Madden Review: Nicolas Cage and Christian Bale fail to convert David O. Russell’s biopic into a touchdown

PLOT: Chronicling the life of football icon John Madden—his Super Bowl-winning tenure coaching the Oakland Raiders, his transition to the broadcast booth alongside Pat Summerall, and the creation of the revolutionary Madden NFL video game franchise.

REVIEW: You can see the separation in football fans between those who remember John Madden as a coach and those who know him as a broadcaster and football icon. Madden’s name has become synonymous with the video game that bears his moniker, even if his face no longer graces the cover. The generation that plays the annually updated NFL game likely has no idea who John Madden was or the importance he had to football, and the new film that explores his life fails to really capitalize on his place in sports and gaming history. Released just in time to capitalize on Amazon’s now annual day after Thanksgiving football coverage, Madden is more feel-good cartoon than unvarnished deep dive. Focused more on the bromance between Oakland Raiders owner Al Davis and John Madden, David O. Russell’s movie is fine but falls short of being more than a nice tribute to the beloved title character.

Madden picks up with Nicolas Cage in full-body prosthetics, playing the coach as he leads the Oakland Raiders to their first Super Bowl in 1976. Promising his wife Virginia (Kathryn Hahn) that, now that he has achieved the pinnacle of his career, he would spend more time at home with her and their sons, Madden is pressured by best friend and Raiders owner Al Davis (Christian Bale) to try and turn that win into a dynasty. The stress of trying to repeat as Super Bowl champions eventually gets to Madden, who develops a bleeding ulcer and needs to leave coaching behind. Trying his hand in the broadcast booth, Madden eventually becomes a household name and a pop culture icon. This leads to an eventual partnership with Electronic Arts founder Trip Hawkins (John Mulaney), who woos Madden into helping develop and grace the cover of their innovative football video game. Along the way, John deals with some minor bumps and challenges, but nothing that really stops the progression of this success story.

Nicolas Cage is such a quirky actor, and he inhabited recent roles like Ben Riley in Spider-Noir with less of the full-tilt insanity he has brought to the screen for the last thirty years. Wearing a full-body suit and facial prosthetics, Cage never really sounds or looks much like John Madden. Yes, he does have some of the signature sayings that Madden became notorious for, and the film also features turducken, his Tenactin commercial, and his fear of flying, but most of Cage’s performance is reliant on Madden being a big, lovable goof who had a vault of knowledge related to football and failed to really function when he was outside of that world. There are many moments where you can see Madden withdrawing into himself and talking to the dog because he doesn’t know what else to do, and everyone around him has to figure out how to prevent him from falling apart. But there really is never any fear that anything truly negative is going to happen. None of the fights between characters really get above room temperature, despite some impressive turns from the other members of the cast.

madden

Christian Bale is virtually unrecognizable as Al Davis, though his American accent has started to feel more like a shtick than a transformation. Adopting Al Davis’s receding hairline and brash personality, Bale is the wackier of the two between Davis and Madden. I never would have expected to see a movie where I would think Nicolas Cage was the more subdued of the main characters, but this is the one that shows that is possible. John Mulaney is good in a small yet bland role, while Shane Gillis as Madden’s neighbor Vince is more of an exposition device than a character. Sienna Miller is good as Al Davis’s wife, Carol, though her performance is very small. The highlight of the movie is Kathryn Hahn, who, as always, is sensational. Hahn starts out as being a bit of a cartoon character herself, with a 1970s hairstyle, chain-smoking, and acceptance of her husband’s foibles. As the film progresses, she becomes more of a reliable, grounded character who wants her husband to be part of her life, rather than always having to go along with everything in his world of football.

Written by Cambron Clark and David O. Russell, Madden feels a lot closer to the director’s I Heart Huckabees than Silver Linings Playbook or American Hustle. Russell doesn’t seem to really know what angle he’s going for with the film, featuring a lot of archival footage and accurate recreations of Madden in the booth calling games (using his trademark telestrator and scribbling all over the screen). But then it also ventures into fake interviews with the actors portraying their characters talking directly to the screen. That fades in and out throughout the film and is not used consistently. The movie’s rated R for language, as the characters drop F-bombs left and right throughout, but that’s really the only thing that elevates this beyond a fairly PG offering. There are a few fun little cameos from Snoop Dogg, as well as former NFL players Julian Edelman and Marshawn Lynch, but they all just really feel requisite for a football biopic. Russell benefited, just like the Madden video game, from the NFL’s involvement, which allowed the use of archival footage, team logos, and uniforms, but at times, Madden feels more like a commercial for the NFL rather than a balanced look into the life of John Madden.

I’ve always enjoyed the films of David O. Russell, but Madden marks the third underwhelming offering from the director in a row. Well, not an outright failure like Joy or an overstuffed and confusing work like Amsterdam, Madden is just overly safe and doesn’t really give a story that is all that exciting to watch. I didn’t learn anything new about John Madden, but I didn’t hate watching the movie. This is a harmless but entertaining little sports flick with some sweet moments between Al Davis and John Madden, as well as between John Madden and his wife. Taken as a relationship story, it’s more entertaining than as either a biopic or a sports movie. Not an outright failure, Madden should have been a lot better, considering the level of effort that Nicholas Cage and Christian Bale went into transforming themselves for it.

Madden is now streaming on Prime Video.

Madden

AVERAGE

6

Source: JoBlo.com

About the Author

TV Critic / Columnist
6,463 Articles Published Started writing in 2012

Favorite Movies: Being There, The Shining, The Royal Tenenbaums, Suspiria, Seven, North By read more Northwest, Citizen Kane, The Monster Squad, Begotten, Fight Club, Monty Python and the Holy Grail, Army of Darkness, Children of Men, Blade Runner, The Big Lebowski, Casino, Pi, Dumb and Dumber, The 400 Blows, Small Change, Bonnie & Clyde, Cool Hand Luke, Moulin Rouge, Gangs of New York, Shallow Grave, The Rock, The Incredibles, Who Framed Roger Rabbit?, The Gate, Prince of Darkness, Oldboy, The Dark Knight, The Lord of the Rings, The Tree of Life, The Exorcist III, Midnight Special

Likes: To piss you off, unpopular opinions, the novels of Stephen King, read more obscure bands that even hipsters dont know, things that go boom, Reeses Pieces, Cate Blanchett, reading paper books, watching people falling down, a good jump scare, listening to a full album in one sitting, rooting for the underdog, red band trailers, rare steaks, cool beer labels, smooth whisky, properly proportioned image files, top ten lists, VHS tapes, and actually scary movies

The comment section exists to allow readers to discuss the article constructively and respectfully, focused on the topic at hand.

What’s Not Allowed

  • Abusive language, insults, or harassment toward other users or staff.
  • Hate speech of any kind is strictly prohibited.
  • Bickering, bullying, personal attacks, or baiting others to argue
  • Extended off-topic debates, especially those centered on politics or religion rather than the article topic
  • No AI content or SPAM