In the sleepy New England town of Loblolly on the Sea, a letter has arrived that is going to wake things up. It’s a love letter; ardent, sensual — and unsigned. Everybody who reads it will wonder who it’s for and speculate who it’s from. As the letter falls into different hands, some residents in the small town start to see one another with renewed interest.

Determined to find it’s author, Helen MacFarquhar (Kate Capshaw) begins a quest that will open her life to a new chapter involving two different men: George (Tom Selleck), an old flame from her past, and Johnny (Tom Everett Scott) a young man very much in her present. Will one of them decide her future?

Unexpectedly, one mysterious love note has the power to unlock some startling secrets, changing the lives of everyone it reaches.