I've stared at your post for five minutes, trying to figure out how to respond.
All I can say is: Really? You're going to shame people for finding a celebrity hot because of something that's hypothetical? "If they weren't celebrities and you just saw them walking down the street, you wouldn't think they were attractive."
I still don't 'get' that. But I'm obviously of a weaker mind than you.
Why does it matter
Come to think of it, what the fuck do I know? Bah...Bah...
LOL @ your thread title, too.