TDK is all-time

+0

I agree

KyleMoucha86
11:37PM on 07/21/2008

that IMDB isn't the most loyal 'news source' to follow, but the difference here is that USERS have voted it to that spot, not [link]

+0

Call me Indiana
9:56PM on 07/21/2008

Add as Friend | Profile

THE DARK KNIGHT was, plain and simple, an amazing movie.

That said, we're talking about IMDB here. The same website that saw Joblo's April Fool's article about Kate Beckinsale being cast as Wonder Woma...

THE DARK KNIGHT was, plain and simple, an amazing movie.

That said, we're talking about IMDB here. The same website that saw Joblo's April Fool's article about Kate Beckinsale being cast as Wonder Woman (back when Joss Whedon was still working on it) and ran it as fact.

I think that right there just goes to show you how much IMDB is to be trusted.

+0

It's IMDB...

Mister_NOIR
9:51PM on 07/21/2008

Add as Friend | Profile

I dunno, I loved The Dark Knight and everything but I really think if IMDb wants its list to be taken a little more seriously then it should tighten the criteria for what can and can't make it onto the top 250.
...

I dunno, I loved The Dark Knight and everything but I really think if IMDb wants its list to be taken a little more seriously then it should tighten the criteria for what can and can't make it onto the top 250.

Maybe a flick should have to be out for say, 3 to 6 months before it can be considered. I mean, just to put things in perspective, this time last year Die Hard 4 had a spot somewhere on the list. It even made it into the top 100 I think.

So yeah, maybe they should just wait a while for the opening weekend frenzy to cool down before considering it for the top 250. The real test of a film's quality isn't how it's thought of on opening weekend, but how it's thought of 10 or more years down the track.

As I said, I loved The Dark Knight and would definitely put it somewhere in my own personal Top 50 list, but its position at #1 now is nothing more than hype, which kinda detracts from the credibility of that list.

Case in point: Titanic used to be at #1

+0

zaika
6:17PM on 07/21/2008

Add as Friend | Profile

So, who wins for the most TDK stories/articles in the JoBlo universe????

+0

It's not the best movie of all time...

Dasmith11
6:01PM on 07/21/2008

Add as Friend | Profile

...but you can't blame math for doing its job. People see the movie and immediately vote on IMDB, it's that simple. I don't think everyone was rating it based on, "well, was it better than The Godfather?" Of course...

...but you can't blame math for doing its job. People see the movie and immediately vote on IMDB, it's that simple. I don't think everyone was rating it based on, "well, was it better than The Godfather?" Of course not. You can expect to see any movie with enough hype, star-power and appeal that does WELL to get in the Top 10 of that IMDB list. It doesn't translate anywhere close to the AFI Top Films. Everyone chill.

+0

Good Deal

TearJerker917
6:01PM on 07/21/2008

Add as Friend | Profile

Not a big deal guys. The film was great, it deserves this right now.

+0

Murder4cookies
5:09PM on 07/21/2008

Add as Friend | Profile

Check out this picture some guy made at IMDB

[link]112462324

+0

Murder4cookies
5:04PM on 07/21/2008

Add as Friend | Profile

Check out this picture some guy made at IMDB

[link]112462324

+0

Talison
3:03PM on 07/21/2008

Add as Friend | Profile

I had no idea people took the IMDB 250 so seriously. This will average out as time goes on. Several movies jump into the 250 in their first weekend and then drift off. I personally did give DK a 10 because I give movi...

I had no idea people took the IMDB 250 so seriously. This will average out as time goes on. Several movies jump into the 250 in their first weekend and then drift off. I personally did give DK a 10 because I give movies a 10 that completely satisfy me and that I have few to no problems with. But that's the problem with IMDB, that is my scale that I vote by. They don't have a stated scale for what voting for a given movie means. I vote for a film based on it's own merits, others might vote based on comparison with other movies or place in movie history. All could be right, but IMDB doesn't tell us. As such their list basically means nothing. And, like Peter Griffin, I did not care for The Godfather.

