CAST THIS: Superman | Movie News

CAST THIS: Superman
Comments: 142
terometer
99%
Strike Back below!
by: Paul Tassi Jul. 15, 2010

Aw man, just when I was going to do a HULK casting column, they had to go and sign up Mark Ruffalo like one day after Norton peaced out. Marvel doesn’t waste any time do they?

Well, DC does, and we haven’t heard much of anything about the SUPERMAN reboot in quite sometime, so I decided it was time to change that. Jonathan Nolan is writing a script, and has been rumored to direct (though so has Chris Columbus, which proved false, so who knows), but now we really need a new Man of Steel as presumably Routh won’t be returning (though I suppose he could be). Who would be your ideal SUPERMAN?

It’s the role that most actors would only dream of, and only a few have played the part over the years in TV and film. Past incarnations of Superman reboots have been rumored to be really random, like, Nicolas Cage random, but I don’t think the studio would want to take any such gamble this time.

But producer Chris Nolan is the man who took the change of Heath Ledger playing the Joker, as he saw something there that no one else did, so I wouldn’t be entirely surprised if we get a pretty out there pick for Superman when things finally do start coming together.

Young? Old? Who knows? I highly doubt this will be an origin story, and I bet Nolan has something out of the ordinary planned for the plot. You all know “the look,” so who do you think should be his new face in the reboot, or should Routh be given one more shot with a new team behind him?

Last Week: MORIARTY

Last week we took a look at who should play Sherlock Holmes’ nemesis Moriarty in the HOLMES sequel, now that it seemed Brad Pitt wasn’t in the running anymore. Who did you pick?

1. Daniel Day-Lewis (13%) 2. Christoph Waltz (11%) 3. Hugh Laurie (9%)

Good show lads, I think this is a fine selection. Daniel Day-Lewis is clearly an excellent choice no matter the role, but I could see him being particularly effective here.

Christoph Waltz is another good choice, as he’s more than proven his villainous chops so far in INGLOURIOUS BASTERDS. As for Hugh Laurie? Everyone’s been begging for him to make a major jump to the big screen, and this could be a good time to do that.

OK, who should be Supes?

Source: JoBlo.com

Add to MFC Profile

Extra Tidbit: I don't know, even though it's classic, this costume just always looks ridiculous onscreen to me.

142 discussions Expand all
Show Oldest First  |  Newest First  |  Most Popular
 
+1
Vote Up Vote Down
TreyTravesty
12:31PM on 08/13/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
I think he'd be great
Joe Manganiello =]
Joe Manganiello =]
 
+1
Vote Up Vote Down
Funployee
2:15AM on 07/25/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
I say Ed Norton. That way, by the time they make a JLA movie they can replace him.
I say Ed Norton. That way, by the time they make a JLA movie they can replace him.
 
-3
Vote Up Vote Down
track100
5:39AM on 07/24/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Gerard Christopher
[link] I also have someone else in mind who's sorta played him before too. Guess who.
[link] I also have someone else in mind who's sorta played him before too. Guess who.
 
-3
Vote Up Vote Down
Paupersoul
11:11PM on 07/22/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Let's be realists...
Neither Routh nor Welling will be attached to this project. Period. Sorry, 'Smallville' fans (I -- like GeneralZod -- have seen every episode, making similar vows never to watch the show again, but sadly crawling back each week, just in case it inexplicably gets good after 9 years), but we're more likely to see the Nolans do an onscreen adaptation of James Earl Jones doing a staged reading of...
Neither Routh nor Welling will be attached to this project. Period. Sorry, 'Smallville' fans (I -- like GeneralZod -- have seen every episode, making similar vows never to watch the show again, but sadly crawling back each week, just in case it inexplicably gets good after 9 years), but we're more likely to see the Nolans do an onscreen adaptation of James Earl Jones doing a staged reading of 'Mein Kampf' than see Welling attached to this current project.



Routh, despite Singer's best efforts, I liked. But his contract is expired and he has not been asked back. Let's move on.



It's been publicized that they're looking at TV actors. In the unlikely event that the Nolans call me up to ask my opinion or browse the suggestions here on JoBlo.com, I agree with the front-runner in this forum: Jon Hamm. The idea is exciting and actually gives me hope that I might see a screen adaptation of Superman that is as true to the spirit of the character as Nolan's Batman films have been to its respective characters. (Also, if they press me further, I'll tell them, "Chris. Jonah. A modern picture with a 1930's aesthetic is the best way to go. But, hey, that's just my take on it... More tea?")



But, like I said: Let's be realistic. I'm not expecting a call from the Nolans. And those regurgitating "Routh/Welling" shouldn't expect one either.
 
-13
Vote Up Vote Down
luckystryker
6:40PM on 07/20/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Cillian Murphy
He has the looks, the acting chops and the connection with Nolan for this to be realistic
He has the looks, the acting chops and the connection with Nolan for this to be realistic
 
-8
Vote Up Vote Down
jazzman
3:20PM on 07/19/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Set Supes in the 1930's and bring in Jon Hamm for that classic look. Otherwise give Routh another chance with the Nolan's. After all the best Superman is no longer with us.
Set Supes in the 1930's and bring in Jon Hamm for that classic look. Otherwise give Routh another chance with the Nolan's. After all the best Superman is no longer with us.
 
-15
Vote Up Vote Down
darthbrowncoat
1:32PM on 07/19/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Inceptiony
You know who I could see them picking as an out of the box pick, Leo. I could see them doing a tormented supes that Leo could do so well. But my pick is routh
You know who I could see them picking as an out of the box pick, Leo. I could see them doing a tormented supes that Leo could do so well. But my pick is routh
 
-12
Vote Up Vote Down
lalex81
4:45AM on 07/19/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Jared Padalecki
He is the only young actor that I think can pull off Clark Kent and Superman.

His look isn't exactly like the traditional comic book one but sometimes a good actor is better than an actor with the right look.
He is the only young actor that I think can pull off Clark Kent and Superman.

His look isn't exactly like the traditional comic book one but sometimes a good actor is better than an actor with the right look.
 
