Sherlock Ritchie? | Movie News

Sherlock Ritchie?
Comments: 14
terometer
15%
Strike Back below!
by: Mike Sampson Jun. 4, 2008

Apparently pleased with what he's doing on the awfully titled ROCKNROLLA, Warner Bros. has hired director Guy Ritchie to direct SHERLOCK HOLMES and help relaunch the iconic character. The studio was perhaps less enthused with DOOMSDAY as they had signed with Neil Marshall early last year to direct. Though exact plot details remain under wraps, WB execs look to "reinvent" Holmes as less of a bookworm and more of an ass-kicking, adventure seeking spawn of Indiana Jones and Batman. Ritchie is currently working on a polish of the existing script by Tony Peckham, which was based on an upcoming comic book by Lionel Wigram. Ritchie's return to the top ranks of Hollywood is impressive given that he was virtually written off after the legendary failure of SWEPT AWAY (his follow-up REVOLVER wasn't exactly hot shit either). Somehow Ritchie convinced WB to sign on to ROCKNROLLA (that the studio wanted back in business with 300 star Gerard Butler didn't hurt) and that work led to this big-budget SHERLOCK HOLMES adaptation. No word on when filming might begin but the studio was hot to trot back when Marshall was attached and they've already set a 2010 release so expect this to his the fast track.

Add to MFC Profile
14 discussions Expand all
 
+0
Vote Up Vote Down
Throckmorton
1:37PM on 06/05/2008 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Bad Idea - Leave SH alone
I have to agree with theshadowalker. Jeremy Brett was the definative Holmes in my opinion. I believe you can "re-boot" a francise such as 007 or Batman, but I don't think you should be messing with the character. If you feel like changing Holmes into a kick-ass adventurer, come up with your own freakin' character and don't butcher the classics.
I have to agree with theshadowalker. Jeremy Brett was the definative Holmes in my opinion. I believe you can "re-boot" a francise such as 007 or Batman, but I don't think you should be messing with the character. If you feel like changing Holmes into a kick-ass adventurer, come up with your own freakin' character and don't butcher the classics.
 
+0
Vote Up Vote Down
Kill Billionair
6:09AM on 06/05/2008 Add as a friend | MFC profile
I don't get why Revolver isn't seen as hot shit. It most definetely is piping hot manure in my book.

I think it's right up there with Lock, Stock and Snatch.
I don't get why Revolver isn't seen as hot shit. It most definetely is piping hot manure in my book.

I think it's right up there with Lock, Stock and Snatch.
 
+0
Vote Up Vote Down
BlakeRom
4:41AM on 06/05/2008 Add as a friend | MFC profile
polished
great. just go ahead and cast jason statham already.
great. just go ahead and cast jason statham already.
 
+0
Vote Up Vote Down
Derrida
2:51AM on 06/05/2008 Add as a friend | MFC profile
What a terrible idea...
Guy Ritchie is the British McG - nuff said...
Guy Ritchie is the British McG - nuff said...
 
+0
Vote Up Vote Down
anomaly7
8:48PM on 06/04/2008 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Are you kidding me
Make Holmes less of a book worm and more of an adventurer?



What a great idea. It worked out so well for Van Helsing.
Make Holmes less of a book worm and more of an adventurer?



What a great idea. It worked out so well for Van Helsing.
 
+0
Vote Up Vote Down
Crimson_Kahuna
8:30PM on 06/04/2008 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Well...
... it could be very good if they made it a realistic dark, dirty, and gritty period piece. Keep the morphine habit for sure. Show real violence, with knives, swords, big unweildy single shot pistols. Horse & carriage chases could work. The more realistic the better, so no overblown special effects or stunts, and show the carnage and injury. Needs to have good costuming, props, and sets...
... it could be very good if they made it a realistic dark, dirty, and gritty period piece. Keep the morphine habit for sure. Show real violence, with knives, swords, big unweildy single shot pistols. Horse & carriage chases could work. The more realistic the better, so no overblown special effects or stunts, and show the carnage and injury. Needs to have good costuming, props, and sets that look weathered and lived in.



The key in my mind would be for them to try to get across that just living during that time period was harsh and fucking dangerous, doubly so if you were poor.



There's my recipe for a good Sherlock Holmes movie. Quite elemantary, but if they stear it toward Van Helsing territory then I'll have to skip it.
 
+0
Vote Up Vote Down
lalex81
7:14PM on 06/04/2008 Add as a friend | MFC profile
There's bad ideas and then there's [link] ideas.



There are so many great directors out there for a project like this:



Christopher Nolan, Tom Tykwer, Alfonso Cuaron, Andrew Dominik, Alejandro Amenabar even the Coen's would be an inspired choice...not Guy Ritchie
There's bad ideas and then there's [link] ideas.



