I don't have a real problem with Aniston being number one. Would you rather it just be another boring list with Marilyn Monroe in the top spot? The idea that there hasn't been a more beautiful woman than Monroe in the past fifty years is a bit absurd. Besides, the list was done simply to generate controversy and attention to the magazine. Mission Accomplished.
The far bigger crime has been overlooked: How in the hell were Sandra Bullock and Kate Beckinsale left off the list?