Categories: JoBlo Originals

When John Carpenter and Wes Craven Got Weird: Inside Their Alive Films Era

Shep Gordon got his start working in the entertainment industry as a manager, guiding the careers of Alice Cooper, Groucho Marx, Raquel Welch, and more. His first producing credits were on Alice Cooper concert videos. He got into the feature film production business in the early ‘80s with producing partner Carolyn Pfeiffer. They formed a company called Island Alive with Island Records founder Chris Blackwell. Their releases included Stop Making Sense, The Hit, and Kiss of the Spider Woman, but the company only lasted for a couple of years. After their partnership with Blackwell came to an end, Gordon and Pfeiffer regrouped as Alive Films. By the late ‘80s, Gordon had secured multi-film deals with two iconic masters of horror: John Carpenter and Wes Craven. Thanks to Alive Films, along with distributor Universal Pictures, Carpenter and Craven were given creative control on a total of four movies: Prince of Darkness and They Live from Carpenter, and Shocker and The People Under the Stairs for Craven.

Gordon certainly had an eye for talent. Carpenter and Craven are two of the most influential filmmakers in horror history. Carpenter gave us Halloween, The Thing, and Escape from New York, among others, while Craven created The Last House on the Left, The Hills Have Eyes, A Nightmare on Elm Street, and Scream. Both were capable of delivering genre classics, but they also had a taste for strange ideas, unconventional storytelling, and movies that went in unexpected directions. The movies they made with Alive Films range from apocalyptic supernatural horror to science fiction satire, from the story of an electric-powered serial killer to a mansion full of abused children. They also represent two different approaches to filmmaking. Carpenter used his opportunities to explore ideas that fascinated him, whether they involved theoretical physics or the manipulation of society. Craven was interested in creating new horror properties that could give him the kind of control and financial rewards he hadn’t received from his association with Freddy Krueger.

Looking back, these four films are a fascinating snapshot of a period when two great filmmakers were given the chance to bring personal and peculiar ideas to mainstream horror productions.

JOHN CARPENTER: SCIENCE, RELIGION, AND SOCIAL CONTROL

Carpenter’s Prince of Darkness begins with a mysterious container hidden beneath a rundown church in Los Angeles. For decades, a guardian priest has watched over it, protecting a secret known only to a forgotten religious order called the Brotherhood of Sleep. When the priest dies, another priest recruits a college professor and a group of graduate students to investigate the strange substance inside the container. The actors include Donald Pleasence and Victor Wong. The students are specialists in fields like physics, microbiology, and biochemistry. They arrive expecting to conduct scientific experiments. Instead, their research begins to reveal that the container holds something more disturbing than any scientific explanation can account for. A two-thousand-year-old book describes a being known as the Sleeper, whose awakening could allow a great evil to enter our world.

PRINCE OF DARKNESS: WHEN SCIENCE MEETS THE SUPERNATURAL

Carpenter came up with the story through his interest in theoretical physics and atomic theory. He wrote the screenplay under the pseudonym Martin Quatermass, a nod to writer Nigel Kneale and his character Professor Bernard Quatermass. Kneale had previously worked with Carpenter on the screenplay for Halloween III: Season of the Witch, although he was unhappy enough with the finished film to have his name removed from its credits. Apparently that didn’t make Carpenter any less of a fan.

Carpenter came up with a genuinely unsettling premise for Prince of Darkness, which combines religious mythology and scientific experimentation as two parts of the same nightmare. The green liquid swirling inside the container is disturbing enough, but things become even more frightening when the characters discover that mirrors may provide access to another world. Meanwhile, the students begin receiving the same dream, a transmission from the future that suggests the apocalyptic disaster they’re trying to prevent may be inevitable.

One by one, the students fall under the Sleeper’s influence. Those who attempt to escape the church discover that murderous, zombie-like homeless people have surrounded it. One of these figures is played by Gordon’s old friend Alice Cooper, whose presence adds another memorable element to an already strange film.

Prince of Darkness is one of Carpenter’s lesser-known works, but it’s one of his most effectively disturbing. The atmosphere is dark, the ideas are unsettling, and the film contains some wonderfully gross imagery. Carpenter and Alan Howarth also deliver another excellent electronic score.

The movie does have its limitations. Its deliberate pacing and restrained approach to the possessed students prevent it from reaching the level of horrific insanity its premise might suggest. These are graduate students, after all, and their tendency to analyze the situation rather than immediately lose their minds can sometimes make the film feel less frantic than it could have been. Still, Carpenter delivers some unforgettable sequences in the final stretch, especially when a student becomes trapped in a janitor’s closet with a room full of possessed people outside. Dennis Dun, who previously worked with Carpenter on Big Trouble in Little China, is involved in that sequence, which is one of the film’s best moments.