+0

........

BXC
2:59PM on 07/21/2008

Add as Friend | Profile

Well.... moving on.....

+0

sbunn10

ginopags
2:42PM on 07/21/2008

Add as Friend | Profile

Biased opinions are cool, so long as you put it that way. People jumping off a cliff in ecstasy yelling TDK is the best thing since, whatever, take it or leave it is kind of silly. I love Batman as a character, and I'...

Biased opinions are cool, so long as you put it that way. People jumping off a cliff in ecstasy yelling TDK is the best thing since, whatever, take it or leave it is kind of silly. I love Batman as a character, and I've enjoyed bits and pieces of the incarnations to film and animation over the years, but no one has made a complete masterpiece, in my opinion, with the material yet. Nolan had the right idea, but again, in my opinion he didn't put together to make a believable and thrilling piece of entertainment. And the worst part is that even most fanboys will agree with the films flaws, and yet with a biased attitude just state that its bar none a great film. I guess its fine for those guys, but I want a better movie. So lay the issues out at least, what worked, what didn't, so next time around we get something better. And believe that something better then this is possible.

+0

Ridiculous

BahWeep
2:41PM on 07/21/2008

Add as Friend | Profile

Talk about people getting swept away in the hype. Overtaking The Godfather? Yeah, talk about premature. This movie, in my eyes, doesn't even come close to possessing the same sort of staying power as a film like The G...

Talk about people getting swept away in the hype. Overtaking The Godfather? Yeah, talk about premature. This movie, in my eyes, doesn't even come close to possessing the same sort of staying power as a film like The Godfather.

By the way, the film has been released all ready so is there any way to shit-can all of these Batman articles? I count four different Batman-related articles/reviews for today alone. Enough is enough.

Is that really too much to ask? Just move on.

+0

Look

sbunn10
2:32PM on 07/21/2008

Add as Friend | Profile

Now i can completely understand why people are getting upset about this. But look.. It was a great film. It is personally one of my favortie movies of all time, maybe my favorite. Now, I dont think that it is the B...

Now i can completely understand why people are getting upset about this. But look.. It was a great film. It is personally one of my favortie movies of all time, maybe my favorite. Now, I dont think that it is the BEST movie of all time, but because I love batman, I am inclined to favor it even more. Realistically, I see it in the top ten all time best. Judging by the critics reviews, the yahoo user ratings, joblo's poll question, and my personal feelings, it has to be. Anyone who disagrees... its ok. You are allowed your opinion, but don't hate on ours, ok?

+0

Balboa6
2:30PM on 07/21/2008

Add as Friend | Profile

I can understand The Godfather, Rocky, Taxi Driver, and all those great classics being among the greatest of all time, but The Dark Knight--don't get me wrong here it was truly astonishing and I believe it is Oscar wo...

I can understand The Godfather, Rocky, Taxi Driver, and all those great classics being among the greatest of all time, but The Dark Knight--don't get me wrong here it was truly astonishing and I believe it is Oscar worthy--has JUST come out. Talk about being premature. Give it some time.

+0

for the record...

ginopags
2:22PM on 07/21/2008

Add as Friend | Profile

TDK sucked. Gets worse the more you think about it. But, it works well in tv spots, and clips. If there was a list for that, let me know and I'll vote for it!

+0

nick_horror
2:15PM on 07/21/2008

Add as Friend | Profile

Seriously? A movie that has only been out for four days is the best movie ever made in the history of movie-making? C'mon people! I know it is a big movie, but give me a break. I doubt the story will ever have the...

Seriously? A movie that has only been out for four days is the best movie ever made in the history of movie-making? C'mon people! I know it is a big movie, but give me a break. I doubt the story will ever have the staying power of films like "The Godfather" and "Shawshank." This is nothing more than an attempt by the fanboys to prove their point: that comic books are a viable literary form--which I agree with. But there is no way on God's green earth that it was the best movie ever made. Hell, on my list, "Funny Games" beats it by at least six spots.

