Watch The People take on George Lucas in this new trailer | Movie News

Watch The People take on George Lucas in this new trailer
Comments: 31
terometer
63%
Strike Back below!
by: Paul Tassi Feb. 4, 2010

Since I started writing here at JoBlo a few months ago, one of my biggest surprises has been seeing how most of you guys are quite adamant about defending George Lucas and his decision making process behind “enhancing” the original trilogy and creating three poorly received new installments. The general consensus I hear is “it’s his series, let him do what he wants, he doesn’t owe us anything.”

Well, I’m interested to hear your take on this film project then, THE PEOPLE VS. GEORGE LUCAS, which chronicles the nerd rage against Lucas and what he’s done to their beloved STAR WARS universe. The trailer is below and it features people taking the thing way too seriously, but sometimes raising valid points.

My own opinion? I’m used to being flamed for it at this point, but I think Lucas does owe the fans his best effort to make films worthy of the universe he’s created, and things like re-releases and toy-friendly new movies just seem like cash grabs. I think Lucas has some great ideas, but needs creative control which everyone is too afraid to give him. I think on the inevitable next STAR WARS trilogy, he should consult and advise, but not write or direct, as those duties seem to be beyond him these days.

Source: JoBlo

Add to MFC Profile

Extra Tidbit: Our own JoBlo has a cameo appearance in this documentary, woo-hoo!

31 discussions Expand all
 
+1
Vote Up Vote Down
Sulaco
5:47AM on 02/05/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
What the hell does Rick McAllum ACTUALLY DO?
What the hell does Rick McAllum ACTUALLY DO?
 
-3
Vote Up Vote Down
Jeff Knite
9:12PM on 02/04/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
episode IV.. 2nd Best SW... Really??
Let's be for real man... Every now and then I have a SW marathon for myself and friends or family and Episode IV is the least enjoyable of all of them... It might have been the shit back in the day but it does not hold up, even with all the cosmetic surgery Lucas did to it.. Empire on the other hand holds up and is just a much better film.. So let's stop this praising E.IV crap. Just because...
Let's be for real man... Every now and then I have a SW marathon for myself and friends or family and Episode IV is the least enjoyable of all of them... It might have been the shit back in the day but it does not hold up, even with all the cosmetic surgery Lucas did to it.. Empire on the other hand holds up and is just a much better film.. So let's stop this praising E.IV crap. Just because you have these memories in your head of the first time seeing it, doesn't make it great.. I love the original CLASH OF THE TITANS but I watched it recently and it looks terrible.. I still love it because I've seen it so many times and those images are burned into my memory but who am I kidding the movie is no CASABLANCA
 
+4
Vote Up Vote Down
anomaly7
7:35PM on 02/04/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
To quote Harvey Dent "You either die a hero, or live long enough to see yourself become the villian." I don't think that could be more true for anyone in cinema but Lucas. He'll always get a free pass from me, because without him we'd live in a universe where star wars and indiana jones never existed, and that is sad, sad thought. Much worse the a few disappointing installments.
To quote Harvey Dent "You either die a hero, or live long enough to see yourself become the villian." I don't think that could be more true for anyone in cinema but Lucas. He'll always get a free pass from me, because without him we'd live in a universe where star wars and indiana jones never existed, and that is sad, sad thought. Much worse the a few disappointing installments.
 
+1
Vote Up Vote Down
KeMo
7:34PM on 02/04/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Every SW movie he has touched since IV has been shit. Thank God; Irvin Kirshner directed the greatest SW of all time..Empire Strikes Back! At least we have that. SW fans know whats best for the franchise. This thing became bigger than Lucas.
Every SW movie he has touched since IV has been shit. Thank God; Irvin Kirshner directed the greatest SW of all time..Empire Strikes Back! At least we have that. SW fans know whats best for the franchise. This thing became bigger than Lucas.
 
-1
Vote Up Vote Down
NeuroticNikk
6:05PM on 02/04/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Gotta poke fun at da Fanboys
First off Greedo did shoot first, check out my youtube for proof lol, second, Star Wars...it's just a film
First off Greedo did shoot first, check out my youtube for proof lol, second, Star Wars...it's just a film
1 Reply
 
filmguy450
2:57PM on 02/05/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Man, I read all your replies and now this. I am a little confused on something: How is "Episode IV" the only true SW film? Also, the post of which you replied that in made no mention of it, so what are you agreeing with exactly?