-10
Vote Up Vote Down
GeneralZod
8:28PM on 07/18/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Tough Choice
Look, I really don't see why everyone constantly screams for Welling. I have seen every episode of Smallville hoping it will achieve it's potential (often vowing never to watch it again as the credits roll), but he is not Superman. He has never been Superman and could not carry the epic movie that Supes needs! Not to mention all the damn baggage he would bring with him...is that really the...
Look, I really don't see why everyone constantly screams for Welling. I have seen every episode of Smallville hoping it will achieve it's potential (often vowing never to watch it again as the credits roll), but he is not Superman. He has never been Superman and could not carry the epic movie that Supes needs! Not to mention all the damn baggage he would bring with him...is that really the Mxyzptlk, Brainiac, and Doomsday you want to see on the big screen?



I thought Routh did a great job, but he has the same issue. Super-son was just stupid as shit.



Is Hamm too old to play SuperMAN? I don't really think so and he could definitely bring the level of acting needed.



In the end, I have faith in the Nolan's, since I would never of chosen Ledger for the Joker.
 
-7
Vote Up Vote Down
hYPE
3:00PM on 07/18/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Okay...
I can totally see Jon Hamm as Clark Kent/Superman! I'm now a fan!
I can totally see Jon Hamm as Clark Kent/Superman! I'm now a fan!
 
-9
Vote Up Vote Down
Geronimo1984
9:24AM on 07/18/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Dean Cain
FTW
FTW
 
-19
Vote Up Vote Down
nokio
8:36PM on 07/17/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Keep Routh as Supes
I see no need to go the way of marvel and recast major characters when there is no need to. Rough was good as Supes. Blame Singer for that crap he managed to crank out. I remember when everyone was just licking up the koolaid cause Singer was at the helm. I voiced my opinion when it was 1st announced that Superman Returns was going to be terriably mediocre. Singer does not have a directorial...
I see no need to go the way of marvel and recast major characters when there is no need to. Rough was good as Supes. Blame Singer for that crap he managed to crank out. I remember when everyone was just licking up the koolaid cause Singer was at the helm. I voiced my opinion when it was 1st announced that Superman Returns was going to be terriably mediocre. Singer does not have a directorial eye for this genre.
 
-3
Vote Up Vote Down
Caats19
12:40PM on 07/17/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
i have no idea
just like nobody knew christopher reeve or brandon routh, i don't wanna have heard of the guy. FIND ME SUPERMAN.
just like nobody knew christopher reeve or brandon routh, i don't wanna have heard of the guy. FIND ME SUPERMAN.
 
-10
Vote Up Vote Down
Otis_Driftwood
12:51AM on 07/17/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Depends...
Jon Hamm would be a great pick for the "Alex Ross" Superman depicted above. Ross' Superman is a little older than the Superman some of us are use to.



Brandon Routh would be OK returning for the "standard" Superman.



I like the Ross one best though.
Jon Hamm would be a great pick for the "Alex Ross" Superman depicted above. Ross' Superman is a little older than the Superman some of us are use to.



Brandon Routh would be OK returning for the "standard" Superman.



I like the Ross one best though.
 
-12
Vote Up Vote Down
mouldy311
12:12AM on 07/17/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
brandon routh
brandon routh
 
-11
Vote Up Vote Down
spacemonkee414
12:04AM on 07/17/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
brandon routh should return. he did a great job.
brandon routh should return. he did a great job.
 
+3
Vote Up Vote Down
KingsOfAwesome
11:47PM on 07/16/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
HAMM
Well said, Princess Kate. I believe Welling deserves the part but you certainly make a convincing argument for Hamm. I'd be willing to set my opinions aside to give him a shot at taking up the mantle.
Well said, Princess Kate. I believe Welling deserves the part but you certainly make a convincing argument for Hamm. I'd be willing to set my opinions aside to give him a shot at taking up the mantle.
 
-11
Vote Up Vote Down
Raegoul
10:43PM on 07/16/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Brandon Routh
There is no need to change he did a great job and as proven in 'Chuck' he is still doing Superman justice. Add to that he has more experience now and should be more comfortable in the role. He can only get better which is a good thing.
There is no need to change he did a great job and as proven in 'Chuck' he is still doing Superman justice. Add to that he has more experience now and should be more comfortable in the role. He can only get better which is a good thing.
 
-13
Vote Up Vote Down
darthbrowncoat
8:21PM on 07/16/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
No Need
for a change, Brandon Routh is the perfect superman, leave him be.
for a change, Brandon Routh is the perfect superman, leave him be.
 
-24
Vote Up Vote Down
aquaticoutlaw
5:01PM on 07/16/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
ZACHARY LEVI
I believe Chuck himself would make an awesome Superman/Clark Kent. He plays a great nice guy, and he can do the action stuff as well.
I believe Chuck himself would make an awesome Superman/Clark Kent. He plays a great nice guy, and he can do the action stuff as well.
 
-5
Vote Up Vote Down
Princess Kate
4:39PM on 07/16/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Superman/Kal-el/CK Character Study
I think Richard Donner hit on something profound with the original when his production motto, was "verasimilitude", and Christopher Reeves keyed in on a very revelatory observation about his character, as described to him by Donner. The two of them realized the complexity of the Superman character, essesentially embodying MULTIPLE identities. There is a true Identity Crisis, playing out...
I think Richard Donner hit on something profound with the original when his production motto, was "verasimilitude", and Christopher Reeves keyed in on a very revelatory observation about his character, as described to him by Donner. The two of them realized the complexity of the Superman character, essesentially embodying MULTIPLE identities. There is a true Identity Crisis, playing out within him.



Let me just say, I am not against either Brandon Routh or Tom Welling, in the role, and as much of a division as there is regarding Welling, he has played the character for years, over several seasons, and understands the character and actually cameoed with the late Christopher Reeves, so he has an advantage, in several ways. Routh, on the other hand has potential and brand recognition now with the character after "Returns" but the production altered canon, that has unleashed some very visible outcries.



Looking through the posts, there is tremendous support for John Hamm, and I side on that fence, for several reasons. Many are logical.



After watching Hamm in the new Ben Affleck Film "The Town", the man obviously fits in a Nolan-esque Universe, as that film oozes with a Nolan vibe, albeit I also beleive that film, will stand on it's own.



John Hamm matches the legacy of the Superman Source Material in so many ways.



He is a modern actor who immediately reminds us of the icons of the 40s & 50s, where the character originated, and closer to Schuster & Siegel creation.