Prince of Darkness isn’t one of Carpenter’s most accessible films, but he made full use of the imaginative freedom Gordon was offering. He took his scientific interests, combined them with religious horror, and came up with something terrifying.

THEY LIVE: CARPENTER’S SCIENCE FICTION WARNING

Carpenter followed Prince of Darkness with a film that was directly concerned with the state of the world around him. In 1963, Ray Nelson published a very short story called Eight O’Clock in the Morning. It follows a man named George Nada who awakens from a hypnotic demonstration to discover that strange creatures are living among humanity, controlling society through subliminal messages. Twenty-five years later, Carpenter expanded that concept into They Live, a science fiction action film about consumerism, greed, the shrinking middle class, and the influence of television. Nelson had supplied the central idea, but Carpenter transformed it into a broader commentary on American life.

Roddy Piper stars as Nada, a drifter who arrives in Los Angeles looking for work. He finds a job on a construction site, where he befriends Frank Armitage, played by Keith David, a fellow worker trying to support his family. Frank introduces Nada to a homeless encampment, where Nada discovers a group of people who believe society is being controlled by hidden forces. The group has been using a church as a base for its operations, hacking TV broadcasts to send out messages intended to wake people up. Unfortunately, the creatures they’re fighting are very good at keeping humanity under control.

Nada’s discovery of a pair of special sunglasses changes everything. Manufactured by the resistance, the glasses reveal the subliminal messages hidden in advertisements, magazines, money, and broadcasts. They also expose the creatures’ true appearance: hideous beings disguised as ordinary people. Carpenter replaces the original story’s hypnosis with this simple visual device, which becomes the foundation for the film’s satire. Suddenly, the world is full of commands to Obey, Consume, and Conform. Money tells people to stay asleep. Advertising is a mechanism for social control.

It’s a clever idea, and Carpenter makes the most of it. The sunglasses allow the film to turn familiar everyday environments into something sinister without requiring elaborate explanations. Nada doesn’t handle the revelation well. Once he puts on the glasses, he starts picking fights with the creatures, insulting them in public, and generally making himself a target. Eventually, he walks into a bank carrying a shotgun and begins shooting the aliens. It’s not exactly a sensible strategy for someone attempting to undermine a secret ruling class, but it gets the movie rolling.

Carpenter takes his time getting to this point. Nada doesn’t put on the glasses until roughly a third of the way through the film, allowing the director to examine a world in which poverty and desperation are everyday life.

Nada eventually finds allies in Frank and TV station employee Holly Thompson, played by Meg Foster. Frank is so determined to mind his own business and protect his livelihood that he engages Nada in an extended fistfight rather than putting on the glasses. Their confrontation is one of the most popular sequences, partly because it takes so long for Frank to accept what Nada is trying to show him. That reluctance is an important part of the film. People don’t want to discover that the world they inhabit is built on lies. Even when presented with evidence, they may prefer blissful ignorance over the frightening prospect of having to change their lives.

They Live has developed a substantial cult following, and that has a lot to do with how well its central idea has aged. The technology and social conditions have changed since 1988, but the movie’s concerns about advertising, economic inequality, media influence, and the manipulation of public opinion are still recognizable. If Carpenter were making the same film today, it would be pretty similar. The internet and cell phones would just have to be part of the equation.

The movie also demonstrates that Carpenter wasn’t interested in making horror films just to frighten people. He wanted to say something about the world, and he found an outrageous way to say it.

Unfortunately, Carpenter’s arrangement with Alive Films didn’t work out as planned. Prince of Darkness and They Live were supposed to be the first two entries in a four-picture deal, but the third film, a time travel action project called Victory Out of Time, never went into production. Disagreements over financing and scheduling led to a breakdown in the relationship. Carpenter sued Gordon in 1990, claiming their deal had been breached, and the producer countersued. A project titled At Midnight also went unmade due to this legal dispute, and the idea for a They Live sequel called HypnoWar went out the window as well.

WES CRAVEN: LOOKING BEYOND FREDDY KRUEGER

While Carpenter was using horror to explore his own interests, Wes Craven had a more immediate professional concern: what would come after Freddy Krueger? Craven had created one of the most iconic villains in horror with A Nightmare on Elm Street, but he had little control over the direction of the sequels. Although he co-wrote Dream Warriors and later returned to write and direct Wes Craven’s New Nightmare, he wasn’t the person steering the franchise through most of its development. As he explained to Fangoria, creating Freddy had given him tremendous credibility without giving him a tremendous payday.