Now, you are wrong. Yes, E.IV is the only one that lucas wrote and directed, but why in the fucking hell does that negate the other two films in the origin...
Man, I read all your replies and now this. I am a little confused on something: How is "Episode IV" the only true SW film? Also, the post of which you replied that in made no mention of it, so what are you agreeing with exactly?

Now, you are wrong. Yes, E.IV is the only one that lucas wrote and directed, but why in the fucking hell does that negate the other two films in the original trilogy?

Finally, sure, the kids now growing up with the new SW (TV shows, prequels, etc) may enjoy them, but when you look at each of the three new films objectively and take them out of the SW universe, you can't call them good, in any fashion, so, the imagination may be igniting a new generation, but as movies, they are terrible.

Finally, it's his vision, but without the fans, there wouldn't be a "George Lucas", so he does owe us, and we owe him.
 
+1
Vote Up Vote Down
Common Sense Man
5:25PM on 02/04/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Stop Lucas just Stop!
I grew up with Star Wars saw it in 77 when I was 10. And I feel he has destroyed the series. I would love to see more SW films but I totally agree he needs to consult, maybe even write but never ever sit in the Directors chair again! I mean compare the multi million dollar second trilogy with the first...there is no comparison the original is better. Money does not a movie make.
I grew up with Star Wars saw it in 77 when I was 10. And I feel he has destroyed the series. I would love to see more SW films but I totally agree he needs to consult, maybe even write but never ever sit in the Directors chair again! I mean compare the multi million dollar second trilogy with the first...there is no comparison the original is better. Money does not a movie make.
1 Reply
 
NeuroticNikk
6:07PM on 02/04/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
All who grew up with the original trilogy say the same thing, there is no denying that the new trilogy is great, to those who grew up with it (and for the record, I am NOT one of those people, original trilogy all the way)
All who grew up with the original trilogy say the same thing, there is no denying that the new trilogy is great, to those who grew up with it (and for the record, I am NOT one of those people, original trilogy all the way)
 
-10
Vote Up Vote Down
Zo!
3:50PM on 02/04/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Star Wars sucked anyway. I was always a Star Trek fan. GL was trying to compete with Gene but fell short. My brother hates when I say stuff like that.
Star Wars sucked anyway. I was always a Star Trek fan. GL was trying to compete with Gene but fell short. My brother hates when I say stuff like that.
1 Reply
 
NeuroticNikk
6:10PM on 02/04/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
lol If a fanboy ever comes up to you and threatens your life with a lightsaber, pull out your phaser and incinerate them (blasters may be uncivilized, but not phasers)
lol If a fanboy ever comes up to you and threatens your life with a lightsaber, pull out your phaser and incinerate them (blasters may be uncivilized, but not phasers)
 
+3
Vote Up Vote Down
justjoe
3:14PM on 02/04/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Some people may be a little harsh on olīLucas but fact is he surerly ows the fans alot (without that overwhelming success of Star Wars nobody would remember him nowadays to be quite honest), so itīs as much "his triology" as it is of his audience. After all heīs a media mogul thanks to the fanbase heīs pretty much fucking around with right now. And yeah, he nearly fucked up the Indiana...
Some people may be a little harsh on olīLucas but fact is he surerly ows the fans alot (without that overwhelming success of Star Wars nobody would remember him nowadays to be quite honest), so itīs as much "his triology" as it is of his audience. After all heīs a media mogul thanks to the fanbase heīs pretty much fucking around with right now. And yeah, he nearly fucked up the Indiana Jones-franchise lately as well (who else could come up with those CGI-rats???). And to those who enjoyed the prequels, well...honestly I canīt help you!
 
+4
Vote Up Vote Down
razgriz21
3:07PM on 02/04/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
I don't know what to say.



Sad or funny.
I don't know what to say.



Sad or funny.
 
+1
Vote Up Vote Down
cupajoe
3:00PM on 02/04/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Star Wars fans really need to fuckin let it go. These guys talk tough but you know if they met George in person they would all drop to their knees and proceed to undo his belt buckle like we all would.
Star Wars fans really need to fuckin let it go. These guys talk tough but you know if they met George in person they would all drop to their knees and proceed to undo his belt buckle like we all would.
2 Replies
 
NeuroticNikk
6:11PM on 02/04/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
I sure as fuck wouldnt undo his belt buckle, damn and Star Wars fans think us Trekkies are bad...
I sure as fuck wouldnt undo his belt buckle, damn and Star Wars fans think us Trekkies are bad...
 
