#1  
Old 12-31-2012, 12:21 PM
The Whip and the Body (1963)

Originally written for Hell Broke Luce



AKA The Whip and the Flesh and What

Normally I like to start off these damned things with an intro of some sort, preferring to not jump right into a plot synopsis. It just seems more, I donít know, ďproperĒ, I suppose to me (I guess you could say thatís one good thing I took away from high school English class). Normally, Iíve been pretty lucky in this department but for the life of me I could not think of an intro of any kind for this film. Iíve even put off writing this on a few occasions in the hopes that something would come to me but alas, nothing. I know itís just for a dumb blog and Iím probably over thinking something that Iím sure most would view as trivial but Iím weird like that. It is what it is. Therefore, in this instance, Iím admitting defeat (I can probably see this happening in the future as well). Consider this rambling a cop out for the lack of a proper intro. I think Iíve stalled long enough, so letís get into it, my all time favorite Mario Bava film, The Whip and the Body!

After being banished for causing the suicide of a servant he seduced and subsequently abandoned, Kurt Menliff (Christopher Lee) returns to his familyís seaside castle upong hearing the news that Nevenka (Daliah Lavi), the woman that was once promised to him is now married to his brother Christian (Tony Kendall). It isnít long after Kurtís return that he and Nevenka find themselves revisiting their favorite pastime, with Nevenka being on the receiving end of Kurtís whip, although later that night Kurt is mysteriously murdered in his room. Soon after Kurtís funeral however, Nevenka beings to see Kurt appear to her in her room at night, and the whippings being again, and although nobody believes Nevenka and her ghost stories at first, soon Kurtís presence begins to be felt throughout the entire castle.

A ghost story/murder mystery complete with major psychological and sadomasochistic overtones, The Whip and the Body (La frusta e il corpo) is certainly made up of an odd collection of ingredients seemingly on the opposite ends of the spectrum, but it works, and works well. One of the major keys to the success of the film is how well balanced it is, in the sense that neither one of the aforementioned elements override one or the other, theyíre all working hand in hand to create a truly unique film experience, I doubt youíll see anything else even remotely like it. The mystery element is pretty standard at first, following most of the classic whodunit motifs (itís been said that portions of it could be considered proto giallo) IE who was where and with who when such and such happened, but as the film progresses it becomes something else entirely when taking the ghost story elements into consideration. Far from your average spirit haunting a castle story, the ghost story is unquestionably one of the most enticing devices of the film, as itís simpatico with the psychological and S&M aspects. The character of Nevenka is a fascinating one, and Bava uses Kurtís spirit as a primer of sorts to explore Nevenkaís complex range emotions regarding her relationship with Kurt and her masochistic personality, as well as the fear that, even in death, Kurt still seems to strike in those in the castle. On top of all that, Bava even manages to take the film into romantic and tragic territories at times, which both fit right in with all attributes of the story. One dimensional this film isnít.

Do forgive me for using the tired saying the film looking like a painting come to life, but when taking into consideration the barrage of beautiful, beautiful colors which Bava showcases mere seconds after the opening credits, plus the lighting and cinematography, Iíll be damned if that saying wasnít specifically invented for a film like this. Throughout the film Bava particularly shows an affinity for red, blue and green (amongst many others of course) using said colors to create some incredibly striking images, some of the most memorable in his entire filmography in fact, such as Kurtís green ghost hand lurching towards the screen out of the darkness, or in one sequence choosing to present the face of Kurt as a sharp, ghastly yet gorgeous shade of crimson. Thereís plenty of substance to go along with all the style as Bava took full advantage of the fact that when the events of the story take a turn for the delirious it gave the visuals and the sound design license to do so as well, such as Nevenka constantly hearing sounds resembling lashes of a whip, pretty much any scene taking place within Kurtís tomb, and my personal favorite, the shot of a vine apparently ďwhippingĒ in the wind. The castle setting, complete with secret passages is not only prime for the whodunit subplot, but the gothic atmosphere that naturally comes with such a place couldnít have been more fitting for the ghost story. Bava also threw in some nice beach shots for added beauty, the same beach by the way that he would later return to for the underappreciated Five Dolls For an August Moon (1970).

