Latest Movie Hotties Headlines

Face Off: Evangeline Lilly vs. Elisha Cuthbert

Oct. 29, 2012by: Droz

Ya'll were like me in that you preferred Ukrainian hottie Olga Kurylenko over her hottie countrywoman Milla Jovovich by an 11 to 7 vote in last week's Face Off. I still feel kinda bad about that. Even had to go watch THE FIFTH ELEMENT again just to make it up to Milla. Still had to make the call though. Olga just packs more of the goodies I enjoy.

This week in our continuing tour of world hotties, we leave the icy conquests of former socialist empires behind and travel all the way across the Atlantic to another icy land, where the maple syrup pours almost as readily as the beer and poutine gravy. That's right folks, we're going to Canada - land of horrible weather and fantastic health care. We down here in the States tend to give Canada a hard time, though I'm not sure why. Seems like they've got their shit together better than we in the States have lately. Makes sense then that when the shit hits the fan in the US, everyone wants to go to Canada. Yet when folks start to make a name for themselves in Canada, they all want to come here. Some of the most famous people here in the States and the world are Canadians. Plenty of hotties in that pile as well, like fellow canucks Evangeline Lilly and Elisha Cuthbert.

So which Great White North hottie is your favorite, hoser? Let's see aboot it, eh?

Beauty

Evangeline is by no means ugly and in the right circumstances can be quite beautiful. I guess there were just too many Lost episodes with her looking ragged and beat to convince me that she's got something over Elisha in the beauty area. Granted, that show's focus was to keep its actors looking rode hard and put away wet most of the time, so probably not the best way to evaluate Eva's looks. Still, even when all polished and perfected, I'm still partial to Elisha here.

Elisha's got a perfect mix of true beauty and sex appeal all wrapped up in her sweet face. I like how she seems capable of turning on different aspects of her beauty at will. She can be just the cutest little baby-faced hottie in the world one moment, then a drop dead sexy enchantress the next, just by changing the expression on her face. Now, normally I'd rather the brunettes stay brunettes, but I have to admit that the blonde hair works on her, unlike many who go the blonde route. So she gets a rare blondeness pass from me.

Body

When Evangeline strips down to reveal more of her body, you'll find a somewhat mannish, tomboy look to her that does little for me. Which is weird, because on Lost she looked amazing in a set of jeans trudging through the jungle. I don't know, maybe she needs to give the workouts a rest and put on a pound or two to help her push out a few of those natural, womanly curves. Or maybe this is just how Evangeline is built. All I can say is powerful shoulders and a totally straight midsection work better on a guy than a woman.

If there is one thing you can definitely say about Elisha, it's that she's all woman. Never a moment's doubt about that when you look at her body. If I have any criticism at all for her, it's only that she doesn't show enough of it. She's come achingly close to letting the goods out in a few photo spreads, but there's always just enough covering there to both hide the goods and still keep you wanting more. Boy do I.

Hotness

Well, what can I say? If they're not impressing in the beauty or body area, their hotness potential will probably be diminished as well. That's not the thing of it though. Evangeline seems like a pretty cool person and I don't really have a problem with her, apart from the mild to moderate lack of femininity in her body. Still, that's enough to put her behind Elisha here as well, I'm sad to say. Also, I'm not in the mood for a tie.

Come on, you gotta give the hotness award to the one person in the match who was hot enough to play a porn star. She played that part well too. Only actual porn stars are more convincing. Elisha's got that vibe about her that's always just a little bit naughty. She can make those sexy faces and twist herself into those provocative poses that really ramp up the hotness. It's like she's made a point of inserting a certain amount of hotness into her celebrity persona. It shows.

Career

Gotta give one to Eva and this category is probably the thing about her that really stands out to me. I was such a Lost fan - right until the finale anyway. And "Freckles" was a big part of that. The whole love triangle thing between Kate, Sawyer and Jack was one of those aspects of the show that things kind of pivoted on. Whether the survivors of Oceanic flight 815 either fractured or came together often depended on how Kate was received by one or both of her male suitors on that show. I can see that. Of all the ladies on that initial crash scene, Kate was the most eligible. I'd probably have developed a thing for her too.

