SIN CITY or PULP FICTION?

[poopontheshoes7]

Which one of these films is the most badass. I myself am not answering this question because I simply cant.:D

[Hannibal21]

I loved Sin City, but it still has a long way to go in order to reach the greatness of Pulp Fiction.

[Shockwave]

Sin City may very well be the best movie ive seen this year, but its no Pulp.

But very few things are. No shame in coming in second in this race.

[SpacePuppet]

Sin City was good, but compared to Pulp Fiction it's nothing.

[Lord Nikon]

I am going to agree with the three previous posters. Then I am going to go further and say there is no real reason to even make this a poll. Sin City does not belong in the same sentence as Pulp Fiction, unless the sentence also contains "is no where close to as good as".

Pulp is an all time great. Sin City may be one of the better films of the year (even though I thought it was okay, but over rated...7ish/10)

[poopontheshoes7]

I know theres no real reason for this thread. I thought since both films narratives are almost identical, I would see which you guys like the best.

[Lazy Boy]

Pulp Fiction was leagues better than Sin City, even though the latter was a terrific visual feast.

[ilovemovies]

Not even close!

Pulp Fiction 10/10
Sin City 7/10

[drago25]

Sin City(9/10) is a great movie but Pulp Fiction(10/10) is a classic.

[Cronos]

while i think they are both excellent and id give em 10/10 in the end i got more out of Sin City

[GoldenGhost]

Originally posted by ilovemovies
Not even close!

Pulp Fiction 10/10
Sin City 7/10

[screamer581]

Pulp Fiction-10/10
Sin City-8/10

I thought Sin City was visually breathtaking and a blast to watch, but come on, nothing can touch Pulp Fiction.

[bluesbrother965]

Originally posted by Hannibal21
I loved Sin City, but it still has a long way to go in order to reach the greatness of Pulp Fiction.

I agree.

[blankpage]

Gotta agree with everyone here. Sin City is a really great flick, but Pulp Fiction is one of my all-time faves...so, it easily gets my vote.

[Mr. HokeyPokey]

In my opinion they both Blew

Pulp fiction - QT made it, and I really wanted to see it when it came out... God what a disappointing movie.

Sin City - Over hyped, this was a truely horrible film.

[Tony_Montana]

Look under my avatar for the answer to this one.

[MrCouch]

ha!

pulp fiction, hands down. no contest.

Sin City was great though.

[Fisting Ackbar]

Originally posted by screamer581
Pulp Fiction-10/10
Sin City-8/10

Same here.

[Gordon]

Dear Voters,

I dare whoever vote for They Both Blew to tell me who they are.

Love,
Gordon

[Hannibal21]

Originally posted by Gordon
Dear Voters,

I dare whoever vote for They Both Blew to tell me who they are.

Love,
Gordon

Look at Mr. HokeyPokey's post for the answer.

[Mr-Blonde]

Don't mess w/ the Pulp! (loved 'em both 10/10)

[Gordon]

Originally posted by Hannibal21
Look at Mr. HokeyPokey's post for the answer.

IWell fuck, I'm gonnaa call a couple of hard, pipe-hitting niggers, who'll go to work on the homes here with a pair of pliers and a blow torch. Im gonna get medieval on his ass.

[poopontheshoes7]

AHHHHHHHH Shit! You done pissed off Marsellus Wallace! You best hide your ass good. If you go to Indo-China he's gonna have a nigga hiding in a bowl of rice to pop a cap in your ass!:cool:

[Mr. HokeyPokey]

Originally posted by Gordon
IWell fuck, I'm gonnaa call a couple of hard, pipe-hitting niggers, who'll go to work on the homes here with a pair of pliers and a blow torch. Im gonna get medieval on his ass.

Pretty funny :) If it helps your riot against me, I also disliked Citizen Kane ver much, 4/10 Quite boring.

[bechols]

Sin City is definately a good movie. In my opinion, not as great as some think but ok. Pulp Fiction, on the other hand, is a cinematic masterpiece. It is right up there with movies like the Godfather, Scarface, and Goodfellas. There is absolutely no competition between these to movies.

[Bullet Tooth Tony]

Originally posted by Hannibal21
I loved Sin City, but it still has a long way to go in order to reach the greatness of Pulp Fiction.

Exactly. Pulp Fiction is No.3 on my All Time list.

[QUENTIN]

Sin City is an excellent movie but Pulp Fiction is the best.

[redcunningham]

Without Pulp Fiction there would be no Sin City.

[Gordon]

Originally posted by Mr. HokeyPokey
Pretty funny :) If it helps your riot against me, I also disliked Citizen Kane ver much, 4/10 Quite boring.

I really wish you could have seen my face while I read that.

