Madden First Reactions Are In: Is Nicolas Cage’s John Madden Biopic a Touchdown or a Fumble?

nicolas cage, maddennicolas cage, madden

At the same time that scores of gamers are deleting Madden NFL 27 off their gaming consoles to make room for Grand Theft Auto VI, the first reactions to David O. Russell’s new film about the legendary John Madden are taking the field.

From the Sidelines to the Broadcast Booth

Russell’s new biopic celebrates John Madden’s remarkable journey from a Super Bowl-winning partnership with Al Davis and the Raiders to creating Madden NFL and becoming one of the most iconic voices in football history. The film stars Nicolas Cage and Christian Bale as Madden and Davis, respectively, with Kathryn Hahn playing Virginia Madden, Sienna Miller as Carol Davis, John Mulaney as Trip Hawkins, and Shane Gillis as Vince McGarry.

The First Reactions Take the Field

If you search for early buzz on social media, it’s challenging to track down solid takes on Russell’s film, so we’ve taken the liberty of collecting some of them here.

According to Junior Felix of That Hollywood Show, the Madden movie “is riotously funny, larger than life, and some of the best 110 minutes I’ve had at the movies this year. Cage and Bale are phenomenal together. I could watch another few hours of just the two of them talking to each other. David O. Russell is back to his absolute best, bringing an unbridled energy to this fun, vibrant, kinetic film. It’s one of the best football films I’ve seen in years. BOOM!”

Meanwhile, Giovanni Lago of Next Best Picture thinks Russell’s film is a complete fumble, saying, “O. Russell’s lifeless SNL parody of a biopic is a mess that rivals Amsterdam on numerous occasions. Never imagined that I’d watch Bale as Al Davis break down N.W.A. to Cage’s John Madden, but here we are.”

Hunter Bolding of That Hashtag Show is still gathering his thoughts, saying, “The more I think about Madden, the more I love it. It certainly feels like it’s going to be a rewatchable ‘happy time’ movie for me.”

Elsewhere, Tyler Disney says he had a “blast” with the film, writing, “What can I say about #MaddenMovie? I had a blast with this film; it’s classic David O. Russell filmmaking. Nicolas Cage steals the show as John Madden. The film is very, very funny and inspiring. Make sure you catch this movie on @PrimeVideo.”

Further down the field, Tom Chatalbash of Film Speak thinks Cage is the wrong person to play Madden, saying, “Unfortunately, Nicolas Cage is woefully miscast in David O. Russell’s MADDEN, a biopic that fumbles the ball in telling the larger-than-life story of the beloved football icon.”

Finally, David Rooney of The Hollywood Reporter thinks Cage and Bale go big or go home in the football biopic, even if the movie itself doesn’t quite stick the landing. While teeing up his full review, Rooney said, “Nicolas Cage and Christian Bale go for broke with their cartoonish performances in MADDEN, but the gonzo football biopic does nothing to shift the downward career trajectory of director David O. Russell.”

Touchdown or Fumble? Here’s the Verdict

Russell’s Madden sounds like a crowd-pleaser, though it depends on who you ask. Back in the day, I was more of a John Madden’s Sports Talk Football II guy than a Madden NFL game fan. While I enjoy the idea of Cage and Bale getting weird for this curious biopic, I think I’ll pass on this one.

Are you looking forward to David O. Russell’s Madden? The film comes out on Prime Video on November 18.

Source: Twitter

About the Author

News Editor / Columnist

Favorite Movies: Death to Smoochy, The Big Lebowski, Fear and Loathing in Las read more Vegas, The Crow, KPop Demon Hunters, The Sword in the Stone, Spirited Away, The Fisher King, The Shining, Planes, Trains, and Automobiles, The Burbs, The Babadook, Summer Wars, The Princess Bride, Mad Max: Fury Road, The Game, In the Mouth of Madness, Who Framed Roger Rabbit, Monsters Inc., Amelie, The Crow, Fight Club, O Brother, Where Art Thou?

Likes: Getting lost in waves of sound while cocooned in a pair read more of serious headphones, comic book characters, film, and television, a delicious tumbler of whiskey, scientifically-inclined Canadians, wearing pajamas in public, pancakes, bacon, and long walks on the beach

The comment section exists to allow readers to discuss the article constructively and respectfully, focused on the topic at hand.

What’s Not Allowed

  • Abusive language, insults, or harassment toward other users or staff.
  • Hate speech of any kind is strictly prohibited.
  • Bickering, bullying, personal attacks, or baiting others to argue
  • Extended off-topic debates, especially those centered on politics or religion rather than the article topic
  • No AI content or SPAM