Well, I guess I’m the dog guy now. Nestled between the interesting failures based on books like Watchers, which follows a genetically engineered hyper-intelligent dog, and Bad Moon, a werewolf movie where the dog is the hero and main character, lies the unfulfilled potential of 1993’s Man’s Best Friend.
The film had plenty working in its favor. It had strong casting, memorable makeup effects, and a solid score. It also came from writer-director John Lafia, who already had a proven track record in horror. Most importantly, it had the potential to revive the creature feature in a way that could have worked perfectly for mid-90s horror cinema.
Instead, Man’s Best Friend became one of those movies that horror history mostly leaves behind. Even so, it still offers glimpses of what could have been. It’s an enjoyable watch for a number of reasons, even if it falls flat where it matters most for horror hounds and casual viewers alike.
Be prepared to either adopt this movie as your new favorite pup or send it back to the pound as we take a look at the fun failure that is Man’s Best Friend.
Man’s Best Friend is a very 90s horror movie, from its cast to its action to its almost-forgotten status. That’s not to say every 90s horror film ended up lost to time, but a whole lot of them definitely did.
Unfortunately, there isn’t much behind-the-scenes information available about the production. The film was produced by Roven-Cavallo Entertainment and distributed by New Line Cinema during the period between the company’s reign as an 80s horror powerhouse and its later dominance with The Lord of the Rings trilogy. Because this is a New Line release, we also get the obligatory cameo from Robert Shaye, appearing briefly as a mobile mechanic under the name L. E. Moko.
Filming took place over roughly two and a half months, from late January through early April 1993, in Sierra Madre, California. The movie was released on November 19, 1993, shortly after Halloween season.
Critics weren’t impressed, though Ally Sheedy did receive a Saturn Award nomination. Financially, however, the movie performed modestly well, earning around $13 million domestically.
So what happened? Why is this movie barely talked about today? I hadn’t seen it in almost 20 years before revisiting it, but I definitely came away with thoughts.
The plot of Man’s Best Friend doesn’t reinvent the wheel. It borrows heavily from stories like Frankenstein, with a creature that is created rather than born and isn’t entirely responsible for its violent actions. It also clearly takes inspiration from Watchers and other genetically engineered animal stories. The difference is that Max is definitely not the goodest boy.
The film also briefly touches on environmental themes and animal testing, though it never digs deeply enough into those ideas to say anything particularly meaningful.
The movie was written and directed by John Lafia, who deserves far more recognition for his contributions to horror. Lafia co-wrote Child’s Play and directed Child’s Play 2, which is quietly one of the greatest horror sequels ever made, even if it rarely gets mentioned alongside the usual classics.He also worked on episodes of Monsters and Freddy’s Nightmares, and even directed the FMV horror game Corpse Killer, which rules.
The film follows TV reporter and animal activist Lori Tanner, played by Ally Sheedy, after she is contacted by an employee at EMAX about illegal animal testing at the facility. The informant never makes it to the meeting, having been killed by an unseen predator, but Lori still sneaks into the facility alongside her friend and coworker Annie. Inside, they discover abused animals being experimented on in the name of science.
They also rescue Max, an enormous Tibetan Mastiff that immediately screams “this dog will become a problem” to anyone who has ever seen a horror movie.
The trio escapes the facility despite interference from the head genetic scientist, Jarret, played by Lance Henriksen. From there, the movie becomes a battle between Jarret trying to reclaim his “property” and Lori slowly realizing Max is far more dangerous than he appears.
The body count rises, the action escalates, and the film eventually arrives at an ending that clearly sets up a sequel we never got. That was probably for the best, though this absolutely feels like the kind of movie that could have spawned a weird direct-to-video franchise with five increasingly ridiculous sequels.
The biggest issue with Man’s Best Friend is that nearly every interesting idea feels only half-developed. The movie is violent, but not violent enough. It has a large cast, but not particularly likable characters. It features interesting creature concepts, but rarely pushes them far enough.
It sits awkwardly between harder-edged horror and accessible creature-feature fun. It’s too mean-spirited and cynical to work as family-friendly gateway horror like Gremlins or The Monster Squad, but it also lacks the brutality and insanity that horror fans usually want from a killer-animal movie.
That balancing act ultimately leaves the movie stranded in the middle.
