JOBLO'S MOVIE REVIEWS

SEARCH BY TITLE # A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z
Guess Who (2005)
star Printer-Friendly version
Review Date: March 23, 2005
Director: Kevin Rodney Sullivan
Writer: David Ronn, Jay Sherick, Peter Tolan
Producers: Ashton Kutcher, Bernie Mac, Jason Goldberg…
Actors:
Ashton Kutcher as Simon
Bernie Mac as Percy
Zoe Saldana as Theresa
Plot:
A white guy is about to meet the black parents of his girlfriend and is, understandably, a little nervous about it. It isn’t long after his initial meeting with the surprised daddy that our boy realizes that he hasn’t particularly impressed the man, and gets even more edgy about the whole thing. What ensues are a number of misunderstandings, many of which involve humor underlined by the two races showcased in the film.
Critique:
I think that comedies are the “hardest” movies to review because one’s enjoyment of said films may depend on a variety of factors, many of which are not necessarily related to the actual movie, including your “mood” on a certain day, your attraction/affection for a certain actor/actress, your ability to relate to the particular humorous core of the film and…well, let’s face it, the “type” of humor that makes you laugh. In the case of this film, I was in a “so-so” mood before seeing it (wasn’t expecting much, to be honest with you), I’m a fan of the film’s stars in Ashton Kutcher and Bernie Mac, I was pretty sick of movies featuring married-couples-to-be meeting their in-laws (or films which played the whole “black and white” jokes up) and I generally like most types of humor. Now while this movie certainly didn’t break any records for originality (it’s a remake and essentially just copies MEET THE PARENTS, but with an African-American angle), I found myself laughing pretty consistently the whole way through, in various forms of guffaws, chuckles, smiles, big laughs and even a couple of taps of the hands together. Yes, Kutcher and Mac came through in their respective parts, and even more importantly, in their chemistry together.

Much like the aforementioned movie, this one has little to do with the girl/boy couple, as much as it did the son-in-law-to-be meeting dear ol’ daddie dickhead. And who better to play the “angry black man” but Bernie Mac, an actor who I’ve been praising since OCEAN’S 11 and hoping would eventually break out in a film deserved of his comedic talents. His character’s dry and sarcastic nature was ideal for Mac and he comes through gangbusters here. Kutcher also gets raked over the coals by way too many people off-screen (many of which are likely really annoyed by his PUNK’D persona), but I like the guy. I think he’s personable, funny, cute and he’s definitely got a physical comedic thing happening that cracks me up. Yes, a number of the film’s jokes are in the trailer (and the whole black/white songs playing on the radio was terribly contrived and unfunny), but unlike other movies, it’s got a whole lot more in there as well, in fact…that’s what I liked most about this film…it was consistent. It wasn’t until its final half hour (it did run a little too long), that things got a little “sentimental”, that the jokes stopped for a little while, but otherwise, I just couldn’t help but laugh anytime Mac came on the screen and eye-balled our man.

Sure, the film plays on the stereotypes, but it doesn’t feature them in that stupid BRINGING DOWN THE HOUSE way. It actually has the characters discussing, laughing and speaking directly about those attitudes (“Go ahead…tell me some black jokes.”), which made it a little more than your typical Hollywood schlock. Heck, I even bought the romance between Kutcher and the adorable Zoe Saldana, and thought they were damn cute together! In the end though, as I mentioned off the top, you’re likely to enjoy your time with these folks depending on your mood of the day, your appreciation of the two lead actors and your enjoyment of this “type” of comedy (thank God the soundtrack wasn’t littered with hip-hop crap), and I for one, had a good time and walked out with a smile. And in the end, I don’t think one can really ask for much more from any comedy. PS: If this film actually does break big bank, please – and yes, I’ll even say “pleaze” – do not make a sequel to it entitled GUESS WHO’S HAVING A BABY or some shit. Just let it go, man.
(c) 2017 Berge Garabedian
Strikeback
Not registered? Sign-up!
Or

2:20PM on 01/16/2006

Good

Ashton Kutcher and Bernie Mac are both very funny and when they are a team they are hilarious. The movie was good and was not your typical comedy. The movie was kind of racist (but not in a bad way). This is a remake of the 1970's GUESS WHO'S COMING TO DINNER? Although I haven't seen the original I still plan to see it soon as if this is good (and usually the remake isn't that good) the original must be good too. But in the original it is a black guy with a white chick with a white family. But
Ashton Kutcher and Bernie Mac are both very funny and when they are a team they are hilarious. The movie was good and was not your typical comedy. The movie was kind of racist (but not in a bad way). This is a remake of the 1970's GUESS WHO'S COMING TO DINNER? Although I haven't seen the original I still plan to see it soon as if this is good (and usually the remake isn't that good) the original must be good too. But in the original it is a black guy with a white chick with a white family. But with this one it is the other way around with a white guy with a black girl with a black family. The acting was great and funny and cracked up at Mac and Kutcher. Kutcher plays the mellow nerdy boyfriend well while Mac is funny as the uptight stuck up father. Great pair don't you think? I found myself laughing throughout the movie but then it started to lose its gas. The ending did not surprise me as it was just plain not funny! It was too slow and sentimental for my taste and was not funny. I was expecting to laugh throughout the whole thing but I found myself practically falling asleep at the end. The ending didn't catch me by surprise at all and could see it coming a mile away. A good date movie but it ran out of gas at the end.
Your Reply:



1:20AM on 08/15/2005

over-rated

this movie was terrible. ashton kutcher plays the same character in all of his movies. bernie mac has done way better than this
this movie was terrible. ashton kutcher plays the same character in all of his movies. bernie mac has done way better than this
Your Reply:



JoBlo's T-Shirt Shoppe | support our site... Wear Our Gear!