Face-Off: Deadpool vs. Deadpool 2

Last Updated on October 12, 2021

Nice to see you again, fans of the cinema! This is the Face-Off, where two movies enter and both movies leave, but one leaves in a slightly better light. Yes, here we take two competitors and compare their key elements and see who comes out the champion. It's a fierce competition that results in blood, tears, and online arguments, but the more brutal the battle, the sweeter the victory.

This last weekend saw the latest movie come out in the "R-rated superhero movie" canon, HELLBOY, and the response has been, er, not so great. The over-reliance on gore and profanity proved worse given the lack of heart and strong story elements, which proved that just because your movie is embracing the more adult rating doesn't mean it will be the next LOGAN. While other movies are trying to capitalize on more adult themes, we mustn't forget the character that started it all not too long ago, so that means for this Face-Off we will be taking a look at the current king of the R-rated superhero movie, Deadpool, and his two wildly successful outings — DEADPOOL and DEADPOOL 2. If you're going to chop off limbs and be all sorts of depraved and expect people to pay and watch, you have to do it with a little style.  

The first DEADPOOL movie was a bit of a gamble, relying on the strong fanbase behind the fourth-wall-breaking character and the leading actor, Ryan Reynolds. Thanks to a genius marketing campaign that took advantage of the internet and the movie's irreverent sense of humor, DEADPOOL was a massive success right out of the gate that proved both a game changer and an instant money maker.  A sequel was quickly put into development, and two years later DEADPOOL 2 came along to prove the first movie wasn't a fluke, making almost the exact same amount of money globally and getting the same critical praise. Deadpool is here to stay, which is equal parts frightening and exciting. 

However, which R-rated blockbuster has what it takes to come out on top? Which has the biggest load of awesomeness that's too good to deny? Which movie is the one that would make Scoutmaster Kevin the proudest? Find out below, and be sure to bring some tissues. What? Because of the tearjerking moments, you degenerates!

The Losers Club

Ryan Reynolds as Wade Wilson/Deadpool
Morena Baccarin as Vanessa
T.J. Miller as Weasel
Ed Skrein as Francis/Ajax
Brianna Hildebrand as Negasonic Teenage Warhead
Stefan Kapicic as Colossus
Gina Carano as Angel Dust
Karan Soni as Dopinder
Leslie Uggams as Blind Al

Ryan Reynolds as Wade Wilson/Deadpool
Josh Brolin as Cable
Zazie Beetz as Domino
Julian Dennison as Russell Collins/Firefist
Morena Baccarin as Vanessa
T.J. Miller as Weasel
Brianna Hildebrand as Negasonic Teenage Warhead
Stefan Kapicic as Colossus
Karan Soni as Dopinder
Leslie Uggams as Blind Al

The Dude Calling the Shots

While everyone is bestowing much of the praise for DEADPOOL's success on Ryan Reynolds for inhabiting the role and the writers for bringing out his voice, just as much credit needs to go to director Tim Miller for working within the confines of a small budget (for a mainstream comic book movie) to effectively showcase all of the leading character's many, many gorgeous talents. As for that budget,  the team didn't have as much to work with compared to their other X-Men pals, but Miller makes it work by filming all around the key, small action set pieces to give them their own distinct Deadpool flavor. Take the bridge piece for instance. A rather small location for a crash-em-up, shoot-em-up set piece, but thanks to Miller's ingenuity and understanding of the character he gives it serious breadth and style by switching things up as the kills and moments progress. Given how much time is spent on the road, Miller almost makes it feel like a play, making use of every angle, spot and the characters within it. Same goes for lots of scenes in the movie, like the "medical facility" where DP is tortured, the shipping yard, etc. But what really makes these scenes work, as well as any other featuring the lead character, is he makes up for lack of budget with Reynolds himself. Moreso than in the sequel, there are scenes where not much is going on so Miller just lingers on his leading man as he steps into Pool's disease-ridden shoes and just becomes the character. That's just as entertaining as any expensive set piece, and a testament to a director with a true understanding of the character, the movie they were making and how to do more with less.