I haven't been as engrossed in a lot of Elisha's work. That might be because she went off the radar for awhile when she married her hockey player guy (a distinctly Canadian move on her part), or it might be that her roles just haven't been the sorts of things that interest me. I've seen a couple of her movies and a handful of episodes of 24 she did. Not much else of interest though, which is surprising. You'd think a hottie like Elisha would be everywhere.

Elisha

Yep, I can't hide the fact that I got a thing for Elisha. She almost sweeps here, save for a few somewhat lackluster career choices. Evangeline is a fun, personable woman and when put in the right light, a fairly hot lady. There's just something missing there for me, though. Occasionally she brings the hotness, but the tomboy vibe that underlies her look just isn't my thing. Elisha's got just about everything I like in a woman, which makes her the obvious choice for me.

That's my pick. Which one is yours?
POST YOUR CHOICE BELOW...!!
Tags: Face-Off

Related Articles

MORE FUN FROM AROUND THE WEB

Drool Back
Not registered? Sign-up!
Or

+0
3:07AM on 11/02/2012
Elisha, most definitely.
Elisha, most definitely.
Your Reply:



-1
9:10AM on 10/30/2012
Cuthbert hands down!
Cuthbert hands down!
Your Reply:



6:40PM on 10/29/2012

Evangeline does not have a manish body

She's athletic for fucks sake.
She's athletic for fucks sake.
Your Reply:



6:11PM on 10/29/2012
I just want to cover them both in maple syrup, see their "O" Canada face, and have them play with me timbits. Then I'd like to see Elisha give Evangeline a Reverse Rick Moranis. After that I would join in again giving Elisha the Full Mountie, and Evangeline the Sneaky Snowplow. Finally, we'd end the evening with Two Girls, One Stanley Cup. Congrats Elisha. Fuck I love Canada.
I just want to cover them both in maple syrup, see their "O" Canada face, and have them play with me timbits. Then I'd like to see Elisha give Evangeline a Reverse Rick Moranis. After that I would join in again giving Elisha the Full Mountie, and Evangeline the Sneaky Snowplow. Finally, we'd end the evening with Two Girls, One Stanley Cup. Congrats Elisha. Fuck I love Canada.
Your Reply:



3:36PM on 10/29/2012

Not a fan of either

but that's who I'd have picked too.
but that's who I'd have picked too.
Your Reply:



1:32PM on 10/29/2012
I have to admit, Elisha probably deserves to get the landslide victory here. She definitely is hot, but I've always had a thing for Evangeline, so somehow logic just goes right through the window for me. Maybe it has something to do with seeing her in more movies/shows (Lost, Real Steel, soon to be the Hobbit, ect), maybe it has to do with my preference for brunettes, but i gotta go with the gorgeous Ms. Lilly here, logic be damned!
I have to admit, Elisha probably deserves to get the landslide victory here. She definitely is hot, but I've always had a thing for Evangeline, so somehow logic just goes right through the window for me. Maybe it has something to do with seeing her in more movies/shows (Lost, Real Steel, soon to be the Hobbit, ect), maybe it has to do with my preference for brunettes, but i gotta go with the gorgeous Ms. Lilly here, logic be damned!
Your Reply:



+1
1:30PM on 10/29/2012
Cuthbert wins , but it ain't by much . Evangeline is freakin' FINE !!
Cuthbert wins , but it ain't by much . Evangeline is freakin' FINE !!
Your Reply:



12:37PM on 10/29/2012

Elisha

Yes, Evangeline's got the sweeter career (Hello, Hobbit!) but Elisha brings Nigella-levels of sexiness to the table. Besides, you gotta love a girl who has a hockey blog.
Yes, Evangeline's got the sweeter career (Hello, Hobbit!) but Elisha brings Nigella-levels of sexiness to the table. Besides, you gotta love a girl who has a hockey blog.
Your Reply:



11:43AM on 10/29/2012

Elisha

would have won against just about any woman on the planet as far as i'm concerned
would have won against just about any woman on the planet as far as i'm concerned
Your Reply:



11:43AM on 10/29/2012

Elisha

would have won against just about any woman on the planet as far as i'm concerned
would have won against just about any woman on the planet as far as i'm concerned
Your Reply:



+2
11:32AM on 10/29/2012
I would give Beauty and Career to Lily and then because I like her more I would give her the final win.

