Jane & Punisher split! | Movie News

Jane & Punisher split!
Comments: 25
terometer
52%
Strike Back below!
by: Ben Barna May. 16, 2007

Thomas Jane and THE PUNISHER 2 have ended their relationship, citing irreconcilable differences. Sources close to the couple say that Jane was unhappy with the direction the movie was heading, and would rather not reprise the role of Frank Castle in the sequel to the 2004 film if it wasn’t going to be done right. Jane broke the news himself to AICN, and was clearly devastated over the break-up:

I’m writing to tell you that I regretfully and painfully had to pull out of P2. I can’t tell you how completely broken up I am about it. After busting my ass at the gym four days a week for almost two years, watching every character driven action pic that any fan would ask me to watch while I was standing in line buying egg whites and Tuna fish... Punisher fans are already fighting an uphill battle as it is. And I’ve always felt a responsibility to fight that fight for them and with them so that Frank Castle gets the treatment he deserves.”

If you ask me, it sounds like the studio is to blame for the demise of this relationship. My guess is that if the studio hadn’t butt in and tried to exert their influence and opinions on the couple, we would have seen Jane and THE PUNISHER 2 on the big screen together. It really is a shame, because it sounded like they were really getting to know each other better, and although it didn't seem so at first, I think these two were a good fit. Now all we’ve got left is the original film, when the two were still awkward together. But we can’t act shocked people. Hollywood relationships never last. Best of luck to both Jane and THE PUNISHER 2 in the future and during this difficult time.

Add to MFC Profile

Extra Tidbit: Who do you see THE PUNISHER with next? I think Hugh Jackman and THE PUNISHER would make the perfect couple, but it's unlikely since Jackman is already seeing WOLVERINE.

25 discussions Expand all
 
+0
Vote Up Vote Down
Riz-man
10:05AM on 05/18/2007 Add as a friend | MFC profile
The problem with the Punisher movie...
...if you ask me (apart from the fact that it wasn't very good) is that Man on Fire came out around the same time and was everything the Punisher movie should have been. So, if you're prepared to consider a black Punisher, I say...call for Denzil! ;O) Oh and as bad as the Dolph Lundgren version was, he had the brooding and badass angles nailed dead on.
...if you ask me (apart from the fact that it wasn't very good) is that Man on Fire came out around the same time and was everything the Punisher movie should have been. So, if you're prepared to consider a black Punisher, I say...call for Denzil! ;O) Oh and as bad as the Dolph Lundgren version was, he had the brooding and badass angles nailed dead on.
 
+0
Vote Up Vote Down
the clever guy
11:33PM on 05/16/2007 Add as a friend | MFC profile
HUH?!?!?!?!?
clive owen as the punisher? are you fucking kidding me? im sorry people, but no. clive owens a badass and all, but hes not the fucking punisher by any means. unless i see something to otherwise sway my opinion, clive owen should not be thought of as the punisher.
clive owen as the punisher? are you fucking kidding me? im sorry people, but no. clive owens a badass and all, but hes not the fucking punisher by any means. unless i see something to otherwise sway my opinion, clive owen should not be thought of as the punisher.
 
+0
Vote Up Vote Down
Rabbit
10:35PM on 05/16/2007 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Seriously...
Clive Owen would be an awesome choice...did anyone see "I'll Sleep When I'm Dead"!?!?
Clive Owen would be an awesome choice...did anyone see "I'll Sleep When I'm Dead"!?!?
 
+0
Vote Up Vote Down
Sfpsycho415
10:20PM on 05/16/2007 Add as a friend | MFC profile
I Loved 1st one.
I don't know why everyone puts down the first one (talkin bout the 2004 version). I loved it. I thought Jane fit perfectly for the Punisher they were doing. I liked the story, the action, and the characters. Now i am upset we won't see Jane back in the skull shirt, but if they were gonna make it really stupid, i am glad he's out and doesn't want to sully the name of the Punisher. I just hope...
I don't know why everyone puts down the first one (talkin bout the 2004 version). I loved it. I thought Jane fit perfectly for the Punisher they were doing. I liked the story, the action, and the characters. Now i am upset we won't see Jane back in the skull shirt, but if they were gonna make it really stupid, i am glad he's out and doesn't want to sully the name of the Punisher. I just hope this isn't the end of the Punisher on the big screen.
 
+0
Vote Up Vote Down
IQuitMrWhite
10:13PM on 05/16/2007 Add as a friend | MFC profile
meh
i say they pull a "incredible hulk" and go balls out crazy on this one and stick to the comics rather than make a direct sequel from the first movie.
i say they pull a "incredible hulk" and go balls out crazy on this one and stick to the comics rather than make a direct sequel from the first movie.
 
+0
Vote Up Vote Down
Rabbit
9:59PM on 05/16/2007 Add as a friend | MFC profile
WHO???
Clive Owen



or





Gerard Butler



It's a tragedy that this split occured, because the 2004 film was pure gold. Maybe Tom and the higher-ups will work things out...let's hope so.