[Brando @$$ Fat]

Originally posted by Mr. HokeyPokey
Pretty funny :) If it helps your riot against me, I also disliked Citizen Kane ver much, 4/10 Quite boring.

Wow, good thing my computer doesn't have a neck........

[Shockwave]

..this thread MAY have fared better if Sin City was up against ANY of QTs other movies, but as is, its a slaughter.:p

[Slim_JGE]

For me, it would have to be Pulp Fiction by a C-hair. I love them both though. :D

[Shockwave]

Without Pulp Fiction there would be no Sin City.

Thats not even close to being true.

Pulp Fiction, as great as it is, is NOT responsible for every hard hitting movie that came out after it being made. Thats just silly.

[Mr. HokeyPokey]

Originally posted by redcunningham
Without Pulp Fiction there would be no Sin City.


Care to elaborate? I highly disagree.

[GoldenGhost]

Originally posted by Mr. HokeyPokey
Pretty funny :) If it helps your riot against me, I also disliked Citizen Kane ver much, 4/10 Quite boring.

:D That made me chuckle.

As far as there being no Sin City without Pulp Fiction, that's very not true. There would be no Sin City film without the Sin City comics. End of.

[Katsumoto]

Pulp Fiction

[bigred760]

I freakin' love both movies, but Pulp Fiction (10/10) edges out Sin City (9/10).

[SpacePuppet]

Originally posted by Shockwave
Thats not even close to being true.

Pulp Fiction, as great as it is, is NOT responsible for every hard hitting movie that came out after it being made. Thats just silly.

yeah, Sin City was a comic book too. Pulp Fiction had nothing to do with it being created.

[SpacePuppet]

Originally posted by Shockwave
Thats not even close to being true.

Pulp Fiction, as great as it is, is NOT responsible for every hard hitting movie that came out after it being made. Thats just silly.

yeah, Sin City was a comic book too. Pulp Fiction had nothing to do with it being created.

[Minerva]

Ok i maybe be shot for this, but i love where sin city is taken place. It also kinda has a film noir feel to it, i mean i ve just heard someone critise how we live in the decade where Technicolour remains to be the true method of todays film making ( yeah right !). If there trying to portray a story line from a comic, how are they to do it in colour where most of the comic itself is in the black and white. And as well they are not been a bunch of followers as well.

Look at the visual art put into this film, plus the characters moral and social values, each have their own unique kind, oh i aint saying that characters in piulp fiction dont have their own unique social and moral values, i too think that Pulp Fiction is a kick ass film

Alright im sorry ill get to the point
Pulp Fiction 9.5/10 Sin City 10/10

[Savage Henry]

Sin City seems like a perfect film as I reflect on it: from the gorgeous damn-near unparalleled visual style to the completely self-gratifying, almost pornographic characters. Pulp just has a certain je ne sais quoi, that no other film can touch. So I choose Pulp Fiction, although I do think people are short-changing Sin City a bit.
Pulp Fiction 10/10
Sin City 9/10

[ilovemovies]

Originally posted by Shockwave
..this thread MAY have fared better if Sin City was up against ANY of QTs other movies, but as is, its a slaughter.:p

Not for me. For me, Sin City isn't even as good as Kill Bill Vol. 2 which is, IMO, Tarantino's weakest effort.

[Lazy Boy]

I think Jackie Brown is a better picture than Sin City.

[Gian-Sergio]

I Liked Sin City . It's an excellent film. Pulp Fiction is the true classic.

[Ripper1888]

Sin City-7/10 Visually this my be the most kick-ass movie ever made.Storywise it felt rushed in places,definately entertaing though.

Pulp Fiction-5/10 I don't no what is more overrated the movie or its director.

[sdsskater23]

IM going to have to say that if pulp fiction had the effects of today, it would have been even crazier. But this is about original looks so i have to go with pulp fiction over sin city.

[Terror Australis]

I think both Pulp Fiction (5/5) and Sin City (5/5) are brillant. If I had to choose, it would be Pulp Fiction.

[Mikey2Dope]

Originally posted by Hannibal21
I loved Sin City, but it still has a long way to go in order to reach the greatness of Pulp Fiction.

Ditto

[Sigur509]

As everyone and their brother has said:

Both great, but Pulp Fiction takes it. But Sin City has been the only movie close to being as badass as Pulp Fiction. Well, Snatch.

10/10
9/10

[AJAX]

Pulp Fiction

[redorblue01]

Pulp Fiction

[MickeyKnox]

Sin City-10/10 although a great movie, has nothing on the pure greatness of Pulp Fiction-10/10

[Sir.Lancelot]

Oh yea, thats right YOU CAN'T!! Pulp fiction has heart and soul, Sin City is just gritty in your face crime which has been done a zillion times. So Pulp Fiction all the way. :D