In answer to Can Ispeak To Ken, Lily is about to be involved in what will likely be one of the biggest movie trilogies of all time..
I would give Beauty and Career to Lily and then because I like her more I would give her the final win.

In answer to Can Ispeak To Ken, Lily is about to be involved in what will likely be one of the biggest movie trilogies of all time..
Your Reply:



8:44AM on 10/29/2012

Lilly is beautiful

But Cuthbert is just plain sexy
But Cuthbert is just plain sexy
Your Reply:



+3
5:00AM on 10/29/2012

No Read-Through Required

Elisha simply makes me ACHE. If body cells had penises each and every one of mine would be be in "raging hard-on" state, begging for attention from the woman. She is fantastic.
Elisha simply makes me ACHE. If body cells had penises each and every one of mine would be be in "raging hard-on" state, begging for attention from the woman. She is fantastic.
Your Reply:



4:16AM on 10/29/2012

Elisha loses EVERY category......

Evangeline Lilly should have won it all.
Evangeline Lilly should have won it all.
Your Reply:



3:44AM on 10/29/2012
I would have given career to Elisha as well. 24 was a big show much like Lost and now she's currently on Happy Endings. H.E. is doing well and it's in its third season, not to mention she is drop dead funny in that. Whereas, Evangeline Lilly is kind of absent at the moment.
I would have given career to Elisha as well. 24 was a big show much like Lost and now she's currently on Happy Endings. H.E. is doing well and it's in its third season, not to mention she is drop dead funny in that. Whereas, Evangeline Lilly is kind of absent at the moment.
Your Reply:



3:35AM on 10/29/2012

100%

Elisha is a walking blonde goddess.
Elisha is a walking blonde goddess.
Your Reply:



3:33AM on 10/29/2012
all elisha all the time
all elisha all the time
Your Reply:



2:31AM on 10/29/2012

Elisha

I totally agree....Elisha wins hands down and I think she may even take the career category too. What movie has Evangeline ever headlined? Elisha was brilliant in the girl next door and has done well in TV with Happy Endings and 24
I totally agree....Elisha wins hands down and I think she may even take the career category too. What movie has Evangeline ever headlined? Elisha was brilliant in the girl next door and has done well in TV with Happy Endings and 24
Your Reply:



+4
1:24AM on 10/29/2012
While I certainly wouldn't kick Evangeline out of the hammock, I have to say I agree with this outcome. Elisha is the hotter, no doubt. I bet she has an annoying personality though.
While I certainly wouldn't kick Evangeline out of the hammock, I have to say I agree with this outcome. Elisha is the hotter, no doubt. I bet she has an annoying personality though.
Your Reply:



4:27PM on 10/29/2012
That may well be true, I honestly don't know. But that being said, there are also celebrities that interview well but are douches off-camera. Not saying she is one, because again, I don't know.
That may well be true, I honestly don't know. But that being said, there are also celebrities that interview well but are douches off-camera. Not saying she is one, because again, I don't know.
11:28AM on 10/29/2012
You couldn't be more wrong, watch some interviews with her..shes fucking awesome. She loves going to big Rock festivals and loves Tool.
You couldn't be more wrong, watch some interviews with her..shes fucking awesome. She loves going to big Rock festivals and loves Tool.
1:12AM on 10/29/2012
I'd give every category to Elisha including career. She is hilarious in Happy Endings and is one of my favorite comedic characters on TV right now..
I'd give every category to Elisha including career. She is hilarious in Happy Endings and is one of my favorite comedic characters on TV right now..
Your Reply:



Boobies Of The Day

More
Kim's Keepers

Hottie Of The Week

More
Transcendent Hottie

Latest Pictures

More
rosamund-pike rosamund-pike rosamund-pike