A successful community theatre company is turned upside down when the director of an upcoming production of “Cyrano” casts an inexperienced young man with no apparent talent in the lead. The young man, Peter Rooker (Marcus Thomas), soon becomes caught up in the various intrigues of the “theater people,” including the charming but mercurial Michael (John Corbett), the beautiful leading lady Grace (Amy Smart), and a colorful cast of eccentric players (including Sen Astin, Patty Duke and Alan Corduner). Peter soon discovers that in the world of theater the normal rules do not apply – but in the end there is a role for everyone.