ONLINE

Latest Movie Hotties Headlines

Face Off: Ellen Page vs. Mary Elizabeth Winstead

Mar. 4, 2013by: Droz

It was a tie game between Naomi Watts and Jennifer Lawrence in last week's Face Off. I can understand that. Naomi has the history, but Jennifer's got the momentum. Plus, they're both hotties in their own rights. Interesting how Jennifer seems to generate so much ire in a few of you though. I agree that she's not a traditional hottie in some respects, but she's clearly hot, talented and a truly kind, affable person. She may not be your thing visually, but why all the hate?

This week we're looking at a pair of ladies who have what I consider to be a true, natural beauty. Even without a trace of makeup, Ellen Page and Mary Elizabeth Winstead are gorgeous. Maybe it's just me, but I respect the natural beauty more than anything crafted out of blush and eye shadow tricks. To me, one is obliged to give extra love to the ladies who can go plain and still impress. But which one of these natural beauties is your favorite? Give us your vote below.

Beauty

These two have different angles on their beauty, but I like them both anyway. Ellen has that pixie-like thing happening that some have erroneously associated with being boyish. I don't know how one can look at that face and think she looks like a boy. I guess because she's got straight hair and doesn't wear gobs of makeup, she's boyish? Nothing but the best feminine qualities happening there. If you're thinking of guys when you look at her, you may have other issues you need to address.

We've spoken time and again about the inherent beauty of Mary, so I think everybody is up to speed on that. She's got those big, beautiful doe eyes and lovely, full face that I know many of you love. I suppose those qualities give her a beauty people can more easily call feminine. Or maybe it's the fact that Mary tries a little harder at that glamorous movie star thing, whereas Ellen is more the modest type. They may have different styles, but I like what they do just the same.

Body

This might be the area that prompts people to think of Ellen as the boyish type. She's not all that shapely, as least in the way many people feel a woman should be. Combine that with her tiny, 5-foot frame and the fact that she's not the sort for clothes designed to titillate and you have a reason for such presumptions. So she's never going to be a supermodel. There are worse things not to be.

Mary is probably what more of us are thinking about when we envision a truly sexy, female body. She's always had that going for her, even if she's is similarly disinclined to showing all of it off. Unfortunate that she hasn't gone there, though we've seen enough of her in various states of undress to know that if she ever decides to do a full on nude scene, it's going to be spectacular.

Hotness

Again, not an area where Ellen excels or really has any interest in excelling. That's how it looks from my perspective anyway. Turning people on doesn't seem to be Ellen's priority in most things. Maybe in private she turns into a sexual dynamo, but it's pretty clear that as far as her public and professional life goes, being perceived as hot is about the farthest thing from her mind. Or at least that's what she wants us to think.

Being a sexy creature is no issue for Mary, who is perfectly willing to turn it on when the role calls for it. I think we all remember her in that cheerleader outfit from DEATH PROOF, or better yet, seducing a horribly mismatched Michael Cera in nothing but her underwear in SCOTT PILGRIM. Girl has hotness in spades and she's not afraid to demonstrate that fact, given the opportunity.

Career

I was really tempted to give Mary the win here, just to spite the wretched JUNO, which is pretty close to being the bane of my existence. But there's no reason to get spiteful. I'm willing to overlook that one and acknowledge her more favorable performances in movies like HARD CANDY or INCEPTION or SUPER. She's got the skills and she does make some good movies. I just hope she can continue to get away from those snarky teenage roles that have threatened to typecast her in the past.

I enjoyed Mary in the recent SMASHED and I do hope she gets some better roles out of it. The quality of her performance proves she's clearly overqualified for a lot of work she's done in the past. I wont say that everything she's done outside of that movie was bad, but it's still an underwhelming resume at best. Stuff like the wretched THE THING remake or her involvement with FINAL DESTINATION series are marks against her. She did look great in all of them, though, I'll give her that.

Mary

Two fantastic ladies, different in a lot of ways, but still beautiful by nature. Doesn't matter what the angle, the lighting, the setting, the hair, the clothes, whatever - they're always stunners. Mary may come out ahead in a Face Off, but I remain equally enchanted with them both.

There's my choice. Which one is yours?
POST YOUR CHOICE BELOW...!!

