Rank this years Best Picture nominees.

[The Other]

If you haven't seen all the nominees for Best Picture, obviously just rank the one's you have seen. Here are mine...

1. A Beautiful Mind (10/10)
2. In the Bedroom (9/10)
3. Moulin Rouge! (8/10)
4. Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring (8/10)

STILL haven't seen Gosford Park...

[This message has been edited by The Other (edited 07-04-2002).]

[Quebec-Joel]

1- LOTR (10/10)
2- In The Bedroom (8.5/10)
3- Moulin Rouge! (8/10)
4- A Beautiful Mind (7.5/10)
5- Gosford Park (7/10)

I just think A Beautiful Mind was too much a movie made to win an oscar and that, really, it wasn't anything original, groundbreaking or new. But hey, did you ever saw any original, groundbreaking movies win an Oscar... Hmm, yes, last time it was in 1968 with Midnight Cowboy.

[The Shah Of Blah]

1.In The Bedroom (8.0/10)
2.Moulin Rouge! (7.5/10)
3.A Beautiful Mind (7.5/10)
4.LOTR (7/10)

[This message has been edited by The Shah Of Blah (edited 03-10-2002).]

[idealdiscountdude]

1.LOTR 10/10
2.Gosford Park 9.5/10
3.In The Bedroom 9.5/10
4.A Beautiful Mind 9.5/10
5.Moulin Rouge 9/10

All excellent films!

[ColinM]

.

[This message has been edited by ColinM (edited 07-05-2002).]

[Fergus]

1. A Beautiful Mind-- 9
2. LOTR-- 8
3. Moulin Rouge-- 7

I want to see "In the Bedroom" so bad, it's not even funny. It has been playing at the movie theater I work at for the past month and a week, and it just left the theater on Friday. Gosford Park has been playing since the end of December, and it is still there. The only reason I haven't seen it is because the theater won't let me see it because I have not yet turned 17 (only a month and and 11 days to go). Even though I work there, they won't let me go in....[quietly he mutters].... bastards.....

[QUENTIN]

1.) In The Bedroom -9/10
2.) A Beautiful Mind -8.5/10
3.) Lord of The Rings: FOTR -8/10
4.) Moulin Rouge -5/10

Haven't seen Gosford Park...

[notchjohnson]

1.a beautiful mind
2.the lord of the rings
3.in the bedroom
4.moulin rouge
5.gosford park

[sleekproductions]

1. Moulin Rouge (10/10)
2. Lord of the Rings: Fotr (10/10)
3. A Beautiful Mind (9/10)
4. Gosford Park (9/10)

Haven't seen In The Bedroom, and have no desire to see it.

[SteveSzyk]

01.) Lord of the Rings: 10/10
02.) Moulin Rouge: 9/10
03.) A Beautiful Mind: 9/10
04.) In the Bedroom: 8/10
05.) Gosford Park: 7/10

[dicaprio_travolta_man]

1. A Beautiful Mind
2. Moulin Rouge!
3. LOTR:FOTR
4. Gosford Park
5. In The Bedroom

- As you can see I will be very happy if any movie other then ITB wins the award. ITB shouldn't have gotten it's nomination, neither should have Gosford Park. They should of put Black Hawk Down and Memento in the race instead.

[Strider]

1. The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring(10/10)

2. A Beautiful Mind(10/10)

3. In The Bedroom(9/10)

4. Moulin Rouge(8/10)

Haven't seen Gosford Park, and don't plan to anytime soon.

Strider

[arto_j]

<font face="Verdana, Arial" size="2">Originally posted by ColinM:
1) Moulin Rouge (10/10)
2) A Beautiful Mind (9/10)
3) LOTR: FOTR: (8/10)

I still haven't seen In the Bedroom or Gosford Park. It sucks living in a rural area as I do, and I'd have to travel quite far to see these two. I would, but school and drama take up a lot of time so...yeah.</font>

I have pretty much the same problem, but even worse as I don't live in the U.S .In the Bedroom hasn't even been released yet...


Anyways, I've seen these:

A Beautiful Mind 9/10
Lord of the Rings 7/10

[Quebec-Joel]

well, if nothing else, you can always download those movies. With the Oscar coming, all those movies have really good DVD screener releases that you can get. Like Lord of the Ring DVD is out since mid January. All the others have had decent releases. Just search a little and you shall find.

It's never as good as seeing them in the Theatre. But hey, it's better then not seeing them at all.

[ColinM]

<font face="Verdana, Arial" size="2">Originally posted by QUENTIN:
1.) In The Bedroom -9/10
2.) A Beautiful Mind -8.5/10
3.) Lord of The Rings: FOTR -8/10
4.) Moulin Rouge -5/10

Haven't seen Gosford Park...</font>

I thought you gave Moulin Rouge a 7... http://www.joblo.com/ubb/frown.gif

[dr-movielove]

1.A Beautiful Mind (9/10)
2.In the Bedroom (8.5/10)
3.LOTR: FOTR (8/10)
4.Gosford Park (8/10)
5.Moulin Rouge (7.5/10)

[QUENTIN]

<font face="Verdana, Arial" size="2">Originally posted by dicaprio_travolta_man:

- As you can see I will be very happy if any movie other then ITB wins the award. ITB shouldn't have gotten it's nomination, neither should have Gosford Park. They should of put Black Hawk Down and Memento in the race instead.</font>

While I loved Black Hawk Down and Memento as well, what was so wrong with In The Bedroom?