It's unfortunate that Tim Miller separated from the sequel, as I would've loved to see how he handled the doubled budget and more characters from the comics. But whatever happened happened, and thus Fox went with co-JOHN WICK director David Leitch to bring DP back for more bloody, inappropriate shenanigans. Right out of the gate, this means the action scenes were always going to be top-notch, given Leitch's expertise in the field, and the man didn't disappoint. The director knows his way around an action scene, and he was able to mix in the sleeker, faster, harder action with the movie's sense of humor. The fight in the prison between DP and Cable is as exciting as any big-budget fight, but also bursts with humor – like when DP crashes onto a table and his top and bottom half all but separate from each other, or when DP fights off a gang of orderlies with just a lone brick, while Cable gets all the guns. Leitch brought his visceral eye to DP2, and while not the neon burst fest of WICK, gives DP a more polished, dark, richly-detailed look brings the character into the fold without diminishing the character's playfulness. But on that note, what stops Leitch from all-out winning this bout is that while he makes up for this in action stupendousness, he doesn't give DP the same air to breathe as Miller did in the first movie, which is a bit of a shame. Granted, there are far more characters to cram in and big scenes to get through, DP doesn't have the same room to just be himself as he does in the first.

The Holy Text

To give you just a taste of how long this first movie was in some stage of development, Rhett Reese and Paul Wernick were brought on to write the script for DEADPOOL back in 2010. Through production halts and nigh-hopelessness, they persevered as real heroes do, and constantly updated the script up until it was finally made. With a smaller production budget that continued to shrink even as pre-production was kicking off, the writers (working closely with Reynolds) used that as an opportunity to focus more on the character, his journey, and find clever ways to work around action, as well as fun ways to include X-Men characters like Colossus and Negasonic Teenage Warhead. This focus on the title character and his struggle to be cured of his powers and disfigurement, all so he can try and get back with the woman he loves, give the movie a sweet, heartfelt, nougaty center. As foul-mouthed and deranged as DP is there's an emotional core that drives him. Putting all that stuff aside for a minute, the movie is just endlessly, constantly hysterical and the writers found hilarious, sometimes shocking ways of subverting the genre and carving out this movie's own place within the crowded superhero slate. There is a seemingly limitless supply of meta jokes they came up with that poke fun at the genre and pop culture as a whole, including the lead actor himself, bringing to life that self-aware, irreverent humor Deadpool comic fans know and cherish. All in all, this script is as tight as Deadpool in those jammies of his, pairing a story that showcases the heart underneath the ugly, avocado-esque exterior with the foulest mouth in the superhero world (move over, Groot).

This time with Reynolds getting a credit, Reese and Wernick were back on scripting duties for the sequel, and thankfully all the crude gags and meta references were in-tact. More importantly, the heart of the first story is also safe and sound, with the death of Vanessa driving Pool to find a true family to fill the void. It's the perfect story to continue the character's arc with – even if the presence of Vanessa is missed when not in the "Afterlife" sequences. But however sweet the story is, it can't help but feel a bit muddled in all the additional spectacle and characters coming into play. Yes, the inclusion of Cable, whose journey it is to stop the death of his own family by going back in time and hunting down a child a la THE TERMINATOR plays into the theme of family, but as a result I don't think Wade/Deadpool's arc is as strong or focused this time around. I do like the idea of Wade having to find his "F-word", but it's born out of a journey the spirit of Vanessa sends him on, which makes it feel like he's just going through the motions until he finds the meaning behind it all. It's a heartfelt story, to be sure, and the execution is solid, but it's bogged down by so many other elements. The first movie's story is a bit more grounded and lean, focused on Wade's own tragic motivations for hunting down the bad guy, and in the end, forms the foundations of who he's meant to be as a newly-minted superhero.

