JOBLO'S MOVIE REVIEWS

SEARCH BY TITLE # A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z
Old Boy (2005)
star Printer-Friendly version
Review Date: March 22, 2005
Director: Park Chan-Wook
Writer: Park Chan-Wook, Lim Chun-hyeong, Hwang Jo-yun
Producers: Lim Sueng-yong
Actors:
Choi Min-Sik as Dae-Su
Yu Ji-Tae as Woo-Jin Lee
Kang Hye-jeong as Mi-Do
Plot:
A man, with a lovely wife and child, wakes up to find that he is locked up in a room/prison for a reason about which he's never told, by someone who he's never told about. Fifteen years later, he is let go, only with more questions than answers. He spends the rest of the film trying to find out who incarcerated him for all those hellish years and for what reason-and in relation to that...to get revenge!!!
Critique:
Now that's what I'm talking about! For this, the third film that I've seen at this year's Cannes Film Festival, I was finally blown away by something utterly original which not only managed to capture me both from an emotional and stylistic point of view, but an intellectual and mathematical one as well. Mathematical, you may be asking yourself? That's right, it's been a while since a film has managed to fuck with my head as much as this one did here, bringing out the same sort of feelings that I had while watching movies like MEMENTO, A CLOCKWORK ORANGE and THE GAME. In fact, you can qualify this film as the Asian, much more sadistic version of Fincher's maze of questions, with a much greater emphasis on the why, rather than the "who" or the "what". What I especially loved about this film is how it placed me, the audience member, in the same place as the film's protagonist from scene one, basically being thrown into an extremely inhuman situation (being locked inside a room for 15 years without knowing why or who is doing it to you) and being asked to figure it out all as it comes. As the film progressed, clues provided and responses given, I discovered even more questions and theories sprouting about, until the film's finale just simply blew me for a loop. I'm not sure if this is just a trend, but there is a major Asian renaissance happening in the movie industry today and it is films like this, that re-confirm that Hollywood needs to get their shit together and come up with more creative ideas for cinematic entertainment. You and I both know that someone is going to buy the American rights to this film soon enough and remake it as an "American movie" starring some asshole from the WB and with a much gentler ending.

That's another thing that I loved about this movie and that was its uncompromising approach to the material and its ability to "keep the course" despite things getting quite graphic, both visually and mentally. In other words, these guys don't let up until the very end and it's a great thing to experience, even if things do go a little overboard nearing its conclusion (felt like 2-3 endings). Another aspect of the film which connected with me greatly was its visual approach, which wasn't as stylistic as you'd think, but included plenty of cool touches, particularly one wide-frame 4-minute shot of the lead fighting against a multitude of opponents, but all without cutting away once. It's a great shot and a defining moment in the movie. Another aspect that comes through very clearly in this film is its surreal nature. Throughout this affair, things get a little "dream-like" from time to time, feeling hyper-naturalistic at times, but it works under the circumstances, especially after you yourself, experience the film's first 10-15 minutes, alone in a room with a man losing his mind. The actors are also all great, specifically Choi Min-Sik, who plays the man on the edge brilliantly, as well as Kang Hye-Jeong, who is just plain adorable. The film is not a one-trick pony either. It's not just a matter of finding out why this act has been perpetrated upon this individual, but rather, once that's done, understanding the underlying reasons for any human being to cause such pain/suffering onto another. When you sit back and look at the big picture of the world, it's a perfect metaphor for what seems to be a place in which people will take a small ripple in the water and allow it to grow bigger and bigger, until the small ripple is now of much greater meaning.

If revenge is the theme in many American movies this year, OLD BOY fits right into that master plan, only it takes that vengeful attitude to a whole new absurdly sadistic level. Wow, and you thought you had vengeful tendencies? You gotta see what the folks in this movie do. Incredible!

Review originally written on May 15, 2004 after viewing at the Cannes Film Festival
(c) 2017 Berge Garabedian
Strikeback
Not registered? Sign-up!
Or

4:37PM on 05/19/2007

Boring

I had mild expectations for this movie and was completely let down. I figured out the ending before it was revealed, but after a great first 45 minutes or so, I thought the rest of the movie was like pulling teeth (LOL) so to speak.
I had mild expectations for this movie and was completely let down. I figured out the ending before it was revealed, but after a great first 45 minutes or so, I thought the rest of the movie was like pulling teeth (LOL) so to speak.
Your Reply:



1:50AM on 03/10/2006
Damn!! I finally caught this movie after hearing all the ravings about it (mostly from this website) and hot damn if I can't agree with you people. What an awesome mind f*ck!! This movie had me inside the whole damn time. You want to know what the hell is going on with this guy, you have to know for crying out loud. The pace of the movie is so perfect - you're following this guy, listening to his account of what's he's thinking - and also following along, somewhat, with his tormentor.
But
Damn!! I finally caught this movie after hearing all the ravings about it (mostly from this website) and hot damn if I can't agree with you people. What an awesome mind f*ck!! This movie had me inside the whole damn time. You want to know what the hell is going on with this guy, you have to know for crying out loud. The pace of the movie is so perfect - you're following this guy, listening to his account of what's he's thinking - and also following along, somewhat, with his tormentor.
But when you get to the end, you wish you'd never gotten into the movie theatre - it's that freakin' mindblowing.
This movie is graphic in so many ways - from the final secret to the 2-3 minute fight scene (uncut mind you, all one continuous shot - kickass). And this isn't a martial arts fight scene, like I was half expecting, but a gruesome fist fight with hammers and knives and all kinds of other stuff. It adds to the atmosphere of this movie - to the dark tone of the revenge story.
And the characters make it all come together. You feel sorry for the main guy throughout and basically see everything through his POV (very much like Memento in that aspect). And his performance at the end was just perfect - but at that point you're so shocked you're not sure what to make of him or the situation.
If you want a love story or beating the odds, character-driven drama - don't see this movie. If you're into movies that screw with your mind - this is definitely the flick for you.
Your Reply:



5:00PM on 09/12/2005

Left me Shaking

I liked this film alot but i watched it expecting hammer in the face, gore and madness, but It was something completely unexpected. I loved the performence of Choi Min-Sik he was excellent through out and i liked the other characters but the dubbing can put one off, i am still shaking from the out come of the whole film* I loved the 4 min fight scene it was incredibly different.
Stewie
*(spoiler start)

the deal with Mi-Do being his Daughter (spoiler end)
I liked this film alot but i watched it expecting hammer in the face, gore and madness, but It was something completely unexpected. I loved the performence of Choi Min-Sik he was excellent through out and i liked the other characters but the dubbing can put one off, i am still shaking from the out come of the whole film* I loved the 4 min fight scene it was incredibly different.
Stewie
*(spoiler start)

the deal with Mi-Do being his Daughter (spoiler end)
Your Reply:



12:02AM on 09/02/2005

Good but Disappointing

When i went into watching Oldboy, i was hoping for a decent revenge flick and thats what i got, but i was still disappointed. The acting, direction and Music score all good and the story is intersating but the movie didn't really blow me away and wasn't that exciting. Too much talking, not enough action (but maybe thats cause i've been spoiled by those american revenge flicks) A bit overrated. Decent though.
When i went into watching Oldboy, i was hoping for a decent revenge flick and thats what i got, but i was still disappointed. The acting, direction and Music score all good and the story is intersating but the movie didn't really blow me away and wasn't that exciting. Too much talking, not enough action (but maybe thats cause i've been spoiled by those american revenge flicks) A bit overrated. Decent though.
Your Reply:



JoBlo's T-Shirt Shoppe | support our site... Wear Our Gear!