Ally Sheedy stars as Lori Tanner, and the film arrived during an interesting period in her career. After dominating the 1980s with films like WarGames, The Breakfast Club, and Short Circuit, the 90s didn’t offer nearly the same level of success. While she appeared in projects like Only the Lonely and later had a memorable role on Oz, much of the decade was filled with more forgettable work.
Sheedy does a decent job here, although the script unintentionally makes Lori responsible for nearly every death in the movie without fully acknowledging it. This also stands as Sheedy’s only true horror movie, though she did appear in several fun made-for-TV thrillers, including the surprisingly entertaining Buried Alive II.
The supporting cast is packed with recognizable genre faces, including William Sanderson, Robert Costanzo, and Frederic Lehne. Still, the standout human performance belongs to Lance Henriksen.
Lance Henriksen has quietly built one of the greatest careers in genre cinema.He’s battled xenomorphs in Aliens, Terminators in The Terminator, and Predators in AVP. He starred in Pumpkinhead and faced off against Jean-Claude Van Damme in Hard Target. The list goes on forever.
Here, Henriksen plays Jarret with a calm, sinister energy that elevates every scene he’s in. From his bizarre pill addiction to his cold obsession with reclaiming Max as company property, he easily becomes the most compelling human character in the movie. Oddly enough, despite clearly being the antagonist, Jarret never directly kills anyone. He threatens people, manipulates them, and knocks them unconscious, but the actual bloodshed is left mostly to Max.
Henriksen’s voice alone carries half the performance. Even when the dialogue isn’t particularly strong, his delivery sells the character.
The real star of Man’s Best Friend is Max himself. The creature effects were handled by legendary makeup artist Kevin Yagher, known for his work on the A Nightmare on Elm Street series, Demon Knight, and countless other horror projects.
For the most part, the practical effects work extremely well. Max looks genuinely intimidating, especially after suffering facial burns later in the movie.
The film combines real dog performances with puppetry and animatronics, and some of the sequences are surprisingly effective. One standout moment involves Max swallowing a cat whole using a mechanical dog puppet after the live animals were swapped out.
And because the universe loves us, Max is voiced by Frank Welker. Of course he is.
Unfortunately, the CGI effects have aged horribly. The infamous camouflage effect looks like something ripped straight out of The Lawnmower Man and instantly dates the movie.
Despite its R rating and fairly high body count, Man’s Best Friend never fully commits to its gore or creature chaos. That’s frustrating because the movie constantly hints at how dangerous Max really is. He has the abilities of multiple predators, including camouflage, enhanced agility, and acidic urine, yet the film rarely uses those ideas to their fullest potential.
Several death scenes feel weirdly restrained. The mailman attack, the police deaths, and especially the acid-urine scene involving Lori’s boyfriend all could have been far nastier and more memorable.
This isn’t Jaws, where hiding the creature increases suspense. This is a genetically engineered killer dog with superpowers. Let the movie get weird.
The biggest issue in Man’s Best Friend is the characters. Unlike many slashers, where audiences either root for the heroes or enjoy watching awful people get picked off, this movie lands in an uncomfortable middle ground. Almost everyone is unpleasant, careless, or emotionally flat. That imbalance kills the emotional stakes.
For comparison, look at the Friday the 13th remake. Audiences genuinely feel bad when Jenna dies, but they also cheer when Trent finally gets what’s coming to him. That contrast matters. In Man’s Best Friend, nobody really earns that reaction. Even the cops fail to leave much impact when they die. Lori herself rarely seems to process the consequences of bringing Max home. Strangely enough, the most sympathetic character in the movie ends up being the killer dog. That probably wasn’t the intended effect.
This movie wants to be Jaws, but it accidentally drifts closer to Godzilla.
Man’s Best Friend is still a fun watch thanks to its brisk runtime, creature effects, and bizarre 90s energy. There’s enough entertainment value here to justify checking it out, especially for fans of forgotten horror oddities.
At the same time, it never fully commits to any of its best ideas. It doesn’t push the gore far enough, doesn’t develop its themes deeply enough, and doesn’t give viewers characters they truly care about.
Sometimes breaking the mold creates a classic. Other times, it creates a movie that slowly disappears from the horror conversation. That’s exactly what happened to Man’s Best Friend.
Still, it’s worth watching at least once. Just maybe don’t let it near your friend’s cat.
Some of the previous episodes of the show can be seen below. To see more, head over to our JoBlo Horror Originals YouTube channel – and subscribe while you’re there!