Hobbit gets closer? | Movie News

Hobbit gets closer?
Comments: 8
terometer
71%
Strike Back below!
by: Dave Davis Oct. 4, 2007

The short answer to the headline is: No, not really.

But Entertainment Weekly has put a lot of effort into speculating on the perceived relationship repairs that may be happening between LORD OF THE RINGS director Peter Jackson and studio New Line. A lengthy new article tracks the entire ugly matter, including how the filmmaker and cast got hosed out of their slice of the $3 BILLION PLUS the trilogy has generated, how the situation became toxic, and how New Line eventually began seeking a replacement director for THE HOBBIT.

But now things seem to have settled (or will, assuming the lawsuit is settled), with Jackson's involvement deemed "indispensable" to the early Tolkein tale. Or tales, more accurately -- Jackson previously stated he'd split the adventure into two films and interweave Tolkein's random Bilbo Baggins writings which, I hope, aren't as excruciating as the extra Arwen scenes from LOTR.

Still, don't expect to see the little hairy-footed wanderer's search for Smaug the Dragon's treasure anytime soon. Jackson is busy with adapting THE LOVELY BONES and then plans to make a TINTIN movie with Steven Spielberg, and he's also producing the WWII movie DAMBUSTERS. And considering HALO 3 has already made over $300 million, he'll likely be called back for exec producing duty on the stalled feature film that will no doubt start up again soon.

Source: EW

Add to MFC Profile

Extra Tidbit: Jackson made a brief appearance as a psychotic Santa in HOT FUZZ.

8 discussions Expand all
 
+0
Vote Up Vote Down
ColdZro
7:53AM on 10/06/2007 Add as a friend | MFC profile
I hope they do work it out, because without Jackson, they might as well not bother making "The Hobbit." I wouldn't trust anybody else with it.
I hope they do work it out, because without Jackson, they might as well not bother making "The Hobbit." I wouldn't trust anybody else with it.
 
+0
Vote Up Vote Down
Doctor Zubian
11:59AM on 10/05/2007 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Nobbit
New line would be KAR-AZEEE to give the job anyone but Jackson. However i hope he doesn't split it into 2 movies and pad it out with unnecessary scenes of young Aragorn, young Legolas and other characters not even featured in the Book to 'Bridge' the other films. Cast Martin Freeman as Bilbo, get McKellen in and a load of new actors for the dwarves and there you have it.
New line would be KAR-AZEEE to give the job anyone but Jackson. However i hope he doesn't split it into 2 movies and pad it out with unnecessary scenes of young Aragorn, young Legolas and other characters not even featured in the Book to 'Bridge' the other films. Cast Martin Freeman as Bilbo, get McKellen in and a load of new actors for the dwarves and there you have it.
 
+0
Vote Up Vote Down
otterhead
10:26AM on 10/05/2007 Add as a friend | MFC profile
I bet not
I predict that in 20 years we'll have articles about "the great lost movies" that will include stuff like Godfather 4, Star Wars 7-9, and the biggest: THE HOBBIT TRILOGY. (Don't forget, New Line/Jackson claimed they were planning on three movies: two Hobbit movies and a 'bridge' movie of additional material.) Whether Jackson & New line never get it ironed out, he loses interest, Ian McKellen dies
I predict that in 20 years we'll have articles about "the great lost movies" that will include stuff like Godfather 4, Star Wars 7-9, and the biggest: THE HOBBIT TRILOGY. (Don't forget, New Line/Jackson claimed they were planning on three movies: two Hobbit movies and a 'bridge' movie of additional material.) Whether Jackson & New line never get it ironed out, he loses interest, Ian McKellen dies and nobody can take his place: I honestly doubt, in the most hopeful way, it'll ever happen.
 
+0
Vote Up Vote Down
grungehippy
9:33AM on 10/05/2007 Add as a friend | MFC profile
God, let's hope so
There are a lot more people out there who feel the same way that I do in that if Jacky-boy doesn't direct and bring back the original players then this entire project will be unacceptable. And also, as far as bashing the trilogy, purists just need to let go or go back and watch the cartoons that didn't include Two Towers. We as fans got our story the best way it could be done because LOTR in its
There are a lot more people out there who feel the same way that I do in that if Jacky-boy doesn't direct and bring back the original players then this entire project will be unacceptable. And also, as far as bashing the trilogy, purists just need to let go or go back and watch the cartoons that didn't include Two Towers. We as fans got our story the best way it could be done because LOTR in its entirety is still unfilmmable. So as far as Arwen goes, it didn't bother me at all, and I felt it gave a fresh and unexpected subplot to take in. As cringe-inducing as it may be to you, drexell, I'd rather watch Arwen and Aragorn instead of Anakin & Padme with their "NO, IT'S BECAUSE I'M SO IN LOVE WITH YOU!!!!"
 
+0
Vote Up Vote Down
drexxell
7:20AM on 10/05/2007 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Two Films?
[link]

Jackson may be a great director and cinematographer, but he is a crappy writer. The scenes he cut from LOTR and especially the scenes he ADDED absolutely remove any rights he has to f*** with source material again.

If he's allowed screenwriting duties on The Hobbit, I'm out.

Oh and P.S....nice move, Jackson, burning down Hobbiton once you were done with LOTR. Didn't have a lot
[link]

Jackson may be a great director and cinematographer, but he is a crappy writer. The scenes he cut from LOTR and especially the scenes he ADDED absolutely remove any rights he has to f*** with source material again.

If he's allowed screenwriting duties on The Hobbit, I'm out.

Oh and P.S....nice move, Jackson, burning down Hobbiton once you were done with LOTR. Didn't have a lot of foresight. Now ya gotta build it again.
 
+0
Vote Up Vote Down
theshadowalker
2:22AM on 10/05/2007 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Come on already!

I mean, he's a brilliant actor, but Ian McKellen's not exactly getting any younger, so can we PLEASE start filming this soon (but only with Jackson, of course)?

I mean, he's a brilliant actor, but Ian McKellen's not exactly getting any younger, so can we PLEASE start filming this soon (but only with Jackson, of course)?
 
+0
Vote Up Vote Down
HoyleHaw
11:28PM on 10/04/2007 Add as a friend | MFC profile
I'm glad I'm not the only one who found Arwen's scenes diverting. I hate to even speculate about other directors, even though I could fill a room with all the things that I felt didn't go with the trilogy (though I'd leave Fellowship alone, that one was perfect). Here's hoping EW isn't doing this in vane.
I'm glad I'm not the only one who found Arwen's scenes diverting. I hate to even speculate about other directors, even though I could fill a room with all the things that I felt didn't go with the trilogy (though I'd leave Fellowship alone, that one was perfect). Here's hoping EW isn't doing this in vane.
 
+0
Vote Up Vote Down
NEMA
9:15PM on 10/04/2007 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Why even bother with Jackson?
Considering the way the suits work things just may as well give it over to McG or Ratner. Or even Raimi, lord knows he knows how to make a cohesive movie series.....yeah that was all sarcasm.
Considering the way the suits work things just may as well give it over to McG or Ratner. Or even Raimi, lord knows he knows how to make a cohesive movie series.....yeah that was all sarcasm.