SHOCKER: THE NEXT GREAT HORROR ICON?

So when Alive Films gave him an opportunity to develop another horror property with creative control, he jumped at the chance. The result was Shocker, a film designed to introduce a new horror icon and launch a franchise. Its villain, Horace Pinker, was supposed to join the ranks of Freddy Krueger, Jason Voorhees, Michael Myers, and Leatherface.

The concept had originated as a television series idea Craven pitched to Fox under the title The Dream Stalker. The finished film retained the idea of a killer who invades someone’s life through dreams, but Craven took the concept in a different direction by making television the gateway to supernatural horror.

The story is set in Maryville, Ohio, where a serial killer known as the Family Slasher has been terrorizing the population. College football player Jonathan Parker begins experiencing psychic nightmares of the crimes. His visions eventually help him identify TV repairman Pinker as the murderer. With the help of his adoptive father, police lieutenant Don Parker, Jonathan brings Pinker to justice. But the killer has a surprise for his pursuers: he claims that Jonathan is his biological son, and he has supernatural plans for what comes next.

The first part of Shocker is really creepy. Mitch Pileggi plays Pinker as a sleazy, intimidating psychopath, a violent criminal who has inflicted terrible abuse on his own family. His son eventually shot him in the knee, leaving him with a permanent limp. Pinker is a horrible person, and Pileggi makes him compelling to watch. Then Pinker is executed in the electric chair, and Shocker becomes a very different movie. Having made a supernatural deal with mysterious electric entities, Pinker returns as a force capable of possessing other people and eventually traveling through appliances and TV screens.

There are amusing moments along the way. Pinker possesses a little girl, who suddenly develops a foul mouth and a murderous disposition. Several other performers get opportunities to play the villain as he jumps between bodies. But the movie’s tonal shifts become tough to ignore. The frightening serial killer of the opening act eventually becomes a wisecracking supernatural menace who delivers lines like “Take a ride in my Volts-wagen.” He even transforms into a recliner and chants “I think I can, I think I can” while attempting to plug himself into an electrical outlet. It’s difficult to imagine a more dramatic change in characterization.

The climactic battle is one of the film’s most ambitious sequences, taking Jonathan and Pinker through TV programs, stock footage, an episode of Leave It to Beaver, and the living rooms of unsuspecting viewers. It is a wild attempt to turn television into a physical landscape, and it demonstrates how far Craven was willing to push his idea. The problem is that the movie is never able to reconcile its competing identities. What begins as a grim slasher becomes a supernatural thriller and then a live-action cartoon. The film is so scattered that it feels as if Craven crammed several movies into one production.

There were also practical problems. Craven struggled with the MPAA over the film’s violence, and encountered difficulties with the special effects. When the original effects fell through, the replacement work had to be assembled on a tight schedule at greater expense. Craven was never entirely satisfied with the results.

The rock soundtrack, featuring artists like Megadeth, Iggy Pop, and Dangerous Toys, adds another layer of personality to the film, fitting with its late-’80s excess.

Despite the hopes surrounding it, Shocker failed to become a major hit, and the intended franchise never materialized. The movie is full of interesting ideas, but they don’t fit together particularly well. Pinker is an excellent villain for the first half of the film, only to become less threatening as his powers grow. The tonal shifts are jarring, and the effects can be silly. Nevertheless, you have to admire Craven’s willingness to make something so weird. Even when his choices don’t work, he’s clearly trying to push beyond familiar territory. Shocker may not have built the franchise the director wanted, but it’s an entertaining example of a filmmaker whose ambition occasionally outran his ability to hold a story together.

THE PEOPLE UNDER THE STAIRS: A NIGHTMARE BEHIND CLOSED DOORS

Craven’s next film under the arrangement with Alive Films was The People Under the Stairs, another horror movie that took an unusual approach to familiar material. The inspiration came from a newspaper story Craven had read in the late 1970s. A respectable couple had been away on vacation when neighbors noticed someone breaking into their house. Police investigated and discovered that the couple’s children had been imprisoned inside for years.

Craven was fascinated by the contrast between outward respectability and hidden depravity. People who appeared normal and well-behaved could commit horrific acts behind closed doors, while their neighbors were unaware of what was happening.

That idea became the foundation for a story about a poor young boy named Poindexter, nicknamed Fool by his tarot-reading sister. With the family facing eviction, Fool agrees to help his sister’s friend Leroy rob their landlord’s mansion. They expect to find a valuable coin collection. Instead, they discover a house filled with disturbing secrets. The doors are electrified, the windows are secured from the outside, and a boy called Roach is hiding in the walls. The basement contains other children who have fallen out of favor with the mansion’s owners.

