Robert Pattinson Is James Bond: Why He’s a Great Choice—with a Few Reservations

Chris

Robert Pattinson as James Bond? As soon as it was announced he had screen-tested for the role, 007 fans wondered – could Pattinson actually be Amazon/MGM’s choice for the shaken, not stirred, super spy? Now, it’s official – Robert Pattinson is 007. He’s the seventh actor to play the role on the big screen, following Sean Connery, George Lazenby, Roger Moore, Timothy Dalton, Pierce Brosnan and Daniel Craig.

But, does Pattinson have the charisma, toughness and screen presence needed to pull off 007? Would casting an actor who’s already Batman be a mistake for a franchise that’s traditionally made stars rather than hired them? And, perhaps most importantly, is Pattinson actually a better choice than some of the other actors reportedly in contention?

As a lifelong Bond fan, I’ve got some pretty strong opinions on the subject. So today, we’re going to break down the pros and cons of Robert Pattinson as James Bond and try to answer one big question: Is he actually a solid choice to inherit the licence to kill?

The Pros: Why Pattinson Could Be a Great 007

Robert Pattinson, Christopher Nolan, Tenet

People may not remember, but when Daniel Craig was cast as James Bond in the lead-up to Casino Royale, fans were outraged. After all—he was blond! James Blond??? Of course, the presumed wrong choice ended up being the right one after all, with him having a stunning run as 007. Fans similarly may have a knee-jerk reaction against Pattinson in the role thanks to the fact that, in the minds of Bond fans of a certain generation, he’ll always be that sparkly vampire with the big hair from Twilight.

But Pattinson has come a long way since his Twilight days. He’s proven himself to be more than adept at multiple genres, impressing audiences with his intensity in early indie dramas like High Life and Good Time, before he really took it to the next level with his casting as Bruce Wayne in The Batman, which currently has a sequel filming. He’s arguably one of the most prominent male actors of his generation. One need only look at the movies he’s done this year. There were a pair of A24 movies, The Drama and Primetime, both of which showcased his indie chops, with him playing a neurotic lead opposite Zendaya in one and none other than Chris Hansen in the other. He also starred as villains in two tentpole movies, earning arguably better reviews than anyone else in The Odyssey, while he’s about to play a bad guy in Dune Part Three for his future Bond director, Denis Villeneuve.

More than anything, though, there’s his role in Christopher Nolan’s Tenet, which, in hindsight, seems like a test run to play 007. In it, he plays a secret agent and showed himself to be adept at action—in a way that shocked people who knew him only as the emo vampire in Twilight.

The Cons: Why He Might Be Wrong for Bond

The Batman Part II Steven Soderbergh

His success as a leading man might be the biggest reason he shouldn’t play Bond. For one thing, in the past, superstars have never played the part. Don’t get me wrong—they BECOME superstars, but there’s a reason you never had someone like Mel Gibson play James Bond in the eighties or nineties. The idea was always to find someone who wasn’t bigger than the franchise. Times have changed, though, and studios want a sure thing. They’re unlikely to anchor what will be their biggest franchise ever around an unproven lead.

But should the same guy who’s playing Batman also be James Bond? Many identify him as Bruce Wayne. It would be one thing if his Batman movies weren’t successful—but The Batman was a giant hit, and The Batman II seems sure to be one too. That means he’ll have to split his time between the franchises.

While most of us would say, “Who cares?”, the typecasting Pattinson is going to find himself subject to sometimes does a number on an actor. Every single James Bond actor has complained about typecasting. Even Timothy Dalton, who hasn’t played James Bond in 38 years, says he can’t walk into a bar to order a drink without someone asking him if he wants a vodka martini—shaken, not stirred. Being part of two franchises will hurt Pattinson’s ambitions to be a great actor.

And, is he cool enough, or charismatic enough? If you’re casting an actor as James Bond, he has to be charming. Pattinson has never really played a charming character before. Sure, he’s done romance, but in an emo-Twilight way. He’s never really proven himself to be a capable romantic lead in his mature work. If anything, he’s tried to avoid the genre in order to break his Twilight typecasting. He’ll have to be a convincing ladies man as 007.