He's definitely got the acting chops, and he can hammer home the Complexity of Superman's Identities: Kal-El, Son of Krypton and the subtlety that goes with losing an entire ancestry to Genocide (if anyone ever wanted to take this seriously, they could look to "Schindler's List" as a reference), Clark Kent, well Tom Welling has epitomized this for years, but Hamm could study Welling and pull from this performance and make it his own, reinterpreting and filling in the holes and make it fit a more serious production where the character has evolved beyond his Smallville Origins to the hustle & bustle of a Mega City, you see his Clark Kent being more Metropolitan, from Affleck's "The Town" and Hamm's "Mad Men" origins, once again, a perfect fit in the Nolanverse, and he could differentiate his Clark Kent and Superman, by carrying his natural nobility.



But the dynamic of Identity Crisis, was really Character Studied by Reeves from bad vs. good Superman, to Kal-El vs. Clark... the character is Complex and it seems very evident that Hamm can pick up on these nuances especially with both Nolans at the helm.



And about Age, as someone else mentioned Robert Downey Jr. is in his mid 40s, and he's playing Ironman, whereas Hamm is 39, so there you go.
 
+1
Vote Up Vote Down
Bicycle_Thief
2:44PM on 07/16/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Will Smith!
"Kryptonyte.... Aahh Hell Naah"
"Kryptonyte.... Aahh Hell Naah"
 
-12
Vote Up Vote Down
oilahize
2:32PM on 07/16/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Brandon Routh
I like him in the role. Should maybe beef up more than in the last movie...
I like him in the role. Should maybe beef up more than in the last movie...
 
-14
Vote Up Vote Down
aaa516
2:13PM on 07/16/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
He's got the look and he's 6'3.
He's got the look and he's 6'3.
 
-10
Vote Up Vote Down
aaa516
2:12PM on 07/16/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Victor Webster
Victor Webster
 
-20
Vote Up Vote Down
calum79
1:38PM on 07/16/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
get karl urban on this he would own it.
get karl urban on this he would own it.
1 Reply
 
Winchester08
3:47PM on 07/16/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
i would definitely like to see him as a leading man..hes got talent.
i would definitely like to see him as a leading man..hes got talent.
 
-8
Vote Up Vote Down
iKev
1:05PM on 07/16/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
See....
I love Jon Hamm, but I feel he would have made the perfect Batman/Bruce Wayne. He's got too much of a dark side thing going on to play boyscout kal el. Although that could play to our advantage. Ok, nvm. I'm on the Hamm train....
I love Jon Hamm, but I feel he would have made the perfect Batman/Bruce Wayne. He's got too much of a dark side thing going on to play boyscout kal el. Although that could play to our advantage. Ok, nvm. I'm on the Hamm train....
 
-8
Vote Up Vote Down
HedwigX
11:26AM on 07/16/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Has to be...
Jon Hamm!
Jon Hamm!
 
-16
Vote Up Vote Down
BaronDoomsday
10:59AM on 07/16/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Neither Welling or Routh
I'm sorry but they are both terrible choices. I can't stand either one of them as Superman. I think Jon Hamm is kind of an inspired choice. I think we need to see Supes a little older this time. I'm sick of all this kiddie stuff.
I'm sorry but they are both terrible choices. I can't stand either one of them as Superman. I think Jon Hamm is kind of an inspired choice. I think we need to see Supes a little older this time. I'm sick of all this kiddie stuff.
 
-14
Vote Up Vote Down
lalex81
9:30AM on 07/16/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Kellan Lutz
Anyone but Sam Worthington. I'm a fan of the guy, but he isn't Superman and for sure we'll be hearing his name tossed around.
Anyone but Sam Worthington. I'm a fan of the guy, but he isn't Superman and for sure we'll be hearing his name tossed around.
 
-12
Vote Up Vote Down
Huttjos
8:16AM on 07/16/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Jon [link] I LOVE THAT
Jon [link] I LOVE THAT
 
-8
Vote Up Vote Down
SoundGirl
8:06AM on 07/16/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
I think the Tom Welling fans need to realize that a Smallville movie is never going to happen. Why? Because it would actually require The CW to put some money into production values, and clearly that's just not an option they're willing to consider.
I think the Tom Welling fans need to realize that a Smallville movie is never going to happen. Why? Because it would actually require The CW to put some money into production values, and clearly that's just not an option they're willing to consider.
 
-9
Vote Up Vote Down
martinphipps
6:51AM on 07/16/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Routh
Brandon Routh
Brandon Routh
 
-11
Vote Up Vote Down
jackieboy
4:47AM on 07/16/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
superman
i would say jon hamm, but he is old. i can imagine them wanting to make a series out of these films, so i would have to go with an unknown.
i would say jon hamm, but he is old. i can imagine them wanting to make a series out of these films, so i would have to go with an unknown.
 
-9
Vote Up Vote Down
drc5145
4:24AM on 07/16/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Jon Hamm. Nearly looks like a real-life Clark Kent and Superman. Talented actor obviously to boot.
Jon Hamm. Nearly looks like a real-life Clark Kent and Superman. Talented actor obviously to boot.
 
-7
Vote Up Vote Down
JimmyJamOn
3:40AM on 07/16/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Keep Brandon.....
.....I don't care what you say, Routh did a good job. Much better than Seth Rogan could ever do with the GH.
.....I don't care what you say, Routh did a good job. Much better than Seth Rogan could ever do with the GH.
 
-10
Vote Up Vote Down
darknite125
1:08AM on 07/16/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Jon Hamm
Jon Hamm
 
-22
Vote Up Vote Down
Stratburst
1:08AM on 07/16/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Michael C. Hall for older Superman?
He has the jawline and the chops. Of course, everyone will look at him and think "Superman serial killer" but it would be an inspired choice.



People are saying Brandon Routh and Tom Welling because they've both done excellent work in the role already. Routh especially deserved better.
He has the jawline and the chops. Of course, everyone will look at him and think "Superman serial killer" but it would be an inspired choice.



People are saying Brandon Routh and Tom Welling because they've both done excellent work in the role already. Routh especially deserved better.
 
+0
Vote Up Vote Down
Johnboy16
12:35AM on 07/16/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Chuck Norris
Chuck Norris
1 Reply
 
Winchester08
6:15PM on 07/16/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Chuck Norris can kick Superman's ass
Chuck Norris can kick Superman's ass
 
-17
Vote Up Vote Down
drufish
12:15AM on 07/16/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
henry cavill
has the look and a good young actor

oddette yustman or emmy rossum for lois
has the look and a good young actor

oddette yustman or emmy rossum for lois
 
-9
Vote Up Vote Down
hYPE
12:08AM on 07/16/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
I want...
None of thee above!
None of thee above!
 