+0

Suprising...

nickdoll
2:08PM on 07/21/2008

Add as Friend | Profile

I work at a movie theater, and though Dark Knight has been selling out, most customers have been disappointed by the flick. Most people say "It's good, but..." and "Meh" when asked how they enjoyed it. I personally lo...

I work at a movie theater, and though Dark Knight has been selling out, most customers have been disappointed by the flick. Most people say "It's good, but..." and "Meh" when asked how they enjoyed it. I personally loved it,though.

Still, it's most definitely not the best movie of all time, or even top 10. Not even the best this year actually.

+0

APzombie
2:07PM on 07/21/2008

Add as Friend | Profile

I bet my lucky coin that not even Nolan is happy about this, because he knows it will only spark negetive reactions from film fans. In fact i feel sorry for any film that gets the number one spot, because theres bound...

I bet my lucky coin that not even Nolan is happy about this, because he knows it will only spark negetive reactions from film fans. In fact i feel sorry for any film that gets the number one spot, because theres bound to be debate and anger. Even a lot of people posted anger in the Godfather IMDB boards the past couple of years.

Is it the best film of all time? no, we all have our favorites, i'm glad though because it could be a hell of a lot worse (like LotR)

+0

Great Movie

TBagNUrMom
1:40PM on 07/21/2008

Add as Friend | Profile

I saw it this weekend and must say it was the BOMB! Now as far as "greatest of all time", that's stretching it a bit. Still a great f***ing movie!! Let's get 3 going already, i'm sure Robin is coming to the next one.

+0

Epic yes...

Omen666
1:38PM on 07/21/2008

Add as Friend | Profile

...greatest of all-time...no. A great film all the way - easily in my personal top 20, but not better than Jaws, Shawshank or Empire Strikes Back.

+0

Snowboy
1:09PM on 07/21/2008

Add as Friend | Profile

#1 of all time? Please. I liked the movie, but that's just ridiculous. It's only been open, what, three days?

+0

Well then...

LivelikeaMurder
1:08PM on 07/21/2008

Add as Friend | Profile

When EXACTLY is it OK too call in the best film ever? Im not saying it is, but too call someone absurd or stupid because they think that is just absurd!

+0

The_DUDE_Abides
12:50PM on 07/21/2008

Add as Friend | Profile

I'm not slamming the Dark Knight by any means because I thought it was an incredible film. But there is no way in hell that a film that just came out less than a week ago can be considered the greatest film of all ti...

I'm not slamming the Dark Knight by any means because I thought it was an incredible film. But there is no way in hell that a film that just came out less than a week ago can be considered the greatest film of all time. Just settle down people.

+0

Shriek10124
12:48PM on 07/21/2008

Add as Friend | Profile

Finally, a group of people who are making sense!! I thought this movie was excellent, but in no way is it to be considered the greatest movie of all time.

I cannot stand hearing these absurd declaratio...

Finally, a group of people who are making sense!! I thought this movie was excellent, but in no way is it to be considered the greatest movie of all time.

I cannot stand hearing these absurd declarations people are saying that this movie is the best; Better than Godfather, Pulp Fiction, Gladiator, Goodfellas, Departed, etc.? Absolutely not!

+0

not_tragedi
12:37PM on 07/21/2008

Add as Friend | Profile

I am inclined to agree. This is just related to the hype of the film. It was spectacular, no doubt of that, but as for it being better than the Godfather? I think we need to take a step back here.

I wou...

I am inclined to agree. This is just related to the hype of the film. It was spectacular, no doubt of that, but as for it being better than the Godfather? I think we need to take a step back here.

I would, however, place Heath Ledger's Joker at the top of the villain's list. Right between Hannibal Lector and Darth Vader would be perfect.

+0

dex14
12:32PM on 07/21/2008

Add as Friend | Profile

The imdb top 250 doesnt mean shit. whenever a new movie opens and a lot of people vote it always gets on the list but quickly drops in the later weeks. why even report this?