What Kind of James Bond Would Pattinson Be?

Robert Pattinson, James Bond

Robert Pattinson is tall and lean, but he’s not all that physically formidable—at least not like Sean Connery was. He’s taller than Daniel Craig, but his frame seems smaller. That said, Bond doesn’t need to be huge. One of the reasons James Bond is so dangerous is that he’s smarter than any of his opponents—and Pattinson could become more of a thinking man’s James Bond. We know he can handle action, so he won’t be like Roger Moore towards the end of his run, when he wasn’t even throwing his own punches.

I think, in terms of action, Pattinson will be solid. But will he be a good ladies’ man? Women are attracted to him—they always have been—but he’s more beta than alpha. To be James Bond, Pattinson will need to be more alpha. He doesn’t need to be Sean Connery, but James Bond should be a ladies’ man—otherwise, he’s not James Bond.

Is He Better Than the Alternatives?

007

This is the million-dollar question. In the age of EON, when Barbara Broccoli was running the show, Pattinson would never have been cast—because he’s too big a star. But we live in a different world now, and all the presumed frontrunners—Callum Turner, Jack Lowden, Jacob Elordi and Josh O’Connor—were met with a shrug. Sure, they’re British dudes—although Elordi is Australian—but were they really the best choices? Did they have the charisma to play James Bond?

Of all the candidates, to me, the most intriguing was actually Jack O’Connell, who played the villain in Sinners and had a Connery-esque menace, but he’s maybe not smooth enough. Nicholas Hoult, who was a late contender, might have been really excellent—but facts are facts, and he’s not the presence Pattinson is. I still think Henry Cavill was built to play James Bond—one need only watch him in The Man from U.N.C.L.E. to see that—but Amazon has plans for him already with Highlander and Warhammer. So, of the current crop of actors, yes, Pattinson is better than the alternatives.

Then again, they could have surprised us. Ever since Patrick Stewart died, I’ve been thinking about how unusual a choice he was to play the captain in a Star Trek series. It was outside-the-box casting that worked. Maybe someone more unusual could have made for a better 007? After all, Sean Connery, who was a Scottish bodybuilder-turned-truck driver, was no one’s ideal choice to play 007, and he was perfect. Pattinson is the obvious choice, but did we miss out on someone who, on paper, would have seemed an odd choice to play 007, but in the end would have been iconic?

The Verdict: Would I Cast Him?

Robert Pattinson

Given who he was up against, yes, I think Pattinson was a no-brainer. But I still have some reservations. One thing I don’t like about Pattinson as an actor is how sullen he can be. I find him incredibly sullen as Bruce Wayne—too much, actually. I don’t want a sullen James Bond. Daniel Craig played him that way, and it worked—but now they need to do something different.

If Pattinson plays him the way he played Neil in Tenet, we might really have something. A fun, charismatic James Bond who harkens back to a lighter era in the franchise’s history. The Roger Moore or Pierce Brosnan to Daniel Craig’s Sean Connery. Will it work? We’ll have to wait and see, but Denis Villeneuve is a great director. Has he made a bad movie? I don’t think so—with him behind the camera and all the best technicians Hollywood has to offer, we may well end up with a classic new entry in the franchise.

About the Author

Editor-in-Chief - JoBlo

Favorite Movies: Goodfellas, A Clockwork Orange, Boogie Nights, Goldfinger, Casablanca, Heat, The Guns read more of Navarone, The Dirty Dozen, Pulp Fiction, Taxi Driver, Blade Runner, any film noir

Likes: Movies, LP's, James Bond, true hollywood memoirs, The Bret Easton read more Ellis Podcast, every sixties british pop band, every 80s new wave band - in fact just generally all eighties songs, even the really bad ones, and of course, Tom Cruise!

The comment section exists to allow readers to discuss the article constructively and respectfully, focused on the topic at hand.

What’s Not Allowed

  • Abusive language, insults, or harassment toward other users or staff.
  • Hate speech of any kind is strictly prohibited.
  • Bickering, bullying, personal attacks, or baiting others to argue
  • Extended off-topic debates, especially those centered on politics or religion rather than the article topic
  • No AI content or SPAM