Common Sense Man
5:25PM on 02/04/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
If I undid his belt it would simply be to beat him senseless with it!
If I undid his belt it would simply be to beat him senseless with it!
 
+5
Vote Up Vote Down
Ocelot_Snake
2:57PM on 02/04/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
I love Star Wars, big fan, but thank god im nothing like these people. Can anyone say permanent wedgie?
I love Star Wars, big fan, but thank god im nothing like these people. Can anyone say permanent wedgie?
 
+1
Vote Up Vote Down
cupajoe
2:56PM on 02/04/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Star Wars fans really need to fuckin let it go. These guys talk tough but you know if they met George in person they would all drop to their knees and proceed to undo his belt buckle like we all would.
Star Wars fans really need to fuckin let it go. These guys talk tough but you know if they met George in person they would all drop to their knees and proceed to undo his belt buckle like we all would.
2 Replies
 
Ocelot_Snake
3:02PM on 02/04/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Just like the South Park girls when they met the Jonas Brother. Mouths open ready to pleasure
Just like the South Park girls when they met the Jonas Brother. Mouths open ready to pleasure
 
Terminal_83
2:58PM on 02/04/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Eww.
Eww.
 
+6
Vote Up Vote Down
zohan
2:54PM on 02/04/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
2 things
1. "I think on the inevitable next STAR WARS trilogy"

umm...what? i hope not. let it end where it ended and be done with it! (read that in the same voice of the guy that fussed at george costanza about double dipping)



2. "Hayden Christensen as Anakin might be one of the worst casting decisions of all time"

what other douche could they have casted?
1. "I think on the inevitable next STAR WARS trilogy"

umm...what? i hope not. let it end where it ended and be done with it! (read that in the same voice of the guy that fussed at george costanza about double dipping)



2. "Hayden Christensen as Anakin might be one of the worst casting decisions of all time"

what other douche could they have casted?
1 Reply
 
Terminal_83
2:58PM on 02/04/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Are you kidding?! They could have cast an unknown but someone who could actually act! Plus Anakin was not what I wanted in this series. Anakin should have been taller than Obi Wan, bigger in stature, and possess a deeper voice. Every time Hayden screamed he sounded like a little boy who wanted some ice cream. I mean when he screamed "I hate you!!" in "Revenge of the Sith" gave a slight chuckle ...
Are you kidding?! They could have cast an unknown but someone who could actually act! Plus Anakin was not what I wanted in this series. Anakin should have been taller than Obi Wan, bigger in stature, and possess a deeper voice. Every time Hayden screamed he sounded like a little boy who wanted some ice cream. I mean when he screamed "I hate you!!" in "Revenge of the Sith" gave a slight chuckle in response. It was pathetic.
 
+4
Vote Up Vote Down
JohnLocke2342
2:44PM on 02/04/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Lucas is a control freak who constantly surrounds himself with people that won't challenge him. Being Spielberg's long time friend probably gave him the extra boost he needed to fuck up Indy IV as well. In the Bonus Materials of Indy IV you see that it was Lucas who insisted on aliens, digital print and the use of more CGI. I mean christ, he shot 99% of Episodes II and III in a blue...
Lucas is a control freak who constantly surrounds himself with people that won't challenge him. Being Spielberg's long time friend probably gave him the extra boost he needed to fuck up Indy IV as well. In the Bonus Materials of Indy IV you see that it was Lucas who insisted on aliens, digital print and the use of more CGI. I mean christ, he shot 99% of Episodes II and III in a blue warehouse. Half the time they were just sitting in a room with chairs AND that was CGI!



Lucas gets way too much credit for basically coming up with a knight rescuing a princess from an evil emperor and putting it in space. The last 4 movies he was involved in were viewed as failures from an audience's viewpoint
 
+0
Vote Up Vote Down
Terminal_83
2:38PM on 02/04/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
People often forget that Lucas didn't direct or write ROTJ or TESB. I'm sick of those people insisting "It's his vision, he can do what he wants, blah blah, yak yak," fuck off. Lucas is a creatively impotent hack who made ONE good Star Wars film and has insisted on destroying the only two he didn't actually direct to pretend it was his vision.