Along with the mystery going on in the story, thereís a few other things regarding the film that Iíve always found to be somewhat mysterious. First, why Christopher Leeís lines were dubbed over post production, when itís obvious they were done in English. To be perfectly honest, the dubbed voice doesnít really sound all that different than Leeís natural voice and it never affects the film or Leeís performance in a negative way, but it just seems so unnecessary. Secondly, why the film was released in the U.S. under the alternate title What. Why? Thereís been some strange alternate titles given to a lot of films over the years, but What sure as hell takes the cake for the most bizarre. Finally, just how badly the film was butchered by the censors when it was first released. Watching the fully uncut version today youíll probably be left scratching your head wondering what was considered so offensive, but take offense people did, and certain scenes that were absolutely essential to the story were cut. Whatís even more surprising is how lenient and more liberal Europe is considered to be when it comes to things of that nature, but I guess for 1963 the film went too far. As I stated above, The Whip and the Body is my favorite Bava film, as to me, every single one of Bavaís strengthís as a filmmaker are on display here. Couple that with the original storyline, one of Christopher Leeís most imposing performances and Daliah Laviís dumbfounding beauty, youíve got a masterpiece. Itís considered by many to be Bavaís best work, and while a statement like that is bound to cause debate, I share that mindset.
Reply With Quote
  #2  
Old 02-21-2013, 03:33 PM
Iīd be hard dressed to judge what my favorite Bava movie is, thereīs at least four I would mention. That aside, I think this was one of his most experimental works, taking the well-established "spooky-castle-with-a-whodunit" formula to another level. Bascially this is a "love" movie, the affection between Kurt and Nevenka being the essential part. The fact that the relationship is sado-machistic is not that problematic in itself - where it not for their victorian and aristrocratic surroundings those two would get along fine, I imagine. Nevenka never shows any sign of affection for her destined husband and, as telegraphed in the film, he makes not much effort for her either. Even the inevitably rather destructive ending has a romantic touch in itself. Bava always manages to put some unusual character development into his movie but The Whip and the Body is more extreme. That said, it would definitely go into my top-5 favorite Bava films.

One word on the rather messy censorship history: The initial european release and all subsequent home video releases lack nearly all of the "romantic" scenes between Kurt and Nevenka - Kurt is shown as a sadist and Nevenka as an unwilling victim. I canīt confirm this for every country but at least the german vhs release had the original score intact despite lacking the context and in the first american version the score is altered as well, plus the dubbing explains the killerīs identity in Kurts death scene (the voice of the assasilant calls behind a curtain). Watch this on a good and uncut dvd.

Another great review hannibalguy, Iīve recently finally seen I Vampiri and will review it, eventually. What are your thoughts on this film?
Reply With Quote
  #3  
Old 02-21-2013, 04:53 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dehydrator View Post
Iīd be hard dressed to judge what my favorite Bava movie is, thereīs at least four I would mention. That aside, I think this was one of his most experimental works, taking the well-established "spooky-castle-with-a-whodunit" formula to another level. Bascially this is a "love" movie, the affection between Kurt and Nevenka being the essential part. The fact that the relationship is sado-machistic is not that problematic in itself - where it not for their victorian and aristrocratic surroundings those two would get along fine, I imagine. Nevenka never shows any sign of affection for her destined husband and, as telegraphed in the film, he makes not much effort for her either. Even the inevitably rather destructive ending has a romantic touch in itself. Bava always manages to put some unusual character development into his movie but The Whip and the Body is more extreme. That said, it would definitely go into my top-5 favorite Bava films.

One word on the rather messy censorship history: The initial european release and all subsequent home video releases lack nearly all of the "romantic" scenes between Kurt and Nevenka - Kurt is shown as a sadist and Nevenka as an unwilling victim. I canīt confirm this for every country but at least the german vhs release had the original score intact despite lacking the context and in the first american version the score is altered as well, plus the dubbing explains the killerīs identity in Kurts death scene (the voice of the assasilant calls behind a curtain). Watch this on a good and uncut dvd.

Another great review hannibalguy, Iīve recently finally seen I Vampiri and will review it, eventually. What are your thoughts on this film?
If I were to make a say, top 4 Bava list it would probably look something like this:

The Whip and the Body
Lisa and the Devil
Kill, Baby... Kill!
Black Sabbath

I'd say the VCI DVD is the way to go with The Whip and the Body, althought it might set you back a few these days. It's got great liner notes to boot which go into some good detial regarding the issues the censor's took to the film.

I've yet to see I Vampiri. Look forward to your write up!
Reply With Quote
Reply

Bookmarks

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump