R-rated comedy

[mcquade]

Favorite r-rated comedies...i know i missed a few(porky's, cheech and chong, harold and kumar,etc...)

[Lazy Boy]

Other: There's Something About Mary

[sarah1980]

Other:The Breakfast Club

[mcquade]

i can't beleive i forgot there's something about mary - i'm a freakin idiot

[redorblue01]

Old School - 7/10
The Girl Next Door - 9/10
American Pie - 8/10
Bad Santa - 5/10
Road Trip - 8/10
South Park: Bigger, Longer and Uncut - 10/10
Team America: World Police - 9/10
Van Wilder - 8/10

[rufio]

Originally posted by Lazy Boy
Other: There's Something About Mary

[ilovemovies]

The Girl Next Door easily.

Although South Park, the American Pie movies and The Wedding Crashers are all great too.


And Scary Movie 3 is PG-13.

[Squid Vicious]

Other: This is Spinal Tap (10/10)

But I suppose I'll rate the ones you have listed:

Old School - 3/10
The Girl Next Door - 3/10
American Pie - 3/10
Scary Movie - 6/10
Scary Movie 2 - 2/10
Bad Santa - 8/10
Road Trip - 2/10
South Park: Bigger, Longer and Uncut - 8/10
Team America - 8/10

I didn't see The Wedding Crashers, the American Pie sequels, Scary Movie 3, Super Troopers and Van Wilder, and I don't really plan to, either. Life is too short.

[morricone]

Out of those.....Bad Santa.

[zeppelin]

Originally posted by Squid Vicious
Other: This is Spinal Tap (10/10)

Agree 100%.

Ranking the ones I've seen that are in the poll:
1. Bad Santa- A-
2. Wedding Crashers- B+
3. South Park: Bigger, Longer, & Uncut- D+
4. American Pie- D+
5. Scary Movie- D
6. Van Wilder- F

[ilovemovies]

Originally posted by Squid Vicious



Scary Movie - 6/10
Scary Movie 2 - 2/10





That is funny because I agree with those ratings except I'd swap them.

[drago25]

Girl Next Door(8/10) is my favourite out of those. Other goes to This Is Spinal Tap for sure.

[chasingbanky]

Other......... The Big Lebowski (10/10)

[Tony_Montana]

Other: Beverly Hills Cop

[Cronos]

touch one between South Park and Team America but i think South Park has to be slightly better

[Mr-Blonde]

THE BIG LEBOWSKI - 10/10

Here's my full review (http://www2.joblo.com/forums/showthread.php?s=&threadid=87055) of this classic film.

[Shockwave]

..what?

No votes for Blazing Saddles?

Shame on u all.

[QUENTIN]

Other: Clerks. Of those, The Girl Next Door by far.

[Lazy Boy]

Originally posted by Shockwave
..what?

No votes for Blazing Saddles?

Shame on u all.

It was funny for its time (and I must admit it still makes me chuckle) but a lot of the jokes are corny and are less scatalogical in comparison to recent comedies (like my choice, There's Something About Mary).

[Shockwave]

The main one im shcoked no one has mentioned would be my most recent fav-

SHAUN OF THE DEAD.

"Dont forget to kill Phillip!"

[bigred760]

Other: Animal House


Dude, you gotta realize that these kind of comedies were perfected in the late 70s and 80s - Porky's, Animal House, etc. All those you listed have elements from the earlier classics.

[Gian-Sergio]

Favorite R-Rated Comedies:
Kill Bill, Pulp Fiction, A Clockwork Orange, The Big Lebowski, 48 Hours, and True Romance

[cerealkiller182]

definately the wedding crashers. i have never laughed so hard in a movie before

[jaw2929]

Dumb and Dumber

Off that list, Bad Santa and Van Wilder

[AJAX]

Revenge of the nerds

[Brando @$$ Fat]

Any of These Gems:

Animal House
Fast Times at Ridgemont High
Shaun of the Dead
The Big Lebowski
Fargo

[the_sneaker]

Bad Santa: 8.5/10. The most refreshing Christmas film I have ever seen.
Super Troopers: 8.5/10. Just so damn funny!
The Girl Next Door: 8.5/10. This one was a pleasent surprise that was so much better than I thought it was going to be. (Besides, any movie that uses "Baba O'Riley," by The Who, during the final scene, is going to score points with me.)
Team America: World Police: 8/10. When no one could shut the hell up about Full'o'shit 9/11, Trey and Matt shoved a stick of TNT up their collective asses and told them to shut it.
Wedding Crashers: 8/10. Brat pack all the way, baby! Any movie with Vince Vaughn in it, is a good movie. (I'm totally kidding guys *cough* Psycho , but still a lot of his movies are fantastic.)
American Pie: 8/10. Just the first one. The others were mediocre at best. This was the Porky's of my generation.
Old School: 7.5/10. Not as good as Wedding Crashers, but c'mon...it's Vince!
Scary Movie: 7.5/10. Just the first one, which was funny, but the whole idea behind it got real old, real fast.
Road Trip: 7/10. EuroTrip was better.

As for South Park and Van Wilder...well, I haven't seem those, so it wouldn't be right to critique them.

[Slim_JGE]

On this list... Probably South Park. But my favorite comedy of all time also happens to be R rated, The Big Lebowski. :D

[bigred760]

Originally posted by Gian-Sergio
Favorite R-Rated Comedies:
Kill Bill, Pulp Fiction, A Clockwork Orange, The Big Lebowski, 48 Hours, and True Romance


I'm sorry (and I don't mean to pick on you there G-Sergio) but does anybody else consider these to be comedies, other than The Big Lebowski? I'll give you 48 Hours, but Kill Bill? Come on.

[Mikey2Dope]

Old School

[the_sneaker]

Originally posted by bigred760
I'm sorry (and I don't mean to pick on you there G-Sergio) but does anybody else consider these to be comedies, other than The Big Lebowski? I'll give you 48 Hours, but Kill Bill? Come on.

I was about to say the same thing...and A Clockwork Orange?

[Gian-Sergio]

Originally posted by bigred760
I'm sorry (and I don't mean to pick on you there G-Sergio) but does anybody else consider these to be comedies, other than The Big Lebowski? I'll give you 48 Hours, but Kill Bill? Come on.

If you were not laughing during Kill Bill , Then you never saw it.

[Terminal]

Other: Butterfly Effect

[Andrew Ratto]

Pulp Fiction and Kill Bill are action films first and dark comedies second or third.

A Clockwork Orange can be humorous, but it isn't a full-fledged comedy, which is what this thread is addressing.

[LegionX]

Other : Friday

[KillerKlown]

Other: There's Something About Mary

[MickeyKnox]

Originally posted by Shockwave
The main one im shcoked no one has mentioned would be my most recent fav-

SHAUN OF THE DEAD.

"Dont forget to kill Phillip!"
I agree totally with that choice.

[king_verhoeven]

From the list: American Pie 1 and 2, my generations Porky. Brilliant stuff.

Others: Dumb and Dumber and Kingpin (R-rated??)

[chasingbanky]

Originally posted by Andrew Ratto
Pulp Fiction and Kill Bill are action films first and dark comedies second or third.


I'm going to have to say Pulp Fiction is crime first, and action never...

[bigred760]

Originally posted by Gian-Sergio
If you were not laughing during Kill Bill , Then you never saw it.

That doesn't make it a comedy.

[Raging Bull080]

Bad Santa is the greatest movie ever. No not really but it is the funniest in my opinion. I practically have the god damn thing memorized.