There are so many great directors out there for a project like this:



Christopher Nolan, Tom Tykwer, Alfonso Cuaron, Andrew Dominik, Alejandro Amenabar even the Coen's would be an inspired choice...not Guy Ritchie
 
+0
Vote Up Vote Down
AaronisMe
6:52PM on 06/04/2008 Add as a friend | MFC profile
If they want to modernize him or make him cooler, just make a Psych movie. I'd see that, Shawn and Gus are the modern Holmes and Watson. And they're funny as hell. Black and Tan forever!
If they want to modernize him or make him cooler, just make a Psych movie. I'd see that, Shawn and Gus are the modern Holmes and Watson. And they're funny as hell. Black and Tan forever!
 
+0
Vote Up Vote Down
DroopMasterD
4:27PM on 06/04/2008 Add as a friend | MFC profile
im not sure how is feel bout this whole re imagining thing hollywood has going on right now....i mean i would love to see a movie bout sherlock holmes but if they are gonna modernize him or make him a bad ass action star than no thank you
im not sure how is feel bout this whole re imagining thing hollywood has going on right now....i mean i would love to see a movie bout sherlock holmes but if they are gonna modernize him or make him a bad ass action star than no thank you
 
+0
Vote Up Vote Down
theshadowalker
2:02PM on 06/04/2008 Add as a friend | MFC profile
No. No. No. No. No. No. No.


Holmes is fine as is, thank you very much. He doesn't need to be reimagined or rewhatevered.



If you have to make a new Holmes movie, then do so (although Jeremy Brett's going to be a difficult, if not impossible, act to follow); but don't change Holmes himself (although he's always been a decent boxer, and not adverse to some adventure...but he's certainly not Batman).


Holmes is fine as is, thank you very much. He doesn't need to be reimagined or rewhatevered.



If you have to make a new Holmes movie, then do so (although Jeremy Brett's going to be a difficult, if not impossible, act to follow); but don't change Holmes himself (although he's always been a decent boxer, and not adverse to some adventure...but he's certainly not Batman).
 
+0
Vote Up Vote Down
numberFIVE
11:57AM on 06/04/2008 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Don't Mess With The Holmes
"Revolver" wasn't terrible (though I figured out the endgame within minutes), but I think Ritchie's talent 86 won't go away until he has sex with an attractive woman again.
"Revolver" wasn't terrible (though I figured out the endgame within minutes), but I think Ritchie's talent 86 won't go away until he has sex with an attractive woman again.
 
+0
Vote Up Vote Down
JamminD
11:39AM on 06/04/2008 Add as a friend | MFC profile
I think reinventing Sherlock Holmes is a good idea...if it's done right. I think Guy Richie has the potential to make it quality, but "less of a bookworm and more of an ass-kicking, adventure seeking spawn of Indiana Jones and Batman" ruins absolutely everything about Sherlock Holmes. He is a bookworm!! a genius bookworm that solves stuff, not looking to avenge his parents and stop injustice or...
I think reinventing Sherlock Holmes is a good idea...if it's done right. I think Guy Richie has the potential to make it quality, but "less of a bookworm and more of an ass-kicking, adventure seeking spawn of Indiana Jones and Batman" ruins absolutely everything about Sherlock Holmes. He is a bookworm!! a genius bookworm that solves stuff, not looking to avenge his parents and stop injustice or go running about jungles finding lost treasures. Make it like the classics with thought and detail in it, not an adventure film!
 
+0
Vote Up Vote Down
zaika
11:22AM on 06/04/2008 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Ripping my heart out
First of all...I seriously doubt anybody Under 30 in North America have read Sherlock Holmes.

The most this movie can hope for is surpassing "The Count of Monte Cristo"



Stop fucking with classics!!!!!



(Word to the producers: There are no ninjas or big explosions in "Hound of Baskerville")
First of all...I seriously doubt anybody Under 30 in North America have read Sherlock Holmes.

The most this movie can hope for is surpassing "The Count of Monte Cristo"



Stop fucking with classics!!!!!



(Word to the producers: There are no ninjas or big explosions in "Hound of Baskerville")
 
+0
Vote Up Vote Down
McClane Maniac
9:00AM on 06/04/2008 Add as a friend | MFC profile
Jason Statham as Sherlock????
I really hope not! Imagine it 'Faaaaarrrckin 'ell Watson, it's Moriarty you farrrrrcckin caarnt'!

I really hope not! Imagine it 'Faaaaarrrckin 'ell Watson, it's Moriarty you farrrrrcckin caarnt'!