Hunk in the Red Mask

Ryan Reynolds had this character in his blood and bones for well over a decade before cameras started rolling, and in that time had gotten to know the character inside and out. On top of that knowledge, he's just a perfect fit for the role, proving insanely funny as both in movies and real life, having the same kind of playful, almost cartoonish sense of humor his character does. There's a sweetness to him as well that makes Pool so relatable, and if you take that big gumbo of qualities you have the perfect actor to bring the Merc With a Mouth to life. He so effortlessly exudes the character's absurd silliness and quick transitions into firey, blood-soaked rage, and also fires off profanities as if his first words were "cock" and "sucker".  But that sweetness does shine through in buckets, and the charming side of him comes through when he's near Vanessa, the only person who can tear his guarded walls down and bring out the man he really is. That chemistry he has with her really sold his performance beyond the F-bombs and further proves why he belongs among the ranks of Christopher Reeve, Robert Downey Jr. and a certain Australian dude who got lucky as an actor who may well be the best person to ever put on a beloved character's costume.

We already knew Reynolds would hit it out of the park again with DP2, simply because we knew the character was part of his DNA at this point. But one of the biggest surprises I get while watching the sequel is seeing just how much further he's able to take the character this time around. He's got the jokes and strange side of the character down pat, but here he's able to explore his emotional complexity even more after losing Vanessa. Here's a man who finally seems to have everything figured out, but soon he loses everything he's ever fought for, and something he may never get to experience again. Reynolds has always had underrated dramatic chops, and here he gets to showcase even more heartbreaking areas of the Merc, especially at the beginning and end. He took a relatively unknown character and made him a likeable hit around the world with first movie, and in the sequel turned him into one we could fall in love with on a deeper level.

Best Naughty Bits & Lines

Bits:

Opening Credits

First Wall Break

Vehicular Takedown

12-Bullet Takedown

Wade at Work

Wade and Vanessa

Happy Holidays

The Gasp

Deadpool "vs." Colossus

Arm Chop!

Wade's Transformation

Fire Fighters

Superhero Montage

Big Al

X-Team Assembled

Superhero Landing

Colossus Down; Negasonic Unleashed

DP in Action

Colossus vs. Angel

DP vs. Francis

Cartoon Character's On the Brain

DP Makes His Choice

Hugh Jackman Mask

Lovers Reunited

Bueller End Credits

Lines:

Deadpool: "Tell me where your fucking boss is or you're going to die! In five minutes!"

—–

Deadpool: You're probably thinking, "Whose balls did I have to fondle to get my very own movie"? I can't tell you his name, but it rhymes with "Polverine." And let me tell you, he's got a nice pair of smooth criminals down under."

—–

Deadpool: "Time to make the chimi-fuckin'-changas."

—–

Wade: "I had another Liam Neeson nightmare. I kidnapped his daughter and he just wasn't having it. They made three of those movies. At some point you have to wonder if he's just a bad parent."

—–

Deadpool: "Looks ARE everything! Ever heard Dave Beckham speak? It's like he mouth-sexed a can of helium. You think Ryan Reynolds got this far on a superior acting method?"

—–

Deadpool: "I'm gonna wait out here, okay? It's a big house. It's funny that I only ever see two of you. It's almost like the studio couldn't afford another X-Man."

—–

Deadpool: "Finish fucking her the fuck up!"
Colossus: "Language, please."
Deadpool: "Suck a cock!"

—–

Deadpool: "You're probably thinking, "My boyfriend said this was a superhero movie but that guy in the suit just turned that other guy into a fucking kabab!"

—–

Deadpool: "Ripley, from Alien 3!"
Negasonic Teenage Warhead: "Fuck, you're old."
Deadpool: "Fake laugh. Hiding real pain. Go get Silver Balls."

—–

Colossus: You will come talk with Professor Xavier.
Deadpool: McAvoy or Stewart? These timelines can get so confusing.

—–

Deadpool: "All dinosaurs feared the T-Rex!"

—–

Weasel: "You look like an avocado had sex with an older, more disgusting avocado…Not gently. Like it was hate-fucking. There was something wrong with the relationship and that was the only catharsis that they could find without violence."

—–

Deadpool: "Maximum effort."

—–

Deadpool: "Wait! You may be wondering, "Why the red suit?" Well, that's so bad guys can't see me bleed…This guy's got the right idea. he wore the brown pants."