-18
Vote Up Vote Down
deja vu
12:01AM on 07/16/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
obligatory john krasinski post.
obligatory john krasinski post.
 
-19
Vote Up Vote Down
luckystryker
11:55PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
An older Supes
Let's cast Billy Zane. He deserves to go down with a bang...
Let's cast Billy Zane. He deserves to go down with a bang...
1 Reply
 
Winchester08
6:18PM on 07/16/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
he'd be good for Lex Luther if they went older..but not for Sups
he'd be good for Lex Luther if they went older..but not for Sups
 
-16
Vote Up Vote Down
RichterJet
11:33PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
I think Henry Cavill would be pretty freaking amazing with a role like this...
I think Henry Cavill would be pretty freaking amazing with a role like this...
 
-14
Vote Up Vote Down
KenMasters
10:26PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Henry Cavill looks the part to me.
Henry Cavill looks the part to me.
 
-1
Vote Up Vote Down
barryallen_thef
10:24PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
my vote is stil Routh and short of that Tom Wellings...as for the Moriaty i think Christopher Waltz is a win-win for me
my vote is stil Routh and short of that Tom Wellings...as for the Moriaty i think Christopher Waltz is a win-win for me
 
+12
Vote Up Vote Down
The_alpz
10:22PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Tom Welling is and will always be Superman to me
Tom Welling is and will always be Superman to me
 
-17
Vote Up Vote Down
Brer B8a
10:18PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Dean Cain because I can only spread my choices out between those that have played him already.
Dean Cain because I can only spread my choices out between those that have played him already.
 
-19
Vote Up Vote Down
SoundGirl
10:17PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Cillian Murphy... if only he were a little taller and beefier. Just look at that face!
Cillian Murphy... if only he were a little taller and beefier. Just look at that face!
 
-22
Vote Up Vote Down
Brer B8a
10:16PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
God dam, cant anyone be more original than Routh and Welling?
God dam, cant anyone be more original than Routh and Welling?
 
-11
Vote Up Vote Down
PSUDelVec
10:10PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Jon Hamm
He's just too perfect for it to cast anyone else.
He's just too perfect for it to cast anyone else.
 
-8
Vote Up Vote Down
AlteredEffect
9:47PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Brandon Routh
Brandon Routh. To me he is SUPERMAN! And i'm sorry guys... I don't want to see Smallvile the movie. I say bring back the cast from Returns and change the direction a bit. Continue the franchise with a compelling action driven story. Surprise us with something spectacular like what Donner's Superman II could have been.
Brandon Routh. To me he is SUPERMAN! And i'm sorry guys... I don't want to see Smallvile the movie. I say bring back the cast from Returns and change the direction a bit. Continue the franchise with a compelling action driven story. Surprise us with something spectacular like what Donner's Superman II could have been.
 
-8
Vote Up Vote Down
Mac136187
9:46PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Routh
Im down for Brandon Routh. He was great in Superman Returns and deserves to keep it going.
Im down for Brandon Routh. He was great in Superman Returns and deserves to keep it going.
 
-1
Vote Up Vote Down
ebrock
9:31PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Older Cast:

John Hamm as Superman/Clark & Charisma Carpenter as Lois

Young Cast:

Tom Welling as Superman/Clark & Sarah Carter as Lois
Older Cast:

John Hamm as Superman/Clark & Charisma Carpenter as Lois

Young Cast:

Tom Welling as Superman/Clark & Sarah Carter as Lois
 
+2
Vote Up Vote Down
lorddeath
9:29PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
welling or routh
hamm not a chance, only 2 people could pull off superman. first and best choice overall is tom welling,second and last choice is rothe. no others, no matter what anyone believes is good enough to fill role.
hamm not a chance, only 2 people could pull off superman. first and best choice overall is tom welling,second and last choice is rothe. no others, no matter what anyone believes is good enough to fill role.
 
-11
Vote Up Vote Down
Potter82
8:49PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Hamm for Superman!
When I first saw this? I, like many other posters below me, immediately thought Jon Hamm. Why? His classic 40/50s good looks on Mad Men fit the image most people have of Superman. Plus he's a good actor. I can see his Superman being humble yet likeable. It's also helps that he's close to 40 - so we'd have a superMAN, not superBOY.



Of course, knowing youth obsessed Hollywood,...
When I first saw this? I, like many other posters below me, immediately thought Jon Hamm. Why? His classic 40/50s good looks on Mad Men fit the image most people have of Superman. Plus he's a good actor. I can see his Superman being humble yet likeable. It's also helps that he's close to 40 - so we'd have a superMAN, not superBOY.



Of course, knowing youth obsessed Hollywood, they'd probably consider him to be too old for the role.
 
+16
Vote Up Vote Down
jrjackson3989
8:43PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
New Superman
I honestly think Tom Welling would do a great job. ANd too all who keep saying Jon Hamm the mans too old to play Superman, the Last I heard they were going to reboot the series which means a younger Supes and Cast
I honestly think Tom Welling would do a great job. ANd too all who keep saying Jon Hamm the mans too old to play Superman, the Last I heard they were going to reboot the series which means a younger Supes and Cast
 
+14
Vote Up Vote Down
Snoogans3000
8:38PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Just cast Ryan Renolds and be done. He seems like the go to boy for superhero movies right now......j/k Bring Tom Welling
Just cast Ryan Renolds and be done. He seems like the go to boy for superhero movies right now......j/k Bring Tom Welling
 
-23
Vote Up Vote Down
jcov28
8:32PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
if they are going for a younger
superman then I believe that Jared Pedalecki could pull it off he has the build the chisled jaw and dark hair. I know its out of the box thinking but it could work
superman then I believe that Jared Pedalecki could pull it off he has the build the chisled jaw and dark hair. I know its out of the box thinking but it could work
 
-12
Vote Up Vote Down
Don'tBlvHisLies
8:28PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Plz dear lord just cast Jon Hamm and start filming this thing already!!
Plz dear lord just cast Jon Hamm and start filming this thing already!!
 
-11
Vote Up Vote Down
Brian Begins
8:28PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
I agree with what everyone seems to be saying about Routh. He really embodied the character. However, I think Returns was a little misunderstood. It was basically a love letter to the Donner films. As a huge Supes fan, I found it had some beautiful moments that really tapped into the heart of Superman, and I think Brandon Routh was a big part of that. Having said that, I think they need to go...
I agree with what everyone seems to be saying about Routh. He really embodied the character. However, I think Returns was a little misunderstood. It was basically a love letter to the Donner films. As a huge Supes fan, I found it had some beautiful moments that really tapped into the heart of Superman, and I think Brandon Routh was a big part of that. Having said that, I think they need to go another direction with the next film and unfortunately I don't think Routh will fit into that which is a shame for him.



