Latest Horror Movie Headlines

THE F*CKING BLACK SHEEP: Hellboy (2004)

12.22.2011by: Ryan Doom
100%

THE BLACK SHEEP is an ongoing column featuring different takes on films that either the writer HATED, but that the majority of film fans LOVED, or that the writer LOVED, but that most others LOATH. We're hoping this column will promote constructive and geek fueled discussion. Dig in!

Hellboy (2004)
Directed by Guillermo del Toro

“Some things simply don’t translate to the big screen. Men in rubber costumes certainly don’t.”

I should start this with an upfront admission. One, this isn't a Christmas movie, but it does star a demon from hell. Two, I’m a Hellboy fan. I’ve been collecting Mike Mignola’s various mini series since the 1990’s, starting with Seed of Destruction if I can remember that far back (which served as the basis for this movie). I always loved the darkness, the humor, the paranormal, and the damn weirdness. It read and looked like nothing else.

Now, while this column is an explanation of why Hellboy doesn’t hold up on repeat viewings, I don’t have anything negative to say about Ron Perlman. This is his movie, and it finally gave him the chance to make him a household name. Sure, dude once again didn’t show his face, but Hellboy relaunched his career. I think it made people remember him and think he’d make a good biker. Plus, he got to shoot some bad ass giant guns.

Anyway, if anyone could bring Hellboy to the screen, it would seem to be del Toro as he has one of those unique signature styles like a Tim Burton or a David Cronenberg. However, as unique as his vision is, his movies feel hokey, always a bit corny on a number of different fronts. I suppose that’s the reason he’s the “perfect fit” for a movie like this. Combine demon characters with humor and action and you've got box office gold. Or at least box office bronze. The problem with adaptations is that they forget they’re an adaptation, not a copy. I wanted to see del Toro create his own vision of the character, take him to a darker, meaner place. Instead, he, much like Zack Snyder, remained faithful to a fault. Hellboy didn’t have to go gruesome R, but it could it could have taken a page from more successful films like V for Vendetta, which could have been unwatchable if humor dominated; instead it was serious, playful, and brutal. It was everything that Hellboy could have been.

By no means is Hellboy the worst movie ever created. With Del Toro’s visual style, it’s hard not to enjoy. Looking back though, I’m not so sure Hellboy stands the test of time. Maybe it’s Christopher Nolan’s fault. Or perhaps Richard Donner’s. Minus a handful of films, I now like my comic movies on the serious side or at least a blend of reality with fiction. Hellboy does attempt to do that. Unfortunately, a man in a giant red rubber suit makes it tough to believe. He reminds me of The Thing from Fantastic Four. Some things simply don’t translate to the big screen. Men in rubber costumes certainly don’t. The same goes for Dr. Manhattan in Watchmen. Shit ends up looking cheesy even if well done. Hellboy certainly is. Pearlman’s makeup is flawless, and it looks as if it didn’t limit his mobility. But the rest of the special effects looked dated, if not down right fake. At least it does have a bad ass Nazi samurai.

Another annoyance comes from the tongue and cheek humor and the romance. The latter works to some extent, but it ends up just awkward and maybe even a little forced. For the former, seriously, does anyone really laugh at one-liners? When Hellboy rescues a box full of kittens during a subway brawl with a demon, the demon’s tentacles latch onto our hero, who replies, “Second date. No tongue.” On comic paper, it’s amusing, but in the context of an epic movie battle, it’s dumb, lowbrow. It removes tension and becomes another dumbed-down action movie.

Not that there’s anything wrong with that. I love 80’s cheese, but sometimes when watching that selection brand of cheese, I wonder what the film could have been if it had taken itself just a little bit more seriously. What if Hellboy would have been in hands of a David Fincher or David Cronenberg? Now that would have been something.

GET HELLBOY DVD HERE

GET HELLBOY BLU RAY HERE

RECOMMENDED MOVIE NEWS

MORE FUN FROM AROUND THE WEB

Spitting Bullets
Not registered? Sign-up!
Or

10:02AM on 12/23/2011
I disagree with this whole article. I love 80's cheeze (when done right), Hellboy (the film), and comic book adaptations that have a little of that comic pulp to them. I also didn't care for the V For Vendetta film. But you know what? That's why these "Black Sheep" articles are written in the first place. It was a great read, regardless of where I stand politically on the topic! :)
I disagree with this whole article. I love 80's cheeze (when done right), Hellboy (the film), and comic book adaptations that have a little of that comic pulp to them. I also didn't care for the V For Vendetta film. But you know what? That's why these "Black Sheep" articles are written in the first place. It was a great read, regardless of where I stand politically on the topic! :)
Your Reply:



Please email me when someone replies to my comment
6:43PM on 12/22/2011
I thought the second film was better as well...

i also think it's kinda messed up to say fincher would make a better hellboy film
I thought the second film was better as well...

i also think it's kinda messed up to say fincher would make a better hellboy film
Your Reply:



Please email me when someone replies to my comment
12:36PM on 12/22/2011
I actually dug part II better than part I. I dug the whole concept of a war of man (and demon) vs angry ninja kung fu monster...while I did dig part I, it always felt like there was something missing. also it felt very claustrophobic for such an expansive world...part II addressed that and made up for it.
I actually dug part II better than part I. I dug the whole concept of a war of man (and demon) vs angry ninja kung fu monster...while I did dig part I, it always felt like there was something missing. also it felt very claustrophobic for such an expansive world...part II addressed that and made up for it.
Your Reply:



Please email me when someone replies to my comment
9:51AM on 12/22/2011
I loved Hellboy, Helboy 2 on the other hand, I dug less than the OG... was kind of a let down for me...
I loved Hellboy, Helboy 2 on the other hand, I dug less than the OG... was kind of a let down for me...
Your Reply:



Please email me when someone replies to my comment
View All Comments

Latest Movie News Headlines


Top
Loading...

Featured Youtube Videos

Views and Counting

Mistress Of The Week

More
Lowndes, Jessica