—–

Deadpool: Bad Deadpool! [shoots guy] Good Deadpool.

—–

Recruiter: What if I told you we can cure your cancer? And what's more, give you abilities most mean only dream of?
Wade: I'd say that you sound like an infomercial, but not a good one, like Slap Chop. More Shake Weight-y.

—–

Wade: "Your right leg is Thanksgiving and your left leg is Christmas. Can I come and visit you between the holidays?"

—–

Deadpool: [unknowingly grabbing Colossus' junk] "Dad?"

Bits:

DP Goes Boom

Opening Credits with Celine Dion

Deadpool's 9 to 5

Vanessa's Death

Return of Blind Al

Heaven with Vanessa

X-Mansion

X-Men Cameo

Meet Firefist

Prison Life

Cable Attacks

Cable vs. DP

Assembling the Team

Jump Gone Wrong

Brad Pitt

Lucky Domino

Cable v. Domino

DP's Twisting Blades

Juggernaut Rips DP

DP Goes Full Donald Duck

Group Car Ride

Taking Juggernaut

Colossus vs. Juggernaut

DP and Cable vs. Pervert Orderlies

Deadpool Dies

Re-Do

Dopinder's First Kill

End Scenes

Lines:

Cable: Dubstep's for pussies!
Wade: You're so dark. Are you sure you're not from the DC universe?

—–

Deadpool: "Zip it, Thanos!"

—–

Cable: "There's nothing I can't kill."
Deadpool: "Well, as Scoutmaster Kevin used to say… 'There's a first time for everything,son.' Give me your best shot, One-Eyed Willy."

—–

Wade: "You're right. I was fighting a caped badass, but then we discovered that his mom is named Martha, too."

—–

Wade: "With this collar on, my superpower is just unbridled cancer. Give me a bow and arrow and I'm basically Hawkeye."

—–

Cable: "Who are you?"
Wade: "I'm Batman."

—–

Cable: "I'm retrieving something from my utility bag."
Weasel: "It's a goddamn fanny pack and you know it, you sick son of a bitch! The difference is night and day."

—–

Cable: "I use a device to slide through time. The longer I travel, the harder it is to control. I got two charges: One to get me here, one to get me home."
Wade: [looks at the camera] "Well, that's just lazy writing."

—–

Firefist: "Stay back or Justin Bieber dies!"
Deadpool: "Ha! Justin Bieber. He called you Justin Bieber."

—–

Deadpool: "You killed Black Tom, you racist son of a bitch!"

—–

Juggernaut: "I'm gonna rip you in half now."
Deadpool: "That is such a Juggernaut thing to say!"

—–

Deadpool: "Only best buddies execute pedophiles together."

—–

Deadpool: "Well, I'm not even going to attempt that. But I did take eighth grade Spanish, so 'donde esta la biblioteca?' Which literally translates to: 'I don't bargain, pumpkin-fucker.'"

—–

Cable: "Here's a spoiler alert. You're not a fucking hero. You're just an annoying clown dressed up as a sex toy."

—–

 

Laughs for the Whole Family

From the very first moment we see Deadpool, with him messing around in the back of Dopinder's cab to one of the final moments with a picture of Hugh Jackman stapled to his face, this movie is miraculosuly always funny thanks to the title character. Dishing out a buffet of one-liners that work as either witty observations, hysterical references or just wild crassness, everything out of his mouth is wildly hilarious from start to finish. Immense shout outs go to the writers and Reynolds who go balls out with the humor, never being afraid to be completely politically incorrect or deranged. You can throw a pebble and hit a classic line in this movie that will be quoted until the end of days. A big reason for this goes back to points I've made before, which is that the entirety of the movie rests on its greatest weapon — Deadpool himself. Just put the camera in front of Reynolds and let him work and you'll get something hysterical out of it. The way he moves and interacts with things is almost as funny as the lines themselves, and it's no wonder this movie — and the sequel — are two of the most endlessly entertaining movies in the genre.

