Arkham Asylum was absolutely amazing...except for a few things...
I wish it were longer...I was so wrapped up in the amazing story and graphics, that i had it beat in about 2 days...
also, the replay value is ok...at best...I would love for some multi player with Batman characters from the game (and some that weren't)
And finally, for such an amazing story...the final battle was BAD!
my vote would have to go to MW2 as of right now...amazing story, graphics, gameplay and multi...I haven't beaten it yet, so i can't speak on that...but from what i have played so far...this game fucking rocks...polished shiny.