As for this documentary, it looks...
People often forget that Lucas didn't direct or write ROTJ or TESB. I'm sick of those people insisting "It's his vision, he can do what he wants, blah blah, yak yak," fuck off. Lucas is a creatively impotent hack who made ONE good Star Wars film and has insisted on destroying the only two he didn't actually direct to pretend it was his vision.



As for this documentary, it looks very good, and I intend to see it with as much objectivity as possible.
1 Reply
 
NeuroticNikk
6:14PM on 02/04/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
I agree that episode iv was the one and only true star wars film, but u have to give lucas credit, it was his baby, he just didnt breast feed it enough (gene Roddenberry didnt write most of Star Trek, but it has always been his vision)
I agree that episode iv was the one and only true star wars film, but u have to give lucas credit, it was his baby, he just didnt breast feed it enough (gene Roddenberry didnt write most of Star Trek, but it has always been his vision)
 
+1
Vote Up Vote Down
Spacegojira
2:08PM on 02/04/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Looks like fun
I'm going to watch this Doc for sure when it comes out. It's probably going to be hilarious. The truth is...the original trilogy is WAY better than the last 3. Whether you like it or not, thats just the simple truth. I'm going to wait until Lucas either dies, or comes to his senses and we get some better star wars movies/ TV shows.
I'm going to watch this Doc for sure when it comes out. It's probably going to be hilarious. The truth is...the original trilogy is WAY better than the last 3. Whether you like it or not, thats just the simple truth. I'm going to wait until Lucas either dies, or comes to his senses and we get some better star wars movies/ TV shows.
 
+0
Vote Up Vote Down
vesaker
1:58PM on 02/04/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
as if
I needed another reason to not drink coffee...
I needed another reason to not drink coffee...
 
-3
Vote Up Vote Down
GroundlessNFree
1:42PM on 02/04/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Ewoks or Jar Jar
I don't think he did anything in the prequels that's any worse than Return of the Jedi. Not a fan of enhanced and prequels, but if Chewbacca lives on Endor you must acquit. Wait, who is the defendant in this trial?
I don't think he did anything in the prequels that's any worse than Return of the Jedi. Not a fan of enhanced and prequels, but if Chewbacca lives on Endor you must acquit. Wait, who is the defendant in this trial?
 
+1
Vote Up Vote Down
goes_to_ricks
1:40PM on 02/04/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
"...but needs creative control which everyone is too afraid to give him."



Seriously? Every ounce of creativeness this guy drops on us is an uninspired pipe bomb. (Of course, I'm not referring to the "originals")



If anything, he's way too focused on what he sees as his target audience (9 years old and younger), and even then, the product is ultimately just what a...
"...but needs creative control which everyone is too afraid to give him."



Seriously? Every ounce of creativeness this guy drops on us is an uninspired pipe bomb. (Of course, I'm not referring to the "originals")



If anything, he's way too focused on what he sees as his target audience (9 years old and younger), and even then, the product is ultimately just what a Hollywood suit believes is "fun".
 
+4
Vote Up Vote Down
RyFranzese24
1:13PM on 02/04/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
This movie is completely and utterly true. George Lucas is worse than Hitler. Much, much worse. Am I being sarcastic? Yup.
This movie is completely and utterly true. George Lucas is worse than Hitler. Much, much worse. Am I being sarcastic? Yup.
 
-2
Vote Up Vote Down
ElderPredator
1:02PM on 02/04/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
It's his trilogy...end of story.
I'm speaking as a "Star Wars" fan who actually really likes the prequel trilogy and there are many more like me out there.



I think this new documentary is kinda dumb to be honest cause George can't satisfy everyone, that's impossible. Even if he did listen to what the fans wanted, people would still find some reason to complain or say that he "trampled on their childhoods". Bull!
I'm speaking as a "Star Wars" fan who actually really likes the prequel trilogy and there are many more like me out there.



I think this new documentary is kinda dumb to be honest cause George can't satisfy everyone, that's impossible. Even if he did listen to what the fans wanted, people would still find some reason to complain or say that he "trampled on their childhoods". Bull!
1 Reply
 
Ocelot_Snake
2:59PM on 02/04/2010 Add as a friend | MFC profile
True
True