Much of the humor that was in the last one comes right on over for the sequel, including all the meta gags and crudeness we loved from before. Deadpool is gleefully profane, and sometimes just flat-out adorable, which makes these movies incredibly easy to wet yourself laughing to. This time around there's some added comedy relief, thanks in part to the total deadpan work of Josh Brolin, who nails his funny bits with total serious delivery to juxtapose Pool's zaniness. The two work wonderfully together, and this movie is a perfect advertisement for a buddy road movie starring the dup. If the movie "loses" this category, I would say it's because that, while being uproariously funny, there's something about the jokes that make them not hit as hard as in the previous movie. Maybe it's all the spectacle taking up more time, or the heavier use of meta references to past movies in the superhero genre, but the gags feel a bit blunter and quickly dished out. They just don't linger as long and have as much power. Granted, while both of these movies are funnier than most straight-up comedies, the first one gets a few more points over this one. 

Sweet, Sweet Murder & Action

The first DEADPOOL had a lower budget, a move planned by Fox given that a movie like this had never really been done before on this scale. This meant some less-polished CG work and action scenes restircted to some simple locations, but as said before, Tim Miller made it work wonderfully. The action is slick and Deadpool moves like the least-silent but most badass ninja who ever lived, slicing and dicing and bathing in the blood of his victims — no matter their race, sex or cultural background. But this outing is more about the character than the action and gore, even if it does embrace as much of both of those as it can. 

The budget doubled, and thus the action doubled. The movie moves like a big action movie in ways the first one simply couldn't, but instead of falling for the "bigger but uglier" trap some sequels do, David Leitch knows how to craft a superb action scene and gives Deadpool more polished sense of finesse during combat scenes, and takes the bigger set pieces up a notch in incredibly gory fashion. The gratuitous blood comes in buckets and is even more awesomely disgusting than the last movie, like when Juggernaut rips Deadpool in half, the blood deep red and guts falling out. But it's still all playful, which stops it from being demented without a sense of fun. Overall, DP2 is an excellent example of how going much bigger can be done right as long as you stick with the tone of the character and don't simply try to destroy more and more cities.

Obviously the Most Important Stuff

Awards:

Golden Globes:

Nominee:

  • Best Motion Picture – Musical or Comedy
  • Best Actor, Motion Picture Musical or Comedy – Ryan Reynolds

Golden Schmoes:

Winner:

  • Favorite Movie
  • Best Screenplay : Rhett Reese, Paul Wernick
  • Best Comedy
  • Biggest Surprise
  • Best Actor: Ryan Reynolds
  • Coolest Character: Ryan Reynolds

Nominee:

  • Most Overrated Movie
  • Best Music
  • Favorite Movie Poster
  • Best DVD/Blu-ray
  • Best Action Scene: "Highway Shootout"
  • Most Memorable Scene: Opening Sequence
  • Best Trailer
  • Best Line: "Time to make the chimi-fucking-changas

**Another 22 Wins & 66 Nominations per IMDb**

 

Praise:

Rotten Tomatoes: 84% (90% Audience Score)

Metacritic: 65 (8.1 Audience)

IMDb: 8.0

 

Money:

$363 million ($783 million globally)

Awards:

Golden Schmoes:

Winner:

  • Best Comedy

Nominee:

  • Favorite Movie Poster
  • Best DVD/Blu-ray
  • Coolest Character: Cable

**Another 2 Wins & 34 Nominations per IMDb**

 

Praise:

Rotten Tomatoes: 83% (84% Audience Score)

Metacritic: 66 (7.7 Audience)

IMDb: 7.8

 

Money:

$324 million ($785 million globally)

Lovie-Dovie Stuff

As Deadpool says near the beginning of the movie while a man is impaled on his katanas: This is a love story. Wade Wilson, a mercenary with a big mouth (Ooooh, that's where they get it) finds a woman, Vanessa, who can match him in the wit, charm, sex and depravity arenas. Their relationship is pure and relatable even as they have sex on top of a turkey dinner, and Reynolds and Baccarin have an undeniable chemistry that could put a smile on the most stone-hearted individual. It's easy to forget this underneath the crude gags and splashes of blood, but truly, what moves this movie forward it's Wade's undying love for Vanessa, and his whole arc is built around trying to cure himself so he can get back to her, thinking she won't love him given what he's become. While laced with some monster movie elements and placed in a debaucherous action flick, the core of the movie is pure rom-com, with the protagonist afraid the perfect woman won't love him for what's on the surface, but in the end she tells him none of that matters, and that his filthy mind and big heart are what she fell in love with it. It's basically JERRY MAGUIRE, but with a few more dick jokes.