The owners call themselves Mommy and Daddy. They’re siblings who have created a grotesque imitation of a conventional family, adopting children and punishing them when they fail to meet their impossible standards. Their daughter Alice has survived by trying not to see, hear, or speak evil. Daddy, played by Everett McGill, hunts through the house with a shotgun and a Rottweiler named Prince. Mommy, played by Wendy Robie, maintains the household’s twisted rules. Both actors had previously appeared together in Twin Peaks, where they played Ed and Nadine, and they bring an eccentric energy to their roles here.

The film becomes a nightmare of secret passages, hidden rooms, and disturbing discoveries. Fool must find a way out of the house, but he also begins to sympathize with the children who have suffered under Mommy and Daddy’s control.

Craven spent years developing the screenplay, struggling to find a way to get Fool into the mansion quickly enough. Early drafts, written under the title The Puzzle, kept the boy outside the house for far too long. The solution eventually came to Craven in a lucid dream, and in the finished film Fool reaches the mansion within the first eleven minutes. Once he solved that structural problem, the production moved forward smoothly.

The mansion’s interior was built on a set, and Craven conceived it as a representation of the human mind. The exterior and first floor seem normal, but the deeper one goes into the house, the stranger and more disturbing things become. The people imprisoned beneath the stairs represent thoughts that their captors attempt to suppress, only to discover that those thoughts cannot be contained forever. Craven also viewed the film as a commentary on American society and a story about younger generations liberating themselves from the madness of their predecessors. The children escaping from Mommy and Daddy’s house become a metaphor for people overcoming the oppression of those who claim to know what’s best for them.

That gives The People Under the Stairs a social dimension that complements its horror imagery. Like They Live, it’s concerned with power and control, although Craven approaches those subjects through a dark fairy tale rather than Carpenter’s science fiction satire.

The film was a box office success, earning more than $31 million against a budget of around $6 million. Critics responded to its blend of horror, humor, and social commentary, although some found the comedy excessive.

Unlike Shocker, The People Under the Stairs wasn’t aiming to establish a new horror icon or launch a franchise. Craven even abandoned an ending jump scare in which Daddy would return, partly because he was tired of that kind of ending and didn’t want to suggest a sequel was coming. The film works as a self-contained story. It’s a one-of-a-kind entry in Craven’s career and demonstrates how much could be accomplished when he was allowed to follow an idea into strange territory.

FOUR FILMS, TWO VERY DIFFERENT VISIONS

Taken together, Prince of Darkness, They Live, Shocker, and The People Under the Stairs show the possibilities and limitations of creative freedom in horror filmmaking. Carpenter used his opportunities to explore subjects that interested him, whether the relationship between science and religion or the ways advertising and economic power influence society. His films aren’t always subtle, but they have a clear identity. Even when their pacing or storytelling choices don’t entirely work, it’s easy to recognize the mind behind them.

Craven’s films are more uneven. Shocker is a fascinating failure of sorts, a movie that tries to create the next Freddy Krueger but becomes so distracted by its own possibilities that it loses sight of what made its villain frightening in the first place. The People Under the Stairs turns a disturbing premise into a horror story with thematic purpose. The Alive Films arrangement offered Craven the freedom to pursue new properties after his experience with A Nightmare on Elm Street, but having control over a project doesn’t automatically make it a success. A franchise needs more than an ambitious concept and a memorable villain; it also needs a story that can sustain the audience’s interest. Shocker didn’t become the next great horror franchise, and The People Under the Stairs didn’t need to become one. Both films have endured as examples of Craven’s willingness to experiment.

That’s what makes these four movies worth revisiting. They’re from a period when established horror filmmakers could take commercial opportunities and use them to explore ideas that were personal, provocative, or downright bizarre. Not every experiment worked. Some were too strange, some too uneven. But the results are more interesting than four interchangeable horror movies designed to follow a formula.

The four films also represent an important period in the brief history of Alive Films. The company’s independent production operation came to an end soon after these movies were released. Carpenter and Gordon eventually worked together again, though, despite the bitter end to their earlier arrangement. Gordon was an executive producer on Carpenter’s 1995 remake of Village of the Damned. It wasn’t a continuation of the original four-picture deal, but at least the dispute hadn’t permanently ended their professional relationship.

Alive Films may have hoped for hits and franchises, but the lasting appeal of these productions is in their individuality. Carpenter and Craven were given room to get weird, and even when the results weren’t entirely successful, they left us with movies that are still worth talking about decades later.

Loading Comments...
Read more...
Published by
Cody Hamman