I honestly don't know who should have the role, but I think maybe casting a relative unknown again may be the way to go. Also, can we please get a better rendition of Luthor in the next movie? Enough with the over the top real estate schemes and zany humor. He needs to be a ruthless and calculating businessman, and I say bring in someone like Brainiac or Doomsday so we can have a real physical threat for the Man of Steel.
 
-18
Vote Up Vote Down
Bigger Boat
8:24PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Patrick Warburton
Patrick Warburton
1 Reply
 
Brer B8a
10:13PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
No way. Save that guy for Captain Marvel. He would be perfect for him.
No way. Save that guy for Captain Marvel. He would be perfect for him.
 
-23
Vote Up Vote Down
Diesel Prophet
8:12PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Henry Cavill
Someone else said Cavill, and I totally agree.

I will say Hamm is the Man though. I wouldn't mind seeing him in the role, but I would actually rather an awesome origin story-type reboot (as superman 1 doesn't really give a solid one, just a gloss over) or anything with Zod in it. Hell, I say fuck superman, and give me a goddamned ZOD MOVIE.
Someone else said Cavill, and I totally agree.

I will say Hamm is the Man though. I wouldn't mind seeing him in the role, but I would actually rather an awesome origin story-type reboot (as superman 1 doesn't really give a solid one, just a gloss over) or anything with Zod in it. Hell, I say fuck superman, and give me a goddamned ZOD MOVIE.
 
-26
Vote Up Vote Down
JohnnyBootstrap
7:59PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Two Words
Ken Jeong
Ken Jeong
1 Reply
 
Winchester08
6:23PM on 07/16/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
lol funny
lol funny
 
-11
Vote Up Vote Down
xander887
7:23PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Jon Hamm
Jon Hamm
 
-10
Vote Up Vote Down
moviesam
7:22PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
John M.F. Hamm
Perfect.
Perfect.
 
-13
Vote Up Vote Down
sequencer
7:18PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
hard to argue with hamm.
count me in.
count me in.
 
-21
Vote Up Vote Down
DookieMercury
6:59PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
I like Routh, I thought Returns shortchanged him because it was pretty much a Lois & Luthor pic. That said I'd go with Jon Hamm, I mean look at that picture and say you don't see him in the role, if not him then Routh.
I like Routh, I thought Returns shortchanged him because it was pretty much a Lois & Luthor pic. That said I'd go with Jon Hamm, I mean look at that picture and say you don't see him in the role, if not him then Routh.
 
-11
Vote Up Vote Down
cord_cuervo
6:53PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Brandon Routh
I thought that Brandon Routh was excellent as Supes in Returns. Give him a second chance.
I thought that Brandon Routh was excellent as Supes in Returns. Give him a second chance.
 
-24
Vote Up Vote Down
will3219
6:36PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Henry Cavill
I am 90% sure they will cast him. He was almost Bond, was considered for Batman and Green Lantern, and almost had the role of Superman back in 2006. He'll get the job.
I am 90% sure they will cast him. He was almost Bond, was considered for Batman and Green Lantern, and almost had the role of Superman back in 2006. He'll get the job.
 
-33
Vote Up Vote Down
rbevanx
6:10PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Milo Ventimiglia or Eion Bailey
Milo Ventimiglia or Eion Bailey
 
-10
Vote Up Vote Down
Lone Justice
6:01PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Hammage
No contest
No contest
 
+3
Vote Up Vote Down
DougHeffernan
5:50PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
chevy chase.
chevy chase.
 
-22
Vote Up Vote Down
bonoferox
5:26PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Routh. But if not him, then Jon Hamm
Routh. But if not him, then Jon Hamm
 
-12
Vote Up Vote Down
zeprules74
5:19PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
100% Jon Hamm, he was born to play Superman.
100% Jon Hamm, he was born to play Superman.
 
-17
Vote Up Vote Down
T DUBBS
5:05PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
John Hamm hands down. I'm tired of this 20 something Smallville bullshit.
John Hamm hands down. I'm tired of this 20 something Smallville bullshit.
 
-21
Vote Up Vote Down
memph666
5:00PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
hhhmmmmmnnnn
I think Routh was a good choice to follow reeve, he really look the part and should really get another crack at the role, but if they had to change I'd go for something completely leftfield and bring in Thomas Jane, he would be a tough ass superman and deserves a big role....

I think Routh was a good choice to follow reeve, he really look the part and should really get another crack at the role, but if they had to change I'd go for something completely leftfield and bring in Thomas Jane, he would be a tough ass superman and deserves a big role....

 
-12
Vote Up Vote Down
Tailgunner
4:55PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
You said it, Puff
Though I dunno about Hamm. Superman should always be an unknown. Superman doesn't need the distraction of a 'name' star.
Though I dunno about Hamm. Superman should always be an unknown. Superman doesn't need the distraction of a 'name' star.
1 Reply
 
Kirk1701
8:09PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
You know, I have heard the same fucking arguement for the past twenty years or so. That the actor who plays Superman needs to an unknown actor. This is total bullshit in my opinion. Hollywoodland is a business and name recognition sells movie tickets. I guess you think that Hollywoodland should wait twenty or even a hundred years for an unknown actor to play Superman. I want to see a Superman m...
You know, I have heard the same fucking arguement for the past twenty years or so. That the actor who plays Superman needs to an unknown actor. This is total bullshit in my opinion. Hollywoodland is a business and name recognition sells movie tickets. I guess you think that Hollywoodland should wait twenty or even a hundred years for an unknown actor to play Superman. I want to see a Superman movie now, not hundred years from now. Get with the fucking program.If this movie does not have Routh or someone who doesn't look like Christopher Reeve, I won't see at all.
 
-10
Vote Up Vote Down
PuffCity
4:27PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Jon Hamm
Hamm is the man. And I'm tired of movies always trying to cast to young for superheroes. Make Superman a 35-40 year old.
Hamm is the man. And I'm tired of movies always trying to cast to young for superheroes. Make Superman a 35-40 year old.
 
