Latest Entertainment News Headlines

Berardinelli's top 10

12.29.2009
100%

We normally like bringing you our own thoughts on the best and worst goings on in the world of film, but every so often, we want to give you an outside voice for a bit of a change of pace.

Reelviews’ James Berardinelli is one of our favorite critics here at JoBlo, outside of Ebert and our own talented staff, and he’s come out with his top 10 of the year in a list that I have to say, looks awfully similar to my own. Check it out below:

10. A Serious Man: There may be no 2009 title that has caused more consternation and puzzlement than the Coen Brothers' A Serious Man. I have given a talk about the film and I still don't claim to have a handle on everything. Still, full comprehension doesn't matter; as long as there's recognition that the movie is following a template based on "The Book of Job," it's clear enough. The movie isn't just quirky and thought-provoking , it's humorous in a way that only a Coen Brothers film can be humorous.

9. An Education: The great strength of An Education is Carey Mulligan's performance, but this movie has a lot more going for it than just the ability of the lead actress. It's a well-developed character drama that generates strong viewer sympathy for Jenny. We relate to her in ways we often don't relate to screen personalities. The supporting cast, which includes the likes of Peter Sarsgaard, Alfred Molia, Emma Thompson, and Sally Hawkins - is top-flight and the Nick Hornby screenplay is as smart as one would expect from a writer of his pedigree. A real treat.

8. Precious: Ultimately, Precious wants to be uplifting, but I'm not sure the "hopeful" note it employs at the end overcomes the two hours of misery to precede it. In part because of its bleakness, however, this is a powerful film. It sugar-coats nothing. One of my problems with too many inspirational films, like The Blind Side and Invictus, is the inherent blandness. They gloss over the ugliness to amplify the crowd-pleasing elements. Precious does the opposite. It provides two strong performances that generate memorable characters and leaves a forceful imprint. One doesn't have to enjoy a movie to be moved by it, and that summarizes my reaction to Precious.

7. District 9: One of the best science fiction films of 2009, District 9 is as allegorical as a movie can get, and all the more effective because of it. The premise is unique - the aliens come to Earth, but things don't go as one expects when a spaceship enters geo-synchronous orbit. The final third, as has been pointed out, is the film's Achilles heel, but it nevertheless offers some effective action sequences. The worstmoments of District 9 are better than the best moments of Transformers: Revenge of the Fallen.

6. (500) Days of Summer: (500) Days of Summer has been referred to as the "romantic comedy for those who don't like romantic comedies," and I understand why. The movie contains many of the familiar rom-com beats, but they are jumbled out-of-order and the Happily Ever After ending never happens, at least not until Autumn. The lead performances (Joseph Gordon Levitt, Zooey Deschanel) are wonderful and the actors connect in precisely the manner the director needs them to. The screenplay is witty and emotionally honest. A great double feature with Adventureland.

To see 5-1, head over to Reelviews, as we're out of space here. I agree with most of those, except his #4, which for the life of me I can’t understand why it’s showing up in so many of these lists.

Extra Tidbit: My number one is waffling between STAR TREK, 500 DAYS and AVATAR.
Source: Reelviews

RECOMMENDED MOVIE NEWS

MORE FUN FROM AROUND THE WEB

Strikeback
Not registered? Sign-up!
Or

+0
8:35AM on 12/30/2009

yeah adventureland

really cmon
i was excited about it and was dissapointed

not the worst of the year glad basterds is getting all the buzz it is deserves oscar noms for pic dir screen play supp actor

i need to see avatar
really cmon
i was excited about it and was dissapointed

not the worst of the year glad basterds is getting all the buzz it is deserves oscar noms for pic dir screen play supp actor

i need to see avatar
Your Reply:



Please email me when someone replies to my comment
2:55PM on 12/29/2009

"Precious"- Really? WTF?

How in the hell is everyone, everywhere falling for this turd of a film? Seriously, Gabbie in the lead role is as bland as can be, and doesn't really emote. Mariah Carrey does decent in her all of 5 minutes of screentime, but 5 minutes is hardly worth any talk of awards, and she is simply decent nothing more. Mo'Nique doesn't act, she emotes, which is entirely different. She is simply either angry, and then at the end, sad. Crying on screen does not make you a good actress, and she's easily the
How in the hell is everyone, everywhere falling for this turd of a film? Seriously, Gabbie in the lead role is as bland as can be, and doesn't really emote. Mariah Carrey does decent in her all of 5 minutes of screentime, but 5 minutes is hardly worth any talk of awards, and she is simply decent nothing more. Mo'Nique doesn't act, she emotes, which is entirely different. She is simply either angry, and then at the end, sad. Crying on screen does not make you a good actress, and she's easily the worst of the bunch here. Paula Patton on the other hand does do an excellent job, although she has no character growth, nor do any of the characters for that matter.

Lee Daniels, the director, has the music turned up to 12, and it overpowers whatever weight those scenes had. The dream life of Precious was awkwardly done, and too muted. Some of the editing choices were truly god awful, and made no sense; why did we linger on the side of a building after the characters left the scene for 5 seconds? Who the fuck knows?

Not only is Precious the most overhyped movie of this year, it's also one of the most of the decade, and one of the worst of the year. Shame on everyone for falling for it.
Your Reply:



Please email me when someone replies to my comment
4:02PM on 12/29/2009
Couldn't have said it better myself. It's ridiculous uppity white moviegoers fall for shit like this and "Crash"
Couldn't have said it better myself. It's ridiculous uppity white moviegoers fall for shit like this and "Crash"
2:20PM on 12/29/2009
berardinelli is my favorite critic.. I find myself agreeing with him more than any other professional reviewer. his list for 2009 is very similar to mine..
berardinelli is my favorite critic.. I find myself agreeing with him more than any other professional reviewer. his list for 2009 is very similar to mine..
Your Reply:



Please email me when someone replies to my comment
2:07PM on 12/29/2009
Great list, Adventureland included.
Great list, Adventureland included.
Your Reply:



Please email me when someone replies to my comment
12:01PM on 12/29/2009
Berardinelli has always been one of my favorites, and his top 10 for this year is a great list.
Berardinelli has always been one of my favorites, and his top 10 for this year is a great list.
Your Reply:



Please email me when someone replies to my comment
11:56AM on 12/29/2009

Hmm

I've never liked Berardinelli's writing. I find it relatively generic and, to me, even after all these years, he's never developed a distinctly personal style of writing. That being said, this isn't a bad list. I liked "Adventureland," btw.
I've never liked Berardinelli's writing. I find it relatively generic and, to me, even after all these years, he's never developed a distinctly personal style of writing. That being said, this isn't a bad list. I liked "Adventureland," btw.
Your Reply:



Please email me when someone replies to my comment
11:40AM on 12/29/2009
I hated Adventureland. Something just wasn't right with Ryan Reynolds making out with Kristen Stewart...Other than that, not a bad list.
I hated Adventureland. Something just wasn't right with Ryan Reynolds making out with Kristen Stewart...Other than that, not a bad list.
Your Reply:



Please email me when someone replies to my comment
12:39AM on 12/31/2009
Agreed. Except on Avatar. Haven't seen it and after 2 MEH reviews read here and even Arrow's 3 out of 4 rating...I can't help but think, "wow, this really may not be worth my $15 bucks."
Agreed. Except on Avatar. Haven't seen it and after 2 MEH reviews read here and even Arrow's 3 out of 4 rating...I can't help but think, "wow, this really may not be worth my $15 bucks."
View All Comments

Latest Entertainment News Headlines


Top
Loading...

Featured Youtube Videos

Views and Counting