But how about villians???

Please tell me I'm not the only one who thinks Dennis Hopper would play a kick ass baddy.
Clive Owen



or





Gerard Butler



It's a tragedy that this split occured, because the 2004 film was pure gold. Maybe Tom and the higher-ups will work things out...let's hope so.

But how about villians???

Please tell me I'm not the only one who thinks Dennis Hopper would play a kick ass baddy.
 
+0
Vote Up Vote Down
RustyRazor
4:23PM on 05/16/2007 Add as a friend | MFC profile
What in the blue hell?!!!!
Do you know how hard it is to defend this movie?! Do you have any idea the number of people that have told me that Dolph Lundgren played the Punisher better.



(After you're done laughing, please continue reading. Of course if you're not laughing and you liked Dolph Lundgren's performance, then I'd say stop reading this.)



I never saw Jane's Punisher in the theaters....
Do you know how hard it is to defend this movie?! Do you have any idea the number of people that have told me that Dolph Lundgren played the Punisher better.



(After you're done laughing, please continue reading. Of course if you're not laughing and you liked Dolph Lundgren's performance, then I'd say stop reading this.)



I never saw Jane's Punisher in the theaters. I caught on cable and I REALLY liked it. He nailed the character, dead on.



What in the f**k are they thinking?!



I'll tell you what they're thinking.

They want to go on Rusty's Enemies List.



(Richard Nixon had one. I can't?)



Stupid. F-ing stupid.



Will I see the sequel?

Depends on who they get and I will NOT be sitting in the theater happy.



The girl who puts extra butter on my popcorn is gonna be like "that guy looks pissed! He snatched the Reese's Pieces out of my hand and said thank you, but it was uninspired".



I'll be watching.
 
+0
Vote Up Vote Down
Niro929
10:42AM on 05/16/2007 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Might be a good idea
Jane was a decent Punisher but didnt really give off the Punisher vibe everyone wanted to see. How 'bout this time they get someone who is, well, INTIMIDATING! Jane is your average size guy. Lets get someone who is at least 6 foot 3 and has some muscle mass to him. Someone who can stand in a room with 2 big ol guns with a cigar hanging out of his mouth and make all the bad guys crap their pants...
Jane was a decent Punisher but didnt really give off the Punisher vibe everyone wanted to see. How 'bout this time they get someone who is, well, INTIMIDATING! Jane is your average size guy. Lets get someone who is at least 6 foot 3 and has some muscle mass to him. Someone who can stand in a room with 2 big ol guns with a cigar hanging out of his mouth and make all the bad guys crap their pants right before they get mauled. Kinda like the comic maybe? But, alas, Hollywood tends to screw things up for everyone. So we'll now see Punisher 2 starring Eric Roberts in a straight to DVD release next summer.
 
+0
Vote Up Vote Down
LloydC
9:48AM on 05/16/2007 Add as a friend | MFC profile
A spartan Pinisher
Gerald Buttler would make a perfect punisher with all the rough spartan ways, i think.
Gerald Buttler would make a perfect punisher with all the rough spartan ways, i think.
 
+0
Vote Up Vote Down
BigShime
9:23AM on 05/16/2007 Add as a friend | MFC profile
That was just about the funniest article I've read in a long time
That was just about the funniest article I've read in a long time
 
+0
Vote Up Vote Down
Alecc Bracero
9:23AM on 05/16/2007 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Good!
Jane sucked as Punisher. In fact, the entire cast was awful. Granted, the script blew as well and the direction was boring.



They should bury Punisher for a while and dig it out after people have forgotten about this last attempt, which is one of the worst movies I have ever seen.
Jane sucked as Punisher. In fact, the entire cast was awful. Granted, the script blew as well and the direction was boring.



They should bury Punisher for a while and dig it out after people have forgotten about this last attempt, which is one of the worst movies I have ever seen.
 
+0
Vote Up Vote Down
DjG
8:55AM on 05/16/2007 Add as a friend | MFC profile
I'll be damned. It was R.



I need a Die Hard/Platoon Rated-R though.
I'll be damned. It was R.



I need a Die Hard/Platoon Rated-R though.
 
+0
Vote Up Vote Down
Gandalf the Grey
8:31AM on 05/16/2007 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Hey DjG...
The first Punisher film was rated-r, just thought I'd point that out for ya.
The first Punisher film was rated-r, just thought I'd point that out for ya.
 
+0
Vote Up Vote Down
antoniojvr
7:59AM on 05/16/2007 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Dammit. Now two things I'm sad about: Jane rocks, and I need a girlfriend (stop with the relationship talk!!)
Dammit. Now two things I'm sad about: Jane rocks, and I need a girlfriend (stop with the relationship talk!!)
 
+0
Vote Up Vote Down
TheFilmFreak
7:58AM on 05/16/2007 Add as a friend | MFC profile
No Way!
No way, Jackman is a pussy, He could never fill the Punishers shoes.
No way, Jackman is a pussy, He could never fill the Punishers shoes.
 
