantastic movie as well