Your GOTY (so far)
Off the top of my head, I've usually been catching up on games I missed last year when we had that big rush or replaying old games in anticipation for games this year (Assassins Creed) but so far these have been my best gaming experiences.
GOTY (so far)
1. Max Payne 3
2. The Darkness II
Have yet to play; Borderlands 2, Transformers Fall of Cybertron, BLOPS II, Spec Ops The Line, Dishonoured