+0
Vote Up Vote Down
TheFilmFreak
7:57AM on 05/16/2007 Add as a friend | MFC profile
OH Shit!
This fucking sucks. He was THE PUNISHER. If this is true then I will not be seeing punisher 2. God only knows what they are going to do with it if Jane pulled out of it. I guess they are trying to destroy the punisher like they destroyed daredevil. This is a very sad day for me.
This fucking sucks. He was THE PUNISHER. If this is true then I will not be seeing punisher 2. God only knows what they are going to do with it if Jane pulled out of it. I guess they are trying to destroy the punisher like they destroyed daredevil. This is a very sad day for me.
 
+0
Vote Up Vote Down
KcMsterpce
7:36AM on 05/16/2007 Add as a friend | MFC profile
that's too bad
I think it's cool that Jane - if it's all true - has a moral standpoint. The first movie wasn't too shabby, IMO, and if the sequel came out, I'd hope it would be at least what the first was, if not better. Good on Jane, though, for pulling out if he didn't feel happy with it.
I think it's cool that Jane - if it's all true - has a moral standpoint. The first movie wasn't too shabby, IMO, and if the sequel came out, I'd hope it would be at least what the first was, if not better. Good on Jane, though, for pulling out if he didn't feel happy with it.
 
+0
Vote Up Vote Down
Robsdeli
7:28AM on 05/16/2007 Add as a friend | MFC profile
I'm pissed. Apparantly not everyone agrees with me, but I loved the first Punisher (pretending that Dolph Lundgren shit never happened) and was pretty psyched about Jane coming back for another. It was turning into a cool film but without the guy...just let the film fade away now. It wont be the same.
I'm pissed. Apparantly not everyone agrees with me, but I loved the first Punisher (pretending that Dolph Lundgren shit never happened) and was pretty psyched about Jane coming back for another. It was turning into a cool film but without the guy...just let the film fade away now. It wont be the same.
 
+0
Vote Up Vote Down
NCarter
7:16AM on 05/16/2007 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Bummer. The first Punisher wasn't that great. But the problem wasn't on Jane's side.

I was looking forward to a badass Punisher movie starring Jane in NY.
Bummer. The first Punisher wasn't that great. But the problem wasn't on Jane's side.

I was looking forward to a badass Punisher movie starring Jane in NY.
 
+0
Vote Up Vote Down
DjG
5:52AM on 05/16/2007 Add as a friend | MFC profile
I'm still waiting on a Punisher movie done right. An R-rating would help for starters.



I agree w/Dark Knight, ctr alt del, restart.
I'm still waiting on a Punisher movie done right. An R-rating would help for starters.



I agree w/Dark Knight, ctr alt del, restart.
 
+0
Vote Up Vote Down
Racci
5:32AM on 05/16/2007 Add as a friend | MFC profile
FUCK
Fuck fuck fuck fuck... I hope the rights will revert back to Marvel as well.
Fuck fuck fuck fuck... I hope the rights will revert back to Marvel as well.
 
+0
Vote Up Vote Down
Dark Knight
4:49AM on 05/16/2007 Add as a friend | MFC profile
NICE MOVE FOR JANE
Let's face it, Punisher sucked bigtime, and clearly Jane also developed brain muscles large enough to see Punisher 2 is a dead end. My advice: leave it for 10 years and do a reboot.
Let's face it, Punisher sucked bigtime, and clearly Jane also developed brain muscles large enough to see Punisher 2 is a dead end. My advice: leave it for 10 years and do a reboot.
 
+0
Vote Up Vote Down
DareDevil
4:29AM on 05/16/2007 Add as a friend | MFC profile
If this movie doesn't start filming before the end of the year the rights go back to Marvel, if that happens I would expect Jane to be back on board. Let's hope for the best.
If this movie doesn't start filming before the end of the year the rights go back to Marvel, if that happens I would expect Jane to be back on board. Let's hope for the best.
 
+0
Vote Up Vote Down
GroundlessNFree
3:45AM on 05/16/2007 Add as a friend | MFC profile
I know people love to hate on every movie that's not perfect, but Jane was good as the Punisher. He took a character that's hard to love, and made him not only likeable, but still a hard-ass. If this movie gets made with a different actor, it will be bad.
I know people love to hate on every movie that's not perfect, but Jane was good as the Punisher. He took a character that's hard to love, and made him not only likeable, but still a hard-ass. If this movie gets made with a different actor, it will be bad.
 
+0
Vote Up Vote Down
Nutz
3:37AM on 05/16/2007 Add as a friend | MFC profile
In which case they may as well drop the whole idea, the 1st one was absolutely terrible anyway and should've been called 'Fairycake' instead of the punisher.
In which case they may as well drop the whole idea, the 1st one was absolutely terrible anyway and should've been called 'Fairycake' instead of the punisher.