The official release of David Fincher’s The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth is nearly upon us, but the film is facing accusations of using generative AI, sparking a bit of a backlash.
After recent screenings, some walked out of the film upset over the apparent use of generative AI. Indie filmmaker Patrick Tomasso was “completely gutted” to find that such a great film was “overshadowed by some of the most blatant and egregious AI use I’ve ever seen in a studio film.” Others chimed in to say it was “noticeably distracting” and an “eyesore.”
Now, I haven’t seen Cliff Booth yet, but our own Chris Bumbray has. He confirms that the film does seemingly appear to contain some usage of AI, but “it’s nowhere near as all-consuming as some of the more overheated reactions on social media suggest.” People overreacting on social media? Why I never!
The only time it seems apparent that generative AI was used is in the recreations of Charlie Peters’ (Scott Caan) TV career. He’s the lead in several fictional TV shows of the era that pair him with actors like Robert Wagner, who is still alive. My guess is that Fincher approached him for permission. The sequences don’t appear to use AI to revive any dead actors.
He continued, “These sequences are not unlike the moments in Once Upon a Time in Hollywood where Rick Dalton is inserted into The Great Escape. For that movie, they used CGI. Here, the result looks fairly seamless, and if AI exists for any reason, it’s perhaps to smooth out existing effects rather than replace them. Some people have a knee-jerk reaction against AI tools being used in any way whatsoever, but I’d rather see a guy like Fincher use them, given his attention to detail, than some hack.“
In the specific context in which AI was used in the film, Bumbray thought it worked just fine. “The rest of the movie didn’t seem to feature any AI, and if it did, it was minor,” he said. “I’m sure people will pick it apart when it hits Netflix.” Oh, I’m sure they will.
Netflix hasn’t commented on this, but a Bloomberg report earlier this year said that Fincher had used technology from InterPositive, Ben Affleck’s AI company, on an upcoming project starring Brad Pitt.
Fincher has always embraced the latest technology, so why would AI be any different? Fincher recently spoke with The Los Angeles Times about where he stands on AI.
“I’m not a Luddite, so I don’t fear the unknown,” he said. “Is everyone satisfied that we have figured this art form out enough that what we really need to do is go back to celluloid? How long have people painted? 40,000 years? We’re talking about a thing that’s a hundred years old and everyone’s going, ‘Stop. Pencils down. No more iterating. It’s not necessary to have at your fingertips the ability to change the color of that person’s eyes.’ Well, it exists. Should we not use it?“
The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth will be released in IMAX theaters on November 25, before it lands on Netflix on December 23. You can check out Bumbray’s glowing review of the film right here.
Does the apparent use of AI in The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth change your tune on the film? And if you’ve already seen it, did you notice any use of AI?