-13
Vote Up Vote Down
Matches_Malone
4:04PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
SuperMADmen
Jon Hamm should be the only choice.
Jon Hamm should be the only choice.
 
-7
Vote Up Vote Down
Sly Guns
3:47PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Brandon Routh ALL THE WAY!!!
It has to be Routh. He did a great job in Returns & the only wothy successor to Reeve.
It has to be Routh. He did a great job in Returns & the only wothy successor to Reeve.
 
-15
Vote Up Vote Down
kohltrain
3:20PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Jon Hamm
We didn't get him for Captain America so make him the other All American Super Hero
We didn't get him for Captain America so make him the other All American Super Hero
 
-11
Vote Up Vote Down
Bogie4Ever
3:16PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Brandon Routh
From the moment he appeared on screen I immediately accepted Brandon Routh as The Man Of Steel. The fact that 'Superman Returns' was not a box-office smash had absolutely nothing to do with him. Actually, Routh was probably the best thing about the movie. If Nolan decides to recast, like Christopher Reeve and Brandon Routh, it should definately be an unknown.
From the moment he appeared on screen I immediately accepted Brandon Routh as The Man Of Steel. The fact that 'Superman Returns' was not a box-office smash had absolutely nothing to do with him. Actually, Routh was probably the best thing about the movie. If Nolan decides to recast, like Christopher Reeve and Brandon Routh, it should definately be an unknown.
 
-21
Vote Up Vote Down
Shaggy89
3:14PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Matt Bomer
have him bulk up and boom there's your Supes
have him bulk up and boom there's your Supes
 
-9
Vote Up Vote Down
OKMovieFan
3:12PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Brandon Routh. I thought he looked to young in Superman Returns but by the time the new movie rolls out, he should be a good age.
Brandon Routh. I thought he looked to young in Superman Returns but by the time the new movie rolls out, he should be a good age.
 
+24
Vote Up Vote Down
Bazzaa
3:10PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Let Smallville fly
It makes sense for Tom Welling to play superman especially if the show is coming to an end. I thought Routh was very good considering his acting creditals at the time.
It makes sense for Tom Welling to play superman especially if the show is coming to an end. I thought Routh was very good considering his acting creditals at the time.
 
-20
Vote Up Vote Down
FilmBufffff
2:57PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Michael Fassbender
My pick would be Michael Fassbender because he's got the charm and the intensity to pull off Clark just as well as Superman. He also deserves to have a breakout role like Supes because he's a such a damn good actor.
My pick would be Michael Fassbender because he's got the charm and the intensity to pull off Clark just as well as Superman. He also deserves to have a breakout role like Supes because he's a such a damn good actor.
 
-15
Vote Up Vote Down
Short Round
2:56PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Jon Hamm, definitely. I really liked Routh, but I think it's time for an older Superman. And whoever said Hamm is too old for a franchise, he's only 39. Robert Downey Jr. is in his mid-40's and doing Iron Man. 'Nuff said.
Jon Hamm, definitely. I really liked Routh, but I think it's time for an older Superman. And whoever said Hamm is too old for a franchise, he's only 39. Robert Downey Jr. is in his mid-40's and doing Iron Man. 'Nuff said.
 
-13
Vote Up Vote Down
Beauski
2:51PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
I like Jon Hamm as Superman. He'd have to gain a bit of muscle but I'm sure it wouldn't be a problem.
I like Jon Hamm as Superman. He'd have to gain a bit of muscle but I'm sure it wouldn't be a problem.
 
-27
Vote Up Vote Down
dillisasexyman
2:51PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Alex O'Loughlin
Alex O'Loughlin
 
+19
Vote Up Vote Down
DarkElfa
2:47PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Tom Welling.
Tom Welling.
 
-12
Vote Up Vote Down
Acerbus III
2:28PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Jon Hamm
I think Hamm is the best, most logical choice. He is ready to become a breakout star, he already has a loyal following and critical acclaim. He has the look - no doubt about that. I think it should be his part to accept or reject.
I think Hamm is the best, most logical choice. He is ready to become a breakout star, he already has a loyal following and critical acclaim. He has the look - no doubt about that. I think it should be his part to accept or reject.
 
-8
Vote Up Vote Down
Cathelotte
2:17PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
cast new
lets take an unknown!

I like Routh but he is to much linked with the pre-crisis superman (with the goofy CK). Nowadays, CK is not a goofy at all, but more in the veine of the CK in Smallville or Loïs & Clark.

So if they go for a Superman more like the most rescent comics, they shouldn't do a goofy clark and a to innocent superman.
lets take an unknown!

I like Routh but he is to much linked with the pre-crisis superman (with the goofy CK). Nowadays, CK is not a goofy at all, but more in the veine of the CK in Smallville or Loïs & Clark.

So if they go for a Superman more like the most rescent comics, they shouldn't do a goofy clark and a to innocent superman.
 
-12
Vote Up Vote Down
coconut84
2:07PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Jon Hamm
Jon Hamm
 
-33
Vote Up Vote Down
MythicalSausage
1:54PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Jon Hamm
Older Superman --- Jon Hamm

Younger Superman --- Bradley Cooper ?
Older Superman --- Jon Hamm

Younger Superman --- Bradley Cooper ?
 
-31
Vote Up Vote Down
soboyle
1:52PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
I love Donald glover! He is awesome but I don't think he would make a very good Superman. How about Bill Hader? If Seth Rogen can be a superhero why not him?
I love Donald glover! He is awesome but I don't think he would make a very good Superman. How about Bill Hader? If Seth Rogen can be a superhero why not him?
 
-11
Vote Up Vote Down
Josh Tequila
1:50PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Routh.
Brandon did a great job first time round. He's not to blame for the BO failure of Returns. Also, they should go the Superman 2 route for an enemy, It will be more entertaining than the Luthor way.
Brandon did a great job first time round. He's not to blame for the BO failure of Returns. Also, they should go the Superman 2 route for an enemy, It will be more entertaining than the Luthor way.
 
-26
Vote Up Vote Down
Terminal_83
1:50PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Keep Welling FAR away!!!
I'll go with Jon Hamm.
I'll go with Jon Hamm.
 
-24
Vote Up Vote Down
mdb47
1:49PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
If they are going older [link] then Jim Caviezel



Younger, then Matt Bomer
If they are going older [link] then Jim Caviezel



Younger, then Matt Bomer
 
-24
Vote Up Vote Down
rodie
1:42PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Karl Urban
Do it!
Do it!
 