+0

Cahoot
12:30PM on 07/21/2008

Add as Friend | Profile

uh... it was good and everything, but it is definitely not the best movie of all time. Sorry guys.

+0

nodirectionhome
12:22PM on 07/21/2008

Add as Friend | Profile

What an amazing film. This is the only film since AMERICAN BEAUTy, that Ive been compelled to tag along and see twice.

I think another sequel would really undermine what Nolan & Co. have accomplished a...

What an amazing film. This is the only film since AMERICAN BEAUTy, that Ive been compelled to tag along and see twice.

I think another sequel would really undermine what Nolan & Co. have accomplished as a film. Gordon's narrative to his son was the greatest ending to a comic book film, ever. True, there were some major plot holes, and they become more apparent the second time, it still as a whole is amazing and serves as a stand alone picture; not a sequel. Its been a long hard road to bring back Bat's to glory after B&R.We certainly dont want Batman "nuking the fridge" in 2012 for the sake of WARNER BROS & McDonalds Happy Meal.

+0

Arvindh

ginopags
12:18PM on 07/21/2008

Add as Friend | Profile

Just because there's a lot going on, doesn't mean it all fits together. On paper, in point form, yeah, it sounds great and exciting. But as I'm watching the movie, I'm feeling a disconnect from one scene to the next. ...

Just because there's a lot going on, doesn't mean it all fits together. On paper, in point form, yeah, it sounds great and exciting. But as I'm watching the movie, I'm feeling a disconnect from one scene to the next. Something happens just because it has too. There's a giant list of stuff that doesn't work well in this movie, its all superficial, but the tone is serious. If don't know if that's supposed to trick me, but it doesn't. Small thing you should pay attention to if you watch it again... what detective work does Batman, or the cops for that matter, actually do in this movie? It's a really lazy script in the sense that it doesn't make things as realistic as the tone, or dialogue, would have us believe.

+0

Poopy-Underwear
11:51AM on 07/21/2008

Add as Friend | Profile

PLEASE

STOP

WRITING

DARK

KNIGHT

ARTICLES

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!(that's great news)!!!!!!!!!!

+0

A.M.A.Z.I.N.G

Arvindh
11:44AM on 07/21/2008

Add as Friend | Profile

TDK has been in my head ever since Thursday and I need something different to talk about, please? How about Batman 3 talk? I'm not sure what I'll be able to say hereon because now that I've watched TDK, I cant stop ta...

TDK has been in my head ever since Thursday and I need something different to talk about, please? How about Batman 3 talk? I'm not sure what I'll be able to say hereon because now that I've watched TDK, I cant stop talking about it. I need something MORE! Anyway...genopags, "a poorly scripted tale"??! C'mon! This flick is more complexed that a boatload of recent movies...and with dissapointments like Spider-Man 3 in the comic world, it's refreshing and hope-giving to see a film like TDK fare this well. Poor script?! Wha?

+0

Zenric
10:50AM on 07/21/2008

Add as Friend | Profile

It's just topping out, the movie was amazing but won't hold that #1 spot.
I guarantee it will settle somewhere within the top 10, maybe even the top 5 though . . .

+0

Yeesh...

ginopags
10:48AM on 07/21/2008

Add as Friend | Profile

It doesn't really matter I guess. I wouldn't be jumping for joy if a movie I love like Clockwork Orange or Seven, or whatever would be number one. Clearly TDK is in this position because fanboys are rabid right now (t...

It doesn't really matter I guess. I wouldn't be jumping for joy if a movie I love like Clockwork Orange or Seven, or whatever would be number one. Clearly TDK is in this position because fanboys are rabid right now (this includes most critics). Keep in mind Metacritic has a slightly more acurate rating system then Rottentomatoes in that it give sthe overall average of the grade, and not whether overall response was positive or negetive. Right now it scores an 83. It goes without saying that many fans are letting TDK get off easy with excellent scores when most of you would agree or have already stated the many annoyances with the TDK, despite some very brilliant parts. A real world Batman? Love it! But a poorly scripted tale... disappointing.

Latest Comments