Colin -I did, but just as Kevin Smith felt his disdain for Magnolia growing and growing, my grade is slipping for this over-blown, showy, pretentious piece of overdone filmmaking.

[ColinM]

Fair enough, QUENTIN.

[bskutle]

1. "The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring"- A+
2. "A Beautiful Mind"- A+
3. "In the Bedroom"- A
4. "Gosford Park"- A-
5. "Moulin Rouge"- C

[Stripes]

"One movie to rule them all" LOTR 9/10
Beautiful Mind 8/10

[Movie Hunter]

This is the one the movie http://www.joblo.com/ubb/smile.gif

LOTR 10/10
beautifull mind 8/10
mouling rouge 7/10

did not catch the rest

[GhostoftheFuture]

1) A Beautiful Mind (4 of 4 stars)
2) Lord of the Rings (3.75)
3) Moulin Rouge! (3.5)
4) In the Bedroom (3.25)
5) Gosford Park (3)

I agree about Memento (but not really BlackHawk Down). The last two films on the list were suburbly-acted, but interminably slow pacing do them in for those who don't like indie-flix (I do, to a point).

~GhostoftheFuture

[dicaprio_travolta_man]

<font face="Verdana, Arial" size="2">Originally posted by QUENTIN:
While I loved Black Hawk Down and Memento as well, what was so wrong with In The Bedroom?</font>

There isn't really anything wrong with In The Bedroom. It has a wonderful story, and great acting but, I will have to agree with JoBlo when he says that it is just a little to slow. And BHD & Memento got higher grades from me then ITB did.

[Benny]

1. Lord of the Rings- 10/10
2. In the Bedroom- 9/10
3. A Beautiful Mind- 7.5/10
4. Moulin Rouge- 7/10
5. Gosford Park- 4/10

For those of you who haven't seen Gosford Park, DON'T.

[This message has been edited by Benny (edited 07-05-2002).]

[urbanlegend23]

...

[This message has been edited by urbanlegend23 (edited 07-04-2002).]

[youngSL]

A Beautiful Mind-(9/10)
LOTR-(7.5/10)
Moulin Rouge!(4.5/10)
Gosford Park(6/10)
In the Bedroom(8.5/10)

[Puck Bond]

1. The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring-10/10
2. A Beautiful Mind-10/10
3. Gosford Park-9/10
4. Moulin Rouge!-8/10
5. In the Bedroom-7/10

[Hypothermia]

1. In the Bedroom (9/10)
2. A Beautiful Mind (9/10)
3. Moulin Rouge! (8/10)
4. Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring (8/10)
5. Gosford Park (7/10)

[The Other]

Yikes! I forgot about this topic. I just edited it because my grades have changed and I at least have seen In the Bedroom since this topic started...but I still haven't seen Gosford Park.

[MiddleEarthArwen]

1. Moulin Rouge (10/10)
2. Lord of the Rings (10/10)
3. Gosford Park (9/10)
4. Beautiful Mind (8/10)

I did not catch In The Bedroom, as where the town I live in as a movie theater that smaller movies (even when nominated for Oscars!) are shown at...unfortunately, this movie theater has thin walls, so you can hear every other movie being played as well as your own. It is avoided at all costs...I'll have to wait till video http://www.joblo.com/ubb/frown.gif

[urbanlegend23]

Whats with all the resurrection of the old posts?

Anyway...

1. Moulin Rouge - 10/10
2. The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring - 10/10
3. A Beautiful Mind - 10/10
4. In the Bedroom - 10/10
5. Gosford Park - 7/10

Just replace GP with Harry Potter and you would have my top 5 for 2001.

[charliebobo]

1. Moulin Rouge 9.5/10
2. ABM 8.5/10
3. LOTR 7.5/10

I want to see Gosford Park and In The Bedroom in english which means I'll have to wait for them to be out on DVD... dubbed movies suck!!! http://www.joblo.com/ubb/mad.gif

[This message has been edited by charliebobo (edited 07-05-2002).]

[Nate6]

I can't believe I didn't post my picks in here earlier! Ah well.

1. A Beautiful Mind - 9/10
2. Moulin Rouge! - 9/10
3. LOTR: FOTR - 8/10
4. In the Bedroom - 7/10
5. Gosford Park - 6/10

[ColinM]

1) Moulin Rouge (10/10)
2) LOTR:FOTR (9/10)
3) A Beautiful Mind (9/10)
4) In the Bedroom (7/10)

Still haven't seen Gosford Park...

[dannywalker17]

1. LOTR(10/10)
2. Moulin Rouge(9/10)
3. A Beautiful Mind(8/10)

[arto_j]

Moulin Rouge 10/10
A Beautiful Mind 9/10
Lord of the Rings 8/10

Still waiting for the other two...

[This message has been edited by arto_j (edited 07-09-2002).]

[CheekyShepherd]

Lord Of The Rings (10/10)
A Beautiful Mind (7/10)
Gosford Park (6/10)
In The Bedroom (5/10)
Moulin Rouge (0/10)

[notchreturns]

That NotchJohnson is a fucking douche bag. http://www.joblo.com/ubb/smile.gif

Anyway...

1. The Lord of the Rings 8/10
2. Moulin Rouge 6/10

I STILL havent seen the other nominees...