At the start of DP2, tragedy befalls Wade when his lady love is killed by the men who he tried to kill previously, sending him down a spiral of regret and misery. While this could've fueled the kind of revenge story the likes of which Liam Neeson is best suited for, instead we find our lead trying to do what he can to be with her in the afterlife, which he can't do until he helps the young Russell, and thus discover something about himself. There are some incredibly sad and moving moments in DP2 (the final moment between them at the end is heartbreaking) but these big moments are scattered, and make up for the lack of Vanessa in the actual plot. The emotional core that motivated the first movie isn't as strong in this one as a result, and while that sweetness and heart are still there, the love story that defines much of who Wade Wilson is in these movies is more defined and meaningful the first time around.

Musical Magic

Tom Holkenberg a.k.a. Junkie XL (or is it the other way around?) was brought on to work on the score just when he was starting to break into the mainstream thanks to movies like MAD MAX: FURY ROAD. Deadpool is a character known for pop culture references that pull from decades past, namely the 80s, and particularly enjoys music from the era like Wham!, so XL took that into account and created a synth-heavy score that pulls from the decade but feels incredibly fresh and exhilarating. Primarily, the pieces highlight the manic energy and fast-paced action and personality of the character, such as the "Twelve Bullets" piece that plays during the highway shootout. But then you have the grand, sweeping orchestration pieces which XL says are meant to pay homage to the music from past X-Men movies, as a way of showing that this movie comes from a long line of mutant movies. Overall, XL has been likened to modern Hans Zimmer music for his use of heavy, unrelenting percussions and tones, but this is perhaps his most fun score to listen to, given how he tried to relate the score back to the title character.

Much like Michael Giacchino, Tyler Bates has become a top go-to name for many blockbuster movie scores, having worked with Marvel Studios in the past on scores for THOR: THE DARK WORLD, GUARDIANS OF THE GALAXY and more. Here, he gives a more traditional superhero sound to DP2, filled with lots of big orchestrations that keep the action moving briskly, and often times, hysterically. He uses that classic operatic chorus work that has been overworked to death in blockbusters and flips it on its head, having them sing for pieces like "You Can't Stop This Motherf*****" and "Holy S*** Balls" which are perfect accent pieces when Juggernaut comes running on the screen. It's a fun play on the standard kind of music that plays over superhero movies, but it does get a tad bit familiar after a while, and though it's a great collection of music, XL's does a much better job of giving the character an original sound.

Numero Uno

They say you'll never forget your first time, but DP2 is proof that not enough credit is given to what comes next. Here is a sequel that could've easily succumbed to the pitfall of going bigger in all the wrong places, proving that the first movie was a singular outing that could never be topped. But that wasn't the case, and here is a sequel that lives up to much of what the first movie delivered and going bigger and bolder in spots the first simply couldn't because, you know, money. The blood is more bountiful, the action is bigger and the impressive ensemble is up to the task. But that first time was not only the most special because it was the first time: DEADPOOL is truly a fantastic movie that's smaller in scope but no less hysterical, and makes up for the lack of major action set pieces with more focused character development, heart and strong moments with the title character. Had this been the only Deadpool movie we got that would've been fine. The story is heartfelt and gives the character an emotional core to relate too, and then fleshes out the rest of him with endless profanity and sexual deviancy. More than the sequel, this movie does more to set itself apart from the others in the genre and brought the damn roof down in the process. It's a perfect adaptation of the character and a masterful showcase for what the comic book movie genre can do when it lets loose and goes balls out, sometimes literally. 

About the Author

3750 Articles Published