-23
Vote Up Vote Down
Thumbs
1:38PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Donald Glover
Donald Glover
 
+19
Vote Up Vote Down
lastmass
1:34PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Tom Welling
Since season 4 of Smallville I've thought Welling was the best Clark Kent/Superman to date. If they were to make another movie he is the only on in my view to fill in the role. I hate the idea that Nolen wants to make the new movie set in the 50's and I'm not even sure I'd pay to see another crap superman in the movies. Last time i saw one that was worth watching i was a child. and the movie...
Since season 4 of Smallville I've thought Welling was the best Clark Kent/Superman to date. If they were to make another movie he is the only on in my view to fill in the role. I hate the idea that Nolen wants to make the new movie set in the 50's and I'm not even sure I'd pay to see another crap superman in the movies. Last time i saw one that was worth watching i was a child. and the movie was Superman 2. Without Welling I'm not sold!
 
-27
Vote Up Vote Down
TBagNUrMom
1:32PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Has to be under 40
I like the Henry Cavill idea, even though he's a Brit. A younger Daniel Day Lewis would have been great, but he's a little old to play CK.
I like the Henry Cavill idea, even though he's a Brit. A younger Daniel Day Lewis would have been great, but he's a little old to play CK.
 
+19
Vote Up Vote Down
aaa516
1:25PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
I too say Tom Welling, he had the approval of Christopher Reeve. He's the only person at this time that I can picture as Superman. I thought Routh's superman was kinda weak.
I too say Tom Welling, he had the approval of Christopher Reeve. He's the only person at this time that I can picture as Superman. I thought Routh's superman was kinda weak.
 
-32
Vote Up Vote Down
threezy
1:10PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Try Routh
If denied, go Brody. I know I'll catch some heat for this, but Adrien Brody seems perfect for Superman... I'm not a Superman fan though so, idk much.
If denied, go Brody. I know I'll catch some heat for this, but Adrien Brody seems perfect for Superman... I'm not a Superman fan though so, idk much.
 
-19
Vote Up Vote Down
Doctor Supertramp
1:07PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Two Ideas. Henry Cavill and Jon Hamm.



I still think Routh deserves a second chance despite it being a reboot.



BTW random casting call for Lois Lane. How about Cameron from House, Jennifer Morrison.
Two Ideas. Henry Cavill and Jon Hamm.



I still think Routh deserves a second chance despite it being a reboot.



BTW random casting call for Lois Lane. How about Cameron from House, Jennifer Morrison.
 
-45
Vote Up Vote Down
cerealkiller182
12:58PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
I think Matthew Fox is capable. Or Cavill.



Fuck Routh and Welling though. They both sucked so badly
I think Matthew Fox is capable. Or Cavill.



Fuck Routh and Welling though. They both sucked so badly
 
-20
Vote Up Vote Down
Brer B8a
12:56PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
It is not going to be Tom Welling or Routh so lets try thinking of someone besides them. I like Matthew Fox if he can beef up. I don't know Jon Hamm but he looks the part.
It is not going to be Tom Welling or Routh so lets try thinking of someone besides them. I like Matthew Fox if he can beef up. I don't know Jon Hamm but he looks the part.
 
+23
Vote Up Vote Down
Wakkidus
12:46PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Tom Welling
No doubt. Welling has gotten better with each year of Smallville, and since this upcoming season is the last he would have time to wrap it up then take on the movie. They wouldn't have to waist a second with origin, just get right to the action.
No doubt. Welling has gotten better with each year of Smallville, and since this upcoming season is the last he would have time to wrap it up then take on the movie. They wouldn't have to waist a second with origin, just get right to the action.
 
-7
Vote Up Vote Down
FNDanny
12:44PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Routh was it. Not his fault Superman Returns was a little drawn out.
Routh was it. Not his fault Superman Returns was a little drawn out.
 
-7
Vote Up Vote Down
polarboy
12:37PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Stick with Routh.
Brandon is meant to be Superman. It's not his fault the movie tanked, so why recast. I say keep him. Although, it's unlikely because the studio would want people to be able to differentiate between takes on the film. Having Routh will make it look like a sequel, when it isn't.
Brandon is meant to be Superman. It's not his fault the movie tanked, so why recast. I say keep him. Although, it's unlikely because the studio would want people to be able to differentiate between takes on the film. Having Routh will make it look like a sequel, when it isn't.
1 Reply
 
Winchester08
6:41PM on 07/16/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
finally someone gets it
finally someone gets it
 
-13
Vote Up Vote Down
The_Soloist
12:35PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Jon Hamm should definitely, no doubt be the next Clark Kent/Superman. Has the look, the build, the acting chops, and could pull of Clark Kent (i.e. 30 Rock) pretty well and could easily pull off Superman (i.e. Mad Men).
Jon Hamm should definitely, no doubt be the next Clark Kent/Superman. Has the look, the build, the acting chops, and could pull of Clark Kent (i.e. 30 Rock) pretty well and could easily pull off Superman (i.e. Mad Men).
 
+4
Vote Up Vote Down
Derek237
12:31PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
My dentist looks a lot like Superman, they should cast him.
My dentist looks a lot like Superman, they should cast him.
 
-11
Vote Up Vote Down
JohnLocke2342
12:22PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
John Hamm certainly has the look of an old-school Superman.. but Brandon Routh nailed it even tho Returns was pretty bland. A couple of times I actually thought he was Christopher Reeves.
John Hamm certainly has the look of an old-school Superman.. but Brandon Routh nailed it even tho Returns was pretty bland. A couple of times I actually thought he was Christopher Reeves.
 
-11
Vote Up Vote Down
lpactor20
12:22PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Routh. He did a great job and I'd love to see him back
Routh. He did a great job and I'd love to see him back
 
+21
Vote Up Vote Down
DaForce
12:21PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Honestly, I'd like to see Tom Welling in the yellow, blue and red. He had Chris Reeves blessing, and that's good enough for me.
Honestly, I'd like to see Tom Welling in the yellow, blue and red. He had Chris Reeves blessing, and that's good enough for me.
 
+4
Vote Up Vote Down
muveadict
12:15PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
my first...
inclination is brandon routh, but that may be because of his striking resemblance to Christopher Reeve. But if dc is heading towards a jl movie them maybe tom welling is the man, he'll be cheaper and millions of people already identify him with the brand. besides, it would be good to see superboy finally grow into his powers.
inclination is brandon routh, but that may be because of his striking resemblance to Christopher Reeve. But if dc is heading towards a jl movie them maybe tom welling is the man, he'll be cheaper and millions of people already identify him with the brand. besides, it would be good to see superboy finally grow into his powers.
 
-24
Vote Up Vote Down
hkr_mob
12:14PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Henry Cavill
time for this guy to finally get a major role...



but wud also love if routh came back... to me he is superman (but 2nd to reeve as always)
time for this guy to finally get a major role...



but wud also love if routh came back... to me he is superman (but 2nd to reeve as always)
 
-13
Vote Up Vote Down
OsLord
12:08PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
John Hamm
Tho, I've never see n Mad Men and only seen him on 30 Rock, he's defintely got the look.
Tho, I've never see n Mad Men and only seen him on 30 Rock, he's defintely got the look.
 
-10
Vote Up Vote Down
brewsky99
12:08PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
firstly i didn't know who Jon Hamm is(i had to check) but knocking on 40,unknown outside North America i don't think it will happen.I think Routh would be my pick he didn't do much wrong.
firstly i didn't know who Jon Hamm is(i had to check) but knocking on 40,unknown outside North America i don't think it will happen.I think Routh would be my pick he didn't do much wrong.
 
+22
Vote Up Vote Down
Manning
12:07PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Tom Welling
Tom Welling has been playing this role for like 11 years, gotta be doing something right.
Tom Welling has been playing this role for like 11 years, gotta be doing something right.
 
-23
Vote Up Vote Down
issorkram
12:03PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Jon Hamm would be good if it is a more middle age cast, but being that SR was played by younger actors, they may want to stick with a fresher face like Mathew Bomer

OR!

It's a bird, Its a plane, it's the one that says bad mutha f_cka on it - Samuel Jackson
Jon Hamm would be good if it is a more middle age cast, but being that SR was played by younger actors, they may want to stick with a fresher face like Mathew Bomer

OR!

It's a bird, Its a plane, it's the one that says bad mutha f_cka on it - Samuel Jackson
 
-5
Vote Up Vote Down
Antarius
12:02PM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Routh was great bring him back!!
Routh was great bring him back!!
 
-11
Vote Up Vote Down
jgcrooks
11:59AM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
John Hamm!!!
set it in the 40's like the old max fleischer cartoons.. do something we haven't seen!
set it in the 40's like the old max fleischer cartoons.. do something we haven't seen!
 
-13
Vote Up Vote Down
ericpeguero
11:57AM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
john hamm as superman
john hamm as superman
 
-26
Vote Up Vote Down
Green-Ghost
11:57AM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
If WB wants an unknown actor I would say Harmon Walsh, he has the look.

I like Jon Hamm too, but he is too old for a franchise.
If WB wants an unknown actor I would say Harmon Walsh, he has the look.

I like Jon Hamm too, but he is too old for a franchise.
 
-26
Vote Up Vote Down
pcch7
11:55AM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Zach Levy.. I wouldn´t mind Routh again, but if it´s a reeboot that might be confusing for people
Zach Levy.. I wouldn´t mind Routh again, but if it´s a reeboot that might be confusing for people
 
-13
Vote Up Vote Down
AlmostFamous91
11:54AM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Jon Hamm
Jon Hamm
 
-9
Vote Up Vote Down
snoopmish
11:52AM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
I pretty much agree with everyone who says bring Routh back....he was the best thing about SR, but if not...get another unknown to do it. Usually that's how it goes with any Superman live action franchise, whether TV or movies.
I pretty much agree with everyone who says bring Routh back....he was the best thing about SR, but if not...get another unknown to do it. Usually that's how it goes with any Superman live action franchise, whether TV or movies.
 
-27
Vote Up Vote Down
writer19
11:48AM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Zach Levi
Zach Levi
 
-22
Vote Up Vote Down
The Bodyguard
11:40AM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Matthew Bomer. He has the charm and the look for it. Let him bulk up a bit and he would be absolutely perfect.





In a perfect world, we would have Routh back, but it just won't happen
Matthew Bomer. He has the charm and the look for it. Let him bulk up a bit and he would be absolutely perfect.





In a perfect world, we would have Routh back, but it just won't happen
 
-15
Vote Up Vote Down
Tash226
11:39AM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Brandon Routh
Best part of "Superman Returns." But, i could totally see Jon Hamm too. He'd be my choice 1b.
Best part of "Superman Returns." But, i could totally see Jon Hamm too. He'd be my choice 1b.
 
-12
Vote Up Vote Down
rdance5507
11:37AM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Jon Hamm
I've been saying Jon Hamm for ages! Either Spuerman or Bruce Wayne...the guy would be perfect for either. Hopefully he gets the cred he deserves.
I've been saying Jon Hamm for ages! Either Spuerman or Bruce Wayne...the guy would be perfect for either. Hopefully he gets the cred he deserves.
 
-12
Vote Up Vote Down
JokerJonWaugh
11:35AM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Jon Hamm
It's no contest. Don Draper all the way. Look at him, he IS Superman! Plus, He can do the awkward/goofy guy thanks to "30 Rock", and be the strong silent type thanks to "Mad Men". Seriously, JON. EFFING. HAMM!

It's no contest. Don Draper all the way. Look at him, he IS Superman! Plus, He can do the awkward/goofy guy thanks to "30 Rock", and be the strong silent type thanks to "Mad Men". Seriously, JON. EFFING. HAMM!

 
-4
Vote Up Vote Down
IQuitMrWhite
11:34AM on 07/15/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Brandon Routh. Why mess with a good thing? Superman Returns was disappointing, but he nailed Kent/Supes. Give him another chance.
Brandon Routh. Why mess with a good thing? Superman Returns was disappointing, but he nailed Kent/Supes. Give him another chance.
back (loading) more
JoBlo Movie Show | Movie Games | Stanley Kubrick Tribute | Chat Room | JoBlo Comic Strip | Contests | Links | Advertise on this Site | JoBlo in the Media | JoBlo.com Newsletter
Site Credits | Privacy Policy | Contact Us | Site Map
© 1998 - present JoBlo Media Inc., All Rights Reserved Hello | JoBlo® is a trademark of JoBlo Media Inc. All movie titles, pictures, etc... are registered trademarks and/or copyrights of their respective holders
Dedicated hosting provided by the good folks at NEXCESS.NET Web Hosting
Website Design & Development by Face3 Media
Search Engine Optimization powered by Higher Education Marketing