If it sounds like I’m being hard on the film, I’m not trying to. I’m actually trying to give the film the benefit of the doubt. There are times when projects sound very similar on paper but wind up being exceptionally different once the final products are released. But in the past Pixar and DreamWorks have released projects like A BUG’S LIFE & ANTZ and FINDING NEMO & A SHARK’S TALE. They weren’t necessarily the same but similar enough to split audiences (in favor of Pixar).
I hope in the development process they’ll take BOO U. further away from any territory mined in MONSTERS and the film has at least two years until release so there’s definitely some time. As for Rogen, this is another in a long line of animated voices. Previously he’s lent his pipes to HORTON HEARS A WHO, THE SPIDERWICK CHRONICLES, KUNG FU PANDA (and it’s upcoming sequel) and MONSTERS VS. ALIENS.