MORE FUN FROM AROUND THE WEB

Drool Back
Not registered? Sign-up!
Or

4:42AM on 03/10/2013
While I like Ellen, Mary definitely takes this one
While I like Ellen, Mary definitely takes this one
Your Reply:



7:34AM on 03/06/2013

MEW

No doubt about it. MEW FTW
No doubt about it. MEW FTW
Your Reply:



+1
10:52AM on 03/05/2013

MEW

Never understood the allure of Page
Never understood the allure of Page
Your Reply:



8:52AM on 03/05/2013
I would put them at about the same. Neither one is really hotter than the other. They both seem average and there is nothing wrong with that.
I would put them at about the same. Neither one is really hotter than the other. They both seem average and there is nothing wrong with that.
Your Reply:



6:20AM on 03/05/2013
Mary. A rare woman who can not only pull off bangs but actually looks better with them.
Mary. A rare woman who can not only pull off bangs but actually looks better with them.
Your Reply:



1:22AM on 03/05/2013

This...

Isn't even close, lol.
Mary Elizabeth Winstead wins this by a long shot.
Isn't even close, lol.
Mary Elizabeth Winstead wins this by a long shot.
Your Reply:



+5
12:44AM on 03/05/2013
Mary, of course. This almost seems unfair. Ellen is cute, but I wouldn't say hot. She doesn't really have the kind of sex appeal that Mary has. Besides having an awesome body, Mary seems to have an easier time pulling off a natural sex appeal, whereas Ellen seems more down to earth and....normal, I guess. Both are great, but in terms of sheer hotness, Mary is the clear winner.
Mary, of course. This almost seems unfair. Ellen is cute, but I wouldn't say hot. She doesn't really have the kind of sex appeal that Mary has. Besides having an awesome body, Mary seems to have an easier time pulling off a natural sex appeal, whereas Ellen seems more down to earth and....normal, I guess. Both are great, but in terms of sheer hotness, Mary is the clear winner.
Your Reply:



12:42AM on 03/05/2013
So I vote for one person and get negative props? This site is full of d-bags.
So I vote for one person and get negative props? This site is full of d-bags.
Your Reply:



+6
11:02PM on 03/04/2013
While I'm a fan of both ladies,I've just gotta go with Mary.
While I'm a fan of both ladies,I've just gotta go with Mary.
Your Reply:



10:42PM on 03/04/2013

MEW for sure

I like EP and all but this one is not even close. The only one EP wins for me is career and that is BARELY. MEW crushes her in everything else.
I like EP and all but this one is not even close. The only one EP wins for me is career and that is BARELY. MEW crushes her in everything else.
Your Reply:



+3
6:10PM on 03/04/2013

I wouldn't kick either out of bed... But...

The right woman won. There's something about Mary... Hmmm... That was unfortunate. But, none the less, there is. She's got this cute, yet sexy, girl next door quality... and what's amazing is that she doesn't come across as unattainable. She seems like the kind of girl that you could approach in a bar, and it may take her a while to realize that she is way out of your league... And while Ellen seems really cool and funny, I'm not sure who would pick Ellen over Mary.
The right woman won. There's something about Mary... Hmmm... That was unfortunate. But, none the less, there is. She's got this cute, yet sexy, girl next door quality... and what's amazing is that she doesn't come across as unattainable. She seems like the kind of girl that you could approach in a bar, and it may take her a while to realize that she is way out of your league... And while Ellen seems really cool and funny, I'm not sure who would pick Ellen over Mary.
Your Reply:



+3
6:02PM on 03/04/2013

MEW

...but I'm not kicking Ellen out of bed
...but I'm not kicking Ellen out of bed
Your Reply:



5:19PM on 03/04/2013

good god

not even close. MEW by 10 billion miles.
not even close. MEW by 10 billion miles.
Your Reply:



3:24PM on 03/04/2013
DP. Sorry
DP. Sorry
Your Reply:



3:22PM on 03/04/2013

REALLY!!!???????!???

You really think this is a contest??? Winstead all the way!! She just oozes sex!!
You really think this is a contest??? Winstead all the way!! She just oozes sex!!
Your Reply:



2:31PM on 03/04/2013
Mary Elizabeth Winstead...easily.
Mary Elizabeth Winstead...easily.
Your Reply:



+11
2:26PM on 03/04/2013

Both hot

but Winstead takes this one.
but Winstead takes this one.
Your Reply:



-7
1:42PM on 03/04/2013

...

Easy. Mary is a Woman, Ellen a little girl. I actually get the distinct impression Page is a lesbo. Props to her if so!
Easy. Mary is a Woman, Ellen a little girl. I actually get the distinct impression Page is a lesbo. Props to her if so!
Your Reply:



1:32PM on 03/04/2013

Ellen

Going with Ellen Page, there' just something about Mary Elizabeth Winstead that annoys that absolute shit about me and I can't figure out what it is.
Going with Ellen Page, there' just something about Mary Elizabeth Winstead that annoys that absolute shit about me and I can't figure out what it is.
Your Reply:



1:21PM on 03/04/2013

I'm going with Mary Elizabeht Winstead

Yes, Ellen Page has had the stronger career, and I think she's the better actress, but MEW just radiates sex appeal. And yes, I suspect the rumours about Ellen are true (not that there's anything wrong with that).
Yes, Ellen Page has had the stronger career, and I think she's the better actress, but MEW just radiates sex appeal. And yes, I suspect the rumours about Ellen are true (not that there's anything wrong with that).
Your Reply:



+8
12:10PM on 03/04/2013
Mary
Mary
Your Reply:



11:50AM on 03/04/2013
Love me some Page, but MEW is what you get if you combine Sigourney Weaver with Audrey Hepburn. She's mesmerizing.
Love me some Page, but MEW is what you get if you combine Sigourney Weaver with Audrey Hepburn. She's mesmerizing.
Your Reply:



8:25PM on 03/04/2013
A combination I never thought of.
A combination I never thought of.
+1
11:07AM on 03/04/2013

Ellen Page

Mary ranks incredibly high on my list, but Miss Page ranks even higher.
Mary ranks incredibly high on my list, but Miss Page ranks even higher.
Your Reply:



10:05AM on 03/04/2013
Objectively speaking, I can see how MEW beats Page in the categories. I think subjectively though I prefer Ellen pAge
Objectively speaking, I can see how MEW beats Page in the categories. I think subjectively though I prefer Ellen pAge
Your Reply:



9:36AM on 03/04/2013

MEW

Not a fair contest, Ellen is nowhere in the same league as Mary, as far as womanliness goes...I do like Ellen Page, don't get me wrong, but she doesn't do the things for us that Mary can.
Not a fair contest, Ellen is nowhere in the same league as Mary, as far as womanliness goes...I do like Ellen Page, don't get me wrong, but she doesn't do the things for us that Mary can.
Your Reply:



8:36AM on 03/04/2013

Ellen wins for me.

Mary is beautiful but Ellen is a goddess in my eyes and far more talented. She's one of the few celebs that I would literally drop on one knee and propose the moment I met her.
Mary is beautiful but Ellen is a goddess in my eyes and far more talented. She's one of the few celebs that I would literally drop on one knee and propose the moment I met her.
Your Reply:



+11
8:34AM on 03/04/2013
Mary Mary
Mary Mary
Your Reply:



5:48AM on 03/04/2013

Man, this is tough

Like asking which one of my bollocks I would rather have yanked off.

Gonna fice it to Mary but Ellen is a megababe make no mistake.
Like asking which one of my bollocks I would rather have yanked off.

Gonna fice it to Mary but Ellen is a megababe make no mistake.
Your Reply:



-6
5:11AM on 03/04/2013
Ellen Page is too much of a hipster. I can't stand her.
Mary Elizabeth Winstead is an angel. She doesn't need my vote, because she's a winner regardless.
Ellen Page is too much of a hipster. I can't stand her.
Mary Elizabeth Winstead is an angel. She doesn't need my vote, because she's a winner regardless.
Your Reply:



4:07AM on 03/04/2013
I can't choose I like them both. Also, I never noticed how similar they look side by side.
I can't choose I like them both. Also, I never noticed how similar they look side by side.
Your Reply:



3:53AM on 03/04/2013
While Mary is definitely my fave out of the two I'd be willing to take on both of these ladies at the same time because I can't stand to see a girl with hurt feelings. I'm just that kinda guy I suppose.
While Mary is definitely my fave out of the two I'd be willing to take on both of these ladies at the same time because I can't stand to see a girl with hurt feelings. I'm just that kinda guy I suppose.
Your Reply:



-3
2:17AM on 03/04/2013
On what planet is Ellen Page considered a hottie comparable to MEW?
On what planet is Ellen Page considered a hottie comparable to MEW?
Your Reply:



+10
2:01AM on 03/04/2013

MEW

I like Ellen but I love MEW
I like Ellen but I love MEW
Your Reply:



1:48AM on 03/04/2013

MEW

This one should not even be close. Ellen Page is a good actress but far far from hot.
This one should not even be close. Ellen Page is a good actress but far far from hot.
Your Reply:



1:37AM on 03/04/2013
I'm voting for the underdog here and going with Page.
I'm voting for the underdog here and going with Page.
Your Reply:



Celebrity Boobies Of The Day

More
Readeing Rainbows

Movie Hottie Of The Week

More
Red Snapper

Most Popular Movie Hottie Stories

Latest Hot Celebrity Pictures

More
kristen-